🚨 The “blowout” jobs report that just killed your rate cut? Misleading.
It was bartenders. 🍺
70K hospitality hires for the World Cup -> 5x normal. Wall Street saw a hot economy. It was a soccer tournament.
Back out the one-off and there’s NO blowout -> just trend. Yes, there’s a soccer tournament sitting on top of a trend-line economy. 🤯
Look under the hood. 🧵
It was bartenders. 🍺
70K hospitality hires for the World Cup -> 5x normal. Wall Street saw a hot economy. It was a soccer tournament.
Back out the one-off and there’s NO blowout -> just trend. Yes, there’s a soccer tournament sitting on top of a trend-line economy. 🤯
Look under the hood. 🧵
Do the math. 🧮
Headline: 172K. Leisure & hospitality - World Cup staffing - was 70K of it, vs. a 14K normal pace.
Back out just the abnormal ~56K and you’re at ~116K.
Back out the whole sector and you’re at ~102K - dead on trend.
Headline: 172K. Leisure & hospitality - World Cup staffing - was 70K of it, vs. a 14K normal pace.
Back out just the abnormal ~56K and you’re at ~116K.
Back out the whole sector and you’re at ~102K - dead on trend.
Decompose the 172K and it’s two economies:
📈 Temporary / low-wage / event-driven -> leisure & hospitality +70K (5x its 14K trend; 48K of it food service & bars), local government +55K.
📉 Higher-wage / cyclical - financial activities −22K on the month (−107K from its 2025 peak); transport & warehousing −92K from its 2025 peak.
The headline is the World Cup pouring beer. The trend underneath is the paychecks that matter shrinking.
📈 Temporary / low-wage / event-driven -> leisure & hospitality +70K (5x its 14K trend; 48K of it food service & bars), local government +55K.
📉 Higher-wage / cyclical - financial activities −22K on the month (−107K from its 2025 peak); transport & warehousing −92K from its 2025 peak.
The headline is the World Cup pouring beer. The trend underneath is the paychecks that matter shrinking.
The wage data confirms it. Average hourly earnings cooled to 3.4% YoY from 3.6%.
A genuinely tight labor market bids wages up. This one’s softening because the marginal job added is a seasonal hospitality shift, not a structural hire. Quantity up, quality down. The mix is flattering the print.
A genuinely tight labor market bids wages up. This one’s softening because the marginal job added is a seasonal hospitality shift, not a structural hire. Quantity up, quality down. The mix is flattering the print.
So before pricing out cuts on a “strong” number:
This is a one-off event masking a cooling core. The Fed shouldn’t tighten into a head fake or hold restrictive while the real economy bleeds beneath a tournament.
Normalize to neutral. Read the composition, not the headline.
The real question: is the Fed pricing the headline, or the composition?
This is a one-off event masking a cooling core. The Fed shouldn’t tighten into a head fake or hold restrictive while the real economy bleeds beneath a tournament.
Normalize to neutral. Read the composition, not the headline.
The real question: is the Fed pricing the headline, or the composition?
One more: this is why you read the composition, not the headline.
The number that moves markets and the number that reflects the economy are rarely the same. Everyone reacted to 172K. The story was in the mix.
Look under the hood. Every time.
The number that moves markets and the number that reflects the economy are rarely the same. Everyone reacted to 172K. The story was in the mix.
Look under the hood. Every time.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
