Brad Setser Profile picture
CFR senior fellow. Views are my own. Retweets are not endorsements. Writes on sovereign debt and capital flows.
83 subscribers
Aug 18 6 tweets 3 min read
Euro area exports fell back to earth in June, after pharma front running inflated the q1 number.

Imports (excluding fuels) continue to march up even with slow growth. China ...

1/ Image Imports from China continue to be on an strong upward trend (Chinese industrial policies, China's undervalued CNY .. ). They are now running around EUR 40b a month/ EUR 500b a year. The EV case didn't have a macro impact

2/ Image
Aug 15 14 tweets 5 min read
Foreign appetite for safe US government bonds seems to have waned a bit, at least in June.

But foreign demand for US risk assets was exceptionally strong. Big inflows into equities and corporate bonds in the June TIC data (close to $150b)

1/ Image Looks like there were net sales of LT Treasuries tho, led by official investors ... so a bifurcated report

2/

home.treasury.gov/news/press-rel…
Aug 10 10 tweets 3 min read
Chinese state banks were buying fx to keep the CNY at the fix during the second quarter; with China now intervening to hold the CNY down (v the USD) it would not be hard to engineer a stronger yuan ...

1/ Apart from a brief period in q1 when the market feared China would respond to Trump tariffs with a CNY depreciation, fx settlement has been positive since September --indicating that China's state actors are generally pushing the CNY down.

2/ Image
Aug 9 8 tweets 3 min read
According to the WSJ, the "transshipment" provisions will in reality be rules of origin that limited embedded Chinese content --

1/ Image This potentially matters quite a lot, as the primary impact of the tariffs on China to date have been a reallocation of the point of final assembly inside Asia -- so rising imports from the ASEAN countries and the NIEs (Korea, Taiwan)

2/ Image
Aug 7 8 tweets 3 min read
China's seemingly inexorable march toward a $1.2 trillion goods surplus (customs data) continues.

The July monthly surplus was a bit below $100b, but still up about $15 billion compared to July 2024.

1/ Image Higher US tariffs are having an impact on bilateral trade (the US and Chinese data agree on the trend tho not the level of trade) ...

2/ Image
Aug 6 4 tweets 2 min read
Lots of folks (including the FT!) seem puzzled by the broad strength of Chinese exports so far this year --

The answer tho seems easy. China's real exchange rate has fallen by at least 15% over the last couple of years -- giving China's exports a big boost

1/ Image . @sobel_mark has a good piece today for OMFIF making the case that an appreciation of the yuan is a necessary component of any global effort to bring China's surplus down. I of course agree

2/

omfif.org/2025/08/its-ti…
Aug 5 6 tweets 2 min read
One by product of Trump's obsession with bilateral trade deficits is that it has brought attention to the big deficits the US runs with pharmaceutical exporting tax centers ...

1/ Image The deficit in pharmaceuticals is now big ($200b, ~ 1/6th the total deficit ...) and 1/2 of that is with Ireland alone ... (hence the bigger bilateral deficit with Ireland than with Germany this year)

2/ Image
Aug 5 9 tweets 4 min read
The June trade data confirms that imports are down a low from the March (gold and pharma front running) peak -- but they aren't down as much in q2 as they were up in q1 ...

1/ Image So the goods deficit is still running ahead of its 2024 pace, even without all the pharma craziness ...

(Pharma imports fell $10b in June v May, driving much of the import weakness)

2/ Image
Aug 4 5 tweets 2 min read
Good summary of the state of Trump's term two tariff offensive, from the FT's Aime Williams and @dimi

1/ Image The "deals" struck by the deal maker in chief haven't been entirely, well, coherent -- raising tariffs on SE Asia to ~ 20 and some tariffs on Mexico to 25% helped China out, as it reduced the edge of alternative suppliers



2/ ft.com/content/05e524…Image
Aug 4 12 tweets 4 min read
President Trump often says he admires President Xi.

He now seems to want to emulate President Xi (or at least China) when it comes to massaging economic data.

And it sure seems like China will up, adjust, its q2 external surplus (down)

1/ Image The issue, as some already know, is that China changed how it calculates its goods surplus in the middle of the pandemic, moving away from the (reliable, and verifiable from counterparty data) customs data to an "internal" survey ...

2/ Image
Aug 3 4 tweets 2 min read
I want to push back just a bit on Martin Sandbu here --

When it comes to goods trade, Japan runs a deficit -- and the EU does too if tax inflated pharma is stripped out. The goods surplus is now incredibly concentrated in Asia, and China specifically ...

1/ Image There are a lot of reasons for the gap between the goods balance and the current account balance. Japan has a huge investment income surplus (why doesn't China tho?) and so on. But the gap here is enormously important ...

2/ Image
Aug 1 11 tweets 2 min read
Trump's new tariff rate lack rhyme or reason (other than rewarding big countries that made an effort to give him a win ... )

But -- as the decision on Brazil showed -- it is always important to know the exclusions as well as the headline rate ...

1/
The 35% tariff rate on Canada is crazy. Nuts. Insane. dumb. Shows a lack of interest in supporting US manufacturing (the US runs a surplus in manufactures with Canada).

But if oil and USMCA compliant trade are exempt, its practical impact will be modest ...

2/
Jul 31 10 tweets 4 min read
China's new (& sadly IMF approved, the IMF didn't think this one through) methodology for constructing China's BoP goods surplus relies on an internal Chinese survey, not the customs data.

The result: China's reported external surplus can simply fall for no good reason

1/ Image Based on the newly reported data for the monthly surplus on a BoP basis, that is what happened in q2.
The estimated surplus (using q2 2024 income) fell to $125b/ $500b annualized -- even though the customs surplus rose and the services deficit fell.

2/ Image
Jul 31 6 tweets 3 min read
China appears to have changed its intervention rule, and now intervenes (via the state banks) at the mid point of the band, not the strong side of the band ...

A true old school follow-the-money blog

1/

cfr.org/blog/chinas-ne… Hope others find this chart as helpful as I did -- the yuan has spent very little time on the strong side of the fix (the theoretical mid point in the band) and, more importantly, the proxy for state bank intervention shoots up if spot is close to the fix

2/ Image
Jul 29 4 tweets 2 min read
Probably the most important chart for the world economy right now -- Chinese export growth in both q1 and q2 was close to 10%; Chinese import growth has been flat (q2) or negative (q1)

With exports 20% of GDP, implies a huge net export contribution ...

1/ Image This excellent FT story provides the narrative to go along with the hard data -- China's localities have tremendous incentives to subsidize the production of overcapacity in new and old sectors alike. & with internal demand weak, exports result

2/

ft.com/content/f7979a…
Jul 29 7 tweets 2 min read
The census advance June trade data shows the goods trade deficit (which in accurately measured at a high frequency) fell back to around $1 trillion USD in June

1/ Image The big swing in the data came from consumer goods (which includes pharma) and is partial payback for a super strong q1 ...

2/ Image
Jul 29 10 tweets 4 min read
The EU opted not to fight a trade war with the US (and the Commission is taking some flak as a result).

China is already fighting an industrial policy war with the EU -- and winning

1/

cfr.org/blog/china-als… I think I have a pretty good understanding of why the deal with the US is controversial inside the EU.

But its impact ultimately hinges (technically) on the elasticity of a more or less global 15% (+/- 5) US tariff

2/

geopolitique.eu/en/2025/05/08/…
Jul 24 5 tweets 2 min read
Americans, understandably focused on the (past and present) antics of Donald Trump, tend to underestimate the shift in elite European views toward China

1/ Von der Leyen is perhaps a bit more hawkish than the European consensus, but there is no way this kind of message would have been delivered 4 years ago --

2/ Image
Jul 23 9 tweets 3 min read
Turns out that there was indeed a disturbance in the force -- the global balance of payments that is -- back when China changed its balance of payments methodology in 21/22 ...

(see the black line in first figure in the first box in the IMF's ESR)

1/ Image That disturbance -- which I felt, and so did Logan Wright and Adam Wolfe -- came as China used a new internal data set (then undisclosed) to adjust its exports down and move its imports up (relative to its previous methodology, note the fit v the old data before 2020)

2/ Image
Jul 22 16 tweets 5 min read
A deep dive -- a really deep dive some might say -- into the IMF's new External Sector Report.

It is a step in the right direction, but the IMF is still understating the scale of global trade imbalances and the scale of China's surplus.

1/

cfr.org/blog/better-la… Pierre-Olivier Gourinchas' blog draws attention to how both the US deficit and Chinese surplus widened in 2024 (v 2023) and how this widening was unwelcome as it pushed China's surplus (and the US deficit) above the estimates in the IMF Model

2/

imf.org/en/Blogs/Artic…
Jul 22 10 tweets 3 min read
I actually think this is real progress.

The Commission has (I hope) recognized that it can no longer make do with pretend deals that offer the illusion of progress without resolving the very real underlying problem ...

1/ Europe (and Germany) has sort of gotten mugged by trade reality.

German exports of autos to China, for example, are down by about 50% relative to their levels in 2014 -- 0r 2022 ...

2/ Image