"Gender critical" people struggle with hypotheticals.

If Beira's Place took donations, @jk_rowling, would you be fine with them publicly courting and accepting the donation of a celebrity like Joey Barton, who was recently convicted of kicking his wife in the head? 1/ The context of this question was that a rabbit charity, acknowledging that Elon Musk owned a company that was charged with animal cruelty for experimenting on a monkey, still publicly courted and said they would accept money from him. This, apparently, is fine with GC people. 2/

Just saw a video where a prominent transphobic woman said she'd sometimes spread toothpaste on her face, and pretend to shave, she so wanted to be a boy. And the thing is, in her other writings, it is clear that this has never gone away for her.

Some transphobia is self-hatred. She says that she was jealous of the anatomy of every boyfriend she had. It says it took decades to "accept" her womanhood. She struggles with the idea of long hair. She uses the male honorific "Lord" in her online handles, or screen names.

It's really important to understand how quickly online radicalisation works on vulnerable people:

Jan: TERFism is a cult
Apr: (Being trans is) not a cult, that's dumb.
May: I don't support a cult. (note the subtle difference)
Jun: Feel like I'm leaving a cult.

6 months. 1/


In reality, nothing has changed. The "gender critical" movement is still an obvious cult, and they are experts at online radicalisation, they can turn someone from "TERFism is a cult" to this within months, because they can see vulnerabilities in people. 2/

If you're watching Legaltweetz become an anti-trans activist in real time, and you're wondering why a very small number of trans people do this (Buck, Brianna etc.), one of the reasons should be very, very obvious from his (and their) tweets:

Narcissism. 1/ You don't have to be a narcissist to be a bigot, to go against your own community, but it helps. You will see in the tweets very similar themes of citing a long history of activism, how important they are to their community, feeling underappreicated for all that they do etc. 2/

It's 10 years since Ireland enacted a "self-id" law, there hasn't been one incident of a trans woman attacking anyone in a toilet. Cis men have done so, and been prosecuted. Banning trans women from women's toilets based on vibes does nothing for women's safety. 1/

https://twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/1923043306574905771

In fact, it makes women less safe, as has been demonstrated in a number of cases recently where women who don't fit the criteria of what men think a woman should look like have been confronted in toilets by men trying to kick them out. 2/

Let's talk about this. @jk_rowling sees that men on her side are generally anti-choice. She sees men who aren't on her side are generally pro-choice. So, she reframes abortion rights as one of the "things that also benefit men" to deal with cognitive dissonance this gives her. 1/ This is how "gender critical" people deal with the logical inconsistency of being in a supposed pro-woman movement, that welcomes so many obvious misogynists as allies. If it was truly a women's rights movement, it would not attract men who are anti-women's rights. 2/

Hi @hannahsbee

In 2022, the UK media reported that it was anticipated that "1000 families" (sic) would sue the Tavistock GIDs clinic, and the case would be filed within months. To date, there is no case. As you are somewhat of an expert, and a journalist, can you explain this? As you are no doubt aware, the case was put forward by a firm called Pogust Goodhead. A representative of the firm appeared on the Times UK Radio and said that while the figure was speculative, from the looks of his email inbox, he was confident it was accurate.

Do you remember this "gender critical" artist who set out to do 100 portraits of "detransitioned women" THREE years ago, and was determined to finish in 2025?

She has done ONE portrait this year, and that comes almost a year after she produced the previous one. 1/ Without a doubt, she believed in the "gender critical" propaganda that there was a huge wave of untold transition regret out there, so finding 100 portrait subjects would surely be easy, but she has stalled at around 60, worldwide, and at some point has to admit failure. 2/

This Canadian nurse lost an employment tribunal for "expressing her gender critical beliefs" and wrote an article that said, "Standing up for women’s rights is not transphobic...It is not hateful."

This is an example of the sort of "not hateful" comment she is talking about. 1/

https://twitter.com/preta_6/status/1485842594680631297

If you go to the mainstream media now you can read that this tribunal was a "witch trial" with lots of quotes from JK Rowling about women's rights, but the reality is that this has nothing to do with women's rights, it is simply hatred of trans people. 2/

Today is the "gender critical" movement's #DetransAwarenessDay, and I think people should be aware that (the very few) GC detransitioners are generally people who fell down Right-Wing rabbitholes, and ended up tweeting, and retweeting, horrifically ableist and racist tweets. 1/


Detransition is very, very rare, and generally not because people aren't trans, but because they find it difficult to exist as a trans person in a transphobic family or community. "General critical" detransition is rarer still, and is ideological.

#DetransAwarenessDay

Stella O' Malley is a celebrity psychotherapist in Ireland, and also the founder of "Genspect."

In that role she platforms "detransitioners" who are invariably awful, hateful people who freely use ableist slurs. Think this is bad? 1/


She also platformed another detransitioner, Keira Bell, 9 days ago, a few days after Keira, a Tommy Robinson fan, was retweeting horrifically racist tweets calling black people "monkeys", for example, without comment. But at least she's the only racist in Stella's gang, right? 2/

Whenever a trans woman does anything, a transphobic woman arrives to say that "women don't do that." The other day I saw a transphobe say that no woman has ever taken a picture of themselves trying on clothes in a dressing room.

That level of irrationality can't be "debated." Looking at the person's other tweets, they weren't a stupid person, they've just been taught to hate trans women for so long that they'll talk any sort of absolute bollocks in order to justify it. You can't "debate" people out of that, that is radicalisation.

Hi @thepeacepoet99,

Could it be that you were rumbled as stealth trans in 2019, by a mother who started an anti-trans org that same year, you ran away to Israel, your friend got shot, you were scared, and you knew the price of coming home to "safety" was detransition? 1/ That's a far more plausible story that what you said in @nypost, and doesn't leave out any awkward details, like your second name, and who your mother is, because that rather ruins your "incredible" narrative of "forgetting my binder, running, while the air sirens blared." 2/

Hi "gender critical" activists,

Graham Linehan asks you if it's likely that he - one of the most successful writers in his field - has been radicalised hours after he shared Robert F Kennedy propaganda on Ukraine that most of you (but not all) think is conspiratorial crap. 1/


Graham has spoken before of having "dark nights of the soul," where one presumes he wonders if he's actually just a transphobe in a transphobic hate cult, someone who is given to believe any sort of crap almost anyone who hates trans people says about trans people. 2/

Trans people are an innate human reality, much like gay people are. Homophobes will claim that being gay isn't natural, and transphobes will similarly claim that being trans isn't "a biological reality" but, on the evidence, being gay/trans is a natural part of humanity. 1/ In relatively recent human history, homosexuality was classed as a mental illness by medical professionals, even though, on the evidence, it clearly isn't a mental illness. This was because of prejudice, ignorance, anger and hatred, not sober-minded, unbiased calm reflection.

Progressives are not bad at debate; the Right Wing is just good at propaganda. For example, it's nearly three years since there was a huge Right-Wing media splash that "1000 families" (sic) were going to sue a trans healthcare facility in the UK. To date, the number is zero. 1/ What was actually being reported was an ambulance-chasing legal firm saying they were looking for litigants, and were expecting to get 1000 families. Either they were high on their own transphobic supply, or they knew well this was utter nonsense. But...2/

"The problem is that progressives are afraid of debate." You know, this year it'll be five years since JK Rowling revealed herself to be an anti-trans activist, and in all that time she has not once done a mainstream interview with any journalist who will challenge her. 1/ She did do a fawning 7-part podcast called "The Witch Trials of JK Rowling" with @meganphelps (who got out of one cult - The Westboro Baptist Church - only to fall straight into another one - The Gender Critical Movement.) But, she's never had to actually debate in a forum...2/

I'll translate @benryanwriter's tweet for you:

@BriannaWu is my "trans friend who agrees with me." She is one of "The Good Ones," she deserves better than all the other ones.

The days of "the trans friend who agrees with me" are over.

Ben and Brianna haven't got the memo. 1/ The anti-trans or "gender critical" movement is a hate movement.

In the early days, you'd have heard names of "trans women who agree with us" like Debbie Hayton, Fionne Orlander and Kristina Harrison coming up again and again, being cited as their "friends." 2/

Anyone who follows me knows that I am pretty level-headed, not given to abusive language, but I think you'll understand, when you read the quote tweet, why it is appropriate in this instance to say get utterly fucked with this shit, Peter.

https://twitter.com/PeterTatchell/status/1888944814252527798

This tone-policing nonsense happened in 2018 during the Irish abortion rights campaign where male centrist allies would admonish women for the tone of their tweets, telling them they were going to lose the abortion referendum by being too abusive to religious zealots. 2/

Hi again "gender critical" people, I see you are doing your usual campaign of holding a rally somewhere and then going to a local pub and trying to drum up a legal case.

Fundraiser incoming: more money from middle-class activists to harass working people just doing their jobs. Because that is what your movement is, at its heart. An entitled people's privileged harassment campaign. You say it's you versus the elites, but it's actually a group of relatively well-off people, travelling from city to city harassing local young workers when you get there.

Hey again "gender critical" people, do you see the way your MAGA allies are trying to claim that vaccines are a medical scandal by saying that the rates of identification of autism in children have risen from 1 in 150 in 2000 to 1 in 36 now?

Remind you of anything? 1/ It should be: this is exactly the same rhetoric you use to try to discredit trans kids, and claim that it is caused by a medical cabal intent on "transing kids" for profit.
You know how you think MAGAs are barmy on autism and vaccines? That's how you sound on trans kids. 2/