Clinically Vulnerable Families 💙💜💗 Profile picture
Dec 3 11 tweets 4 min read Read on X
A letter just landed on Baroness Hallett’s desk from CATA (Covid Airborne Transmission Alliance).

If you are a patient, an NHS worker, or Clinically Vulnerable... or you want to see safety measures updated - you need to see this!

1/
The Covid Inquiry is there to help us to learn lessons and change how we plan for pandemics.

But, NHS England quietly published a strategy (July '24) that says:

it will not be possible to halt the spread of a new pandemic virus, and it would be a waste... to attempt to do so
2/ See Appendix 5  https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/framework-for-managing-the-response-to-pandemic-diseases/#appendix-5-planning-assumptions
That clashes with Hallett’s recommendation:

"risk assessment that moves away... reasonable worst-case scenarios towards... a wider range of scenarios"

But their plan assumes mass infection is inevitable and acceptable.

For some, it isn’t survivable!
3/
On top of that, the DHSC Pandemic Preparedness Strategy is late, and there’s still no UK-wide Pandemic Respiratory Disease Response Plan.

Exercise Pegasus was in the summer holidays, mainly with senior leaders. It lacked transparency in the absence of stakeholders & experts.

4/
Then comes the bit that should make every NHS worker and patient furious...

Hallett has already said clearly:
Covid is an airborne disease. Her experts backed this up again and again.

Yet DHSC and infection control manuals are *still* clinging to droplet/contact myths!

5/
Their letter points out:
Guidance still uses the incorrect 5 micron cut-off between “droplets” and “aerosols” that inquiry experts have said is WRONG.

This means that fluid-resistant surgical masks are still incorrectly as Covid / airborne protection in healthcare settings.

6/
CATA say this situation goes as far as being unlawful under Health & Safety law and the COSHH regulations.

The science is clear
The law is clear
But the guidance isn’t

...and workers and patients being left to face the consequences.

7/ Image
The annexes show a paper trail where:
Ashley Dalton MP stated in March 2025 that Covid is “not predominantly airborne”.

CATA sends detailed evidence, pointing her to inquiry findings.

Her final response?
She has “nothing further to add”

That is not “following the science”!
8/ https://ia902302.us.archive.org/BookReader/BookReaderImages.php?zip=/18/items/2025-11-29-open-letter-cata-to-baroness-hallett/2025-11-29%20Open%20Letter%20-%20%20CATA%20to%20Baroness%20Hallett_jp2.zip&file=2025-11-29%20Open%20Letter%20-%20%20CATA%20to%20Baroness%20Hallett_jp2/2025-11-29%20Open%20Letter%20-%20%20CATA%20to%20Baroness%20Hallett_0003.jp2&id=2025-11-29-open-letter-cata-to-baroness-hallett&scale=2&rotate=0
In Oct '25, the Minister for Children and Families writes to confirm that “COVID-19, flu and strep A are all airborne respiratory illnesses.”

Perhaps this is a sign that schools have accepted airborne risks?

But the DHSC certainly isn't protecting NHS staff and patients.
9/
CATA ended with a warning:

These failings “raise serious doubts about State bodies’ commitment” to actually implementing Hallett’s recommendations.

If they ignore the inquiry on major issues like airborne transmission and health protection, what hope is there for the rest?
10/ The issues we have raised in this letter raise serious doubts about State bodies’ commitment  to complying with your ladyship’s recommendation in a timely manner. We fear this does not  bode well for any recommendations you might make in your Module 3 report.    As always, CATA hopes to inform and assist the Inquiry in the hope that protections for the  public and healthcare workers can be improved without further delay.    Yours Sincerely    Dr Barry Jones BSc MBBS MD FRCP  Chair    On behalf of the CATA Executive Team:  Ms Kamini Gadhok MBE, Vice Chair  Professor Kevin Bampton  David Osborn
Many thanks to CATA @barryjmjones @KGadhok @BamptonKevin @SafeDavid3 for their tireless efforts to improve the health and safety of our nation. 💕

The full letter is below:


11/ archive.org/details/2025-1…Image
Image
Image
Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Clinically Vulnerable Families 💙💜💗

Clinically Vulnerable Families 💙💜💗 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @cv_cev

Nov 8
🧵 This autumn the UKHSA is rightly worried, as 'flu is a real risk...

TLDR:
Clinically Vulnerable people ALL need 'flu vaccines + antivirals this year (if symptomatic or exposed) + confused infection control guidance.

If you are Clinically Vulnerable, please read on...

1/ Graph showing the early rise of flu in the UK.
This year's strains aren't looking good:

The infections have started earlier.
A(H3N2) strains are dominant - and linked to worse outcomes.
A shifted strain (slightly different to vaccines) is also doing the rounds.

2/ Summary:  Influenza is now circulating in the community with earlier than usual onset of activity in the 2025 to 2026 season, and with an A(H3N2) drifted strain (K, also known as J.2.4.1) predominating  A(H3N2) predominance is associated with higher morbidity and mortality, particularly in the elderly, than when A(H1N1) predominates  All eligible groups should be encouraged to get vaccinated with the 2025 to 2026 seasonal influenza vaccine as soon as possible  Prompt antiviral post exposure prophylaxis and treatment for seasonal influenza should be offered to eligible groups  Antivirals gui...
If you have been invited for a vaccine, or live with a Clinically Vulnerable person (but don't qualify) please consider getting a vaccine - they can be as cheap as £9.95.

Everyone benefits from 'flu vaccines and children (up to 16) are offered them for free in school.

3/ Image of a banner outside a shop. A pharmacist is on the picture. She is has black straight hair, brown eyes, a big smile and is wearing a cream suit jacket with a staff badge.  Superdrug  *REMINDER!!!  IT'S FLU VACCINATION SEASON  Flu Jab Service provided by our healthcare professionals  Noyne Pharmacist  MEMBER PRICE £9.95  NORMAL PRICE £19.95  MEMBERS SAVE MORE  Service available here  Help protect yourself against several strains of the flu this season with one simple visit in-store. وو
Read 10 tweets
Oct 23
CVF💙💜💗's Closing Statement

⚠️SAFE
- Schools must be made safe.

👩‍🏫SUPPORT
- Children must be given appropriate support to continue their education at home.

🛡️STATUS
- Clinical Vulnerability must be recognised as a distinct group in the Equality Act.

1/ @AdamWagner1 KC
⚠️SAFETY
"There is good evidence that many schools can be made safer for Clinically Vulnerable children and those in Clinically Vulnerable families."

Ventilation is uncontroversial!

2/
Ventilation works!

"There is sufficient evidence and consensus now for the Inquiry to recommend that clear air is prioritised in schools"

3/
Read 7 tweets
Oct 21
🚨Boris Johnson - Children & Young People

Message to Gavin : 6/7/20
GW "need to push on the push compulsary attendance, and the message of normality"

AW "[You] encouraged him to continue the job.

Would you agree this was months before the vaccine...?"
BJ "Yes"
1/ @AdamWagner1
AW "Do you think in that race to return to normality [summer 2020] Clinically Vulnerable families may have been left behind?"

BJ "Getting back to school... would have been the best for all C&YP, CV or not."

2/
Johnson knew it would endanger our lives!!!

AW "It was sometimes not safe"

BJ "There was always going to be an argument... from that position... you were going to create a situation in which Vulnerable parents would be exposed to the virus picked up by kids in schools."

3/
Read 14 tweets
Oct 20
🚨Whitty is on the stand today... follow this thread.

CTI "What about children who lived with parents who were still at risk...?"

Whitty "The risk to shielding adult... will be increased somewhat, but the risk to the child... scarring their life chances indefinitely."

1/
CW "Risk-benefit taking a child-centred approach, was to prioritise the needs of the children.

I don't think [there is] convincing evidence, that was with the benefits of hindsight, an incorrect judgement."

- Don't the needs of the children include not killing their parents?
2/
CTI "But looking at if from the perspective of a child who might be a very difficult position... to be in."

CW "The need to have a conversation with the doctor [or nurse] their family know."
___

How would these conversation reduce risks?
Wouldn't it waste the time of HCWs?
3/
Read 23 tweets
Oct 16
🚨UKHSA - Dr Shona Aurara

The system of control in schools was not effective for an airborne virus.

CVF's questions from @AdamWagner1 KC

NB/ There was a HUGE amount of content - our amazing team are working on prioritising the best clips for you actively!

1/
Adam had to work hard today to try to hold UKSHA to account!

2/
AW "By reducing the isolation period [to 3 days], as well as restricting testing unless advised by a healthcare professional, that meant that infectious children were likely to be returning to classrooms?"

SA "Infectious period... viral shedding... balance of risk..."

3/
Read 41 tweets
Oct 16
📢BORIS JOHNSON has been implicated by others as the major decision-maker when it came to schools.

CVF look forward to the opportunity for @AdamWagner1 KC to potentially cross-examine him next Tuesday!

1/
Secret plans were available to control risks in schools, but they weren't published... because they didn't want schools to have "an excuse not to open in September [2020]"

2/
The DfE seemed to agree with Johnson's "let the bodies pile high" approach.

Susan Acland-Hood "There are some things so great that they genuinely need to be weighed up against mass fatalities"

3/
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(