1/ Russia simply isn't capable of doing in Ukraine what the US and Israeli air forces are doing in Iran, a prominent Russian warblogger admits. He blames the Russian air force's "organisational backwardness, underdeveloped intelligence, and lack of specialised aviation." ⬇️
2/ Ukraine's aviation situation is starkly different to that of Iran's, despite facing a theoretically more powerful opponent. The Ukrainian Air Force is not only still flying in substantial numbers but has expanded its capabilities with the addition of Western aircraft.
3/ 'Military Informant' discusses why the Russian Aerospace Forces are still unable to achieve air superiority over Ukraine after over four years of full-scale war:
4/ "Many immediately ask: how can this be? We have the Su-34 with the UMPK, we have the Su-35S with the R-37M, we have the Ka-52 with the LMUR, and so on. After all, they all fly, bomb, hit, and kill.
5/ "And that's all true. There's just one problem: Russian aircraft can do all this only from above territory controlled by the Russian Armed Forces, or, even better, from several dozen kilometers away from the front line.
6/ "This is precisely why the range of the FAB [bomb] with the UMPK [glide kit] is regularly increased—to minimize the risk to the bomber, which is unable to strike rear-area targets behind the front line.
7/ "In this regard, the Ukrainian Armed Forces are fundamentally no different from the Russian Aerospace Forces, but the latter are unable to engage Russian fighters in aerial combat due to the inferiority of their equipment and weapons.
8/ "So, we have exactly the same picture: flights exclusively over friendly territory, strikes with glide bombs across the front lines, and counter-drone warfare in the rear.
9/ "True air superiority looks like in Iran, where American and Israeli drones, along with aircraft, fly literally over the desired target, striking the necessary targets and conducting raids hundreds of kilometers into the country with impunity.
10/ "This is because an effective campaign to suppress and destroy enemy air defences was conducted beforehand.
11/ "The Russian Aerospace Forces, however, due to their organisational backwardness, underdeveloped intelligence, and lack of specialised aviation, are unable to conduct a similar operation to conquer the enemy's skies.
12/ "This is precisely why, for four years now, dozens of missiles and hundreds of drones have been fired at the Starokostyantyniv airfield [in western Ukraine] in an attempt to hit the aircraft based there and their shelters, while Ukrainian Su-24Ms still regularly take off…
13/ …from it and launch cruise missile strikes against the Russian rear, as they did yesterday in Bryansk. The airfield continues to operate as before.
14/ "Add to this the seasonal annual war with Ukraine's power grid, which, over the past four years, has also failed to be completely dealt with, despite the colossal investment of manpower and resources in the strikes, the biggest impact of which was a power outage…
15/ …lasting several days in several districts.
This is why all non-frontline military airfields in Ukraine will continue to operate, just like Starokostyantyniv.
16/ "Until Russian aviation, instead of being an appendage of the Ground Forces, assisting their advance with airstrikes on positions along the front line,…
17/ …becomes a truly independent branch of the armed forces, capable of solving independent tasks and breaking the enemy's back from the air." /end
1/ Russian journalist and analyst Yuri Baranchik asks plaintively: "why have they started terrorising the people?" He joins the dots between various recent actions by the Russian government, including the blocking of Telegram, and warns of a "1917 [or] 1989" scenario. ⬇️
2/ Baranchik's lament is the latest in a growing trend of Russian commentators suddenly becoming aware that the repressive power of the state is being turned on 'loyal Russians', rather than just against the despised liberals or anti-war protesters.
1/ Muscovites are being locked into an ever-growing 'digital gulag', complain Russian warbloggers, as a still-mysterious mobile Internet shutdown in central Moscow enters its second week. The shutdown is reported to be causing huge commercial losses and inconvenience. ⬇️
2/ Starting March 5th, Internet access in central Moscow was shut down, apparently on the orders of the Russian government. It has even extended to shutting down Wi-Fi on the Moscow Metro and the parliamentary Wi-Fi network in the State Duma.
3/ 'Blue Beard' says the city is being plunged back into the primeval darkness of 2007:
"The only app that works in the city centre in the evening, regardless of mobile internet conditions, is Yandex Music.
Meanwhile, Sberbank and T-Bank's banking apps have crashed."
1/ In recent weeks, an entire genre has sprung up on Telegram of Russian bloggers suddenly realising that they live in a repressive dictatorship. They complain bitterly that they were "fools", they are being "enslaved", and forced to endure a "cultural counter-revolution". ⬇️
2/ The forthcoming ban on Telegram – likely to be announced on 1 April – appears to have woken up many Russian bloggers to the way the Russian government is systematically attacking free speech. 'Under the ice' predicts catastrophe:
3/ "In general, the desire to confine all citizens of the country to a sterile information bubble, eliminating the use of inappropriate social networks, books, music, and films, will have the most devastating consequences for the state itself.
1/ News that the Iranian regime is proving more resilient than expected highlights its unusual governing structure as a 'polydictatorship'. In many ways, it was designed from the ground up to resist regime change. ⬇️
2/ The regime comprises a multi-layered set of elected and unelected institutions that shares power across religious bodies bodies, the armed forces (particularly the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps), and economic entities. Each provides a separate and distinct power centre.
3/ They each have their own institutional bases, resources, coercive capacity, and claims to legitimacy — none of which fully controls the others, but which collectively make the regime more resilient to internal and external shocks.
1/ The shutdown of Starlink is reported to be causing a sharp rise in casualties among Russian signalmen and linemen, who are being systematically targeted by Ukrainian drones as they attempt to install alternative communications systems. ⬇️
2/ Pro-Kremlin journalist Andrey Medvedev reports that "in those units where Starlink was operational and then shut down, there was an increase in the number of killed and wounded signalmen and linemen. Why do you think this is?"
3/ "The guys are trying to extend fibre optics to their positions everywhere, while the Ukrainians are herding our signalmen and hitting them with drones. Here's an officer's comment. Not everyone will understand, but...
1/ Ukrainian drone attacks deep in the Russian rear have prompted alarm among Russian warbloggers. They warn that the 'kill zone' behind the front line has expanded far into the rear of the Russian-occupied Donbas region. ⬇️