🧵My last week in Europe this summer. Still one trip and one conference, but I'm slowly beginning to pack up. And my overarching impression is that the security environment on the Old Continent has been deteriorating faster than folks in major capitals here seem to realize. 1/10
There are credible media reports that this fall Putin will mobilize half a million men for the Russian army. If confirmed, this move aligns with Moscow increasing pressure on @NATO's eastern flank, possibly direct hostile action to test the alliance. China continues to arm. 2/10
#Iran's resistance to the US bombing campaign has been strengthened by the "MOU" that effectively gave Tehran the time it urgently needed to restock missiles, drones, and munitions. It also allowed it to digest the lessons learned from the early days of the war and adapt. 3/10
North Korean soldiers who survived the battlefield in #Ukraine are back, assigned to training duties to pass their experience onto the North Korean military. The modernization of their missile technology continues apace. The risk level on the Korean Peninsula has increased.4/10
Most importantly, Europe's democracies (and the US) lack the resilience to adapt quickly to a major kinetic conflict should it erupt. Political divisions run deep, mistrust towards elites is growing, and radical politics draw ever more adherents. Nations remain demobilized. 5/10
The United States has thus far been able to manage multiple crises and pursue discrete military campaigns because it has been able to sequence them, thereby leveraging our constrained military resources to deal with them on a case-by-case basis. But things are changing fast. 6/10
The United States and its allies in key theaters are confronted by the Axis of Dictatorships (China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea). Sequencing is becoming ever more problematic, as a "crisis of simultaneity" is ever more likely to strain our resources to the breaking point.7/10
After 20 years of appeasement towards Russia, Europe is finally waking up to the threat. After twenty 20 years of the so-called Global War on Terror that reformatted the US military for out-of-area warfare, the US Army is coming back to large-scale combat operations (LSCO). 8/10
For Europe, the burning question is this: Does it still have the time necessary to restore deterrence and, should it fail, defeat Russia, especially when supported by China and the other members of the Axis? Or has Europe's lack of urgency after 2022 effectively disabled it? 9/10
The temporal dimension of warfare is unforgiving. Europe, especially Germany and other countries not on the eastern flank, will need a decade to rebuild their armed forces, their DIB, and rearm. The enemy gets a vote on when. Simply put: Has Europe run out of time already? 10/End
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵After some 3 months in Europe, I'm beginning to prepare to go back home. A few thoughts as I reflect on my experience here this summer. First, American democracy is different from what exists in the #EU today, and that shouldn't surprise anyone, but should make us think. 1/10
Democracy is organic to American national identity; the state's origins are inextricably intertwined with its core ideals. On the other hand, democracy in Europe as we know it today is largely derivative, superseding monarchies that defined its systems for a millennium. 2/10
In Europe, democracy grew amidst crises: bargaining between royalty and commoners (the UK); a bloody revolution ending with the guillotine and imperial wars (France); or imposed on the nation as an act of unconditional surrender (Germany).3/10. Different paths were followed. 3/10
🧵I've been in Europe for 2 months (Poland, Estonia, France, next Hungary, Belgium, Germany). I'd like to share a few observations before @NATO summit in Ankara. BLUF: Most of Euro policy elites don't understand current US politics--and often refuse to understand their own. 1/11
Americans are divided on issues like inflation, immigration, trade, or foreign policy, splitting into contentious factions which are generally misidentified by Euro elites as America's left and right. The key problem: Europe's intelligentsia doesn't know the US heartland. 2/11
Each day #EU elites grow more defensive, rallying around their favorite projects (net-zero, migration, multiculturalism, etc.). Beneath lies a deeper problem: with few notable exceptions (Finland), citizens across Europe believe that their leaders feel unaccountable to them. 3/11
🧵As I watch US podcasts on the internet about #Russia’s war against #Ukraine what I see increasingly defies reason. Academics like Mearsheimer or Sachs de facto repeat Russian talking points. For years now retired US colonels continue to declare #Ukraine’s imminent end, etc. 1/6
Most of the people who pontificate on Russia have never been outside of Moscow/Petersburg, if that. They don’t speak a word of Russian, nor Ukrainian. Instead, IR theory and, frankly, chutzpah substitute for country expertise as they boldly predict Ukraine’s imminent demise. 2/6
War is not a professor’s seminar on his/her pet IR theory. Service in the US military doesn’t give one genuine expertise on Eurasia. What I find most jarring is the apparent glee with which they claim their views to be strategic gospel. Zero humility. Zero self-reflection. 3/6
🧵I’m sick and tired of those shilling for Putin who constantly repeat that Zelensky hasn’t held a presidential election or that corruption hampers #Ukraine’s defense effort and thereby Kyiv is “not worthy” of America’s support. Get it through your heads: Ukraine is at war. 1/5
#Ukraine is fighting for its very survival not just as a country, but as a nation. Period. I’d like to remind those sanctimonious “Putin explainers” that during World War II FDR introduced several significant abridgments of civil liberties and constitutional rights in the US. 2/5
Look up the EO 9066, the Smith Act of 1940, the Proclamation 2537, Selective Training and Service Act of 1940, etc. We were at war then, and wartime conditions cannot be judged by peacetime requirements. Roosevelt served four terms until his death in 1945 regardless of custom.3/5
🧵POTUS's post that the US will deploy 5K troops to #Poland could be transformative for @NATO. For too long since the end of the Cold War the US force posture in Europe has relied on legacy installations, predominantly in #Germany, and most of all, on legacy assumptions. 1/6
During the Cold War, the US permanently based its military in #Germany because that was the point of contact. In those days, the Bonn Republic was the critical hub of @NATO's eastern flank. US troops served in Germany with families, with an extensive support infrastructure.2/6
Those decades of US forces being based in Germany created a bond of trust, underlying not only mil-mil relations, but also strengthening public support in the US for @NATO and the US pivotal role in it. Today the geostrategic reality is different-#Poland is the new NATO hub. 3/6
I recently complained about US airlines, comparing them to a superior experience offered by foreign airlines. I was wrong. Today I boarded @LOTPLAirlines from Warsaw to Seoul, flight no LO97. First surprise: No ramp to reach the plane. Instead I was directed to a bus outside. 1/6
A sourly looking @LOTPLAirlines gate agent snapped a few orders at me and sent me on my merry way. People piled on the bus, and kept piling on even though the bus was full. There was no-one from LOT staff to assist and manage the process. Finally we left for the aircraft. 2/6
Two minutes later we arrived at the plane. And… just sat there with virtually no ventilation as we watched through an open aircraft door @LOTPLAirlines flight attendants leisurely prepare for the flight, unpacking dishes, meals, etc. While we sat there. And sat there. And.. 3/6