Brad Setser Profile picture
CFR senior fellow. Views are my own. Retweets are not endorsements. Writes on sovereign debt and capital flows.
82 subscribers
Jun 16 6 tweets 3 min read
The Chinese yuan stayed remarkably stable throughout the period of most intense U.S. tariffs.

And in fact it looks like China's state was adding to its foreign assets over this period. May reserves fell a bit but the foreign assets of the state banks rose.

1/ Image In fact, the strong rise in the net foreign asset position of the state banks increasingly suggests that the yuan is under appreciation pressure (as a result of the $100b monthly goods surplus) not depreciation pressure

2/ Image
Jun 14 7 tweets 3 min read
“China’s vision of trade is exporting without importing,” said Brad Setser, senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations and a former Treasury Department official.

From the WSJ

1/ Image The discrepancy between imports and exports is indeed striking, and is consistent across different data sets

2/ Image
Jun 9 10 tweets 4 min read
There is a widespread view that the US gets a lot of cheap financing because of the dollar's reserve currency role. Two problems there: one, US rates aren't low v the G-10, and two, there aren't actually any current reserve flows ...

1/ Image Anyone who argues that the dollar's reserve currency role currently generates cheap financing for the US should be asked how precisely - it isn't because reserve managers are holding more dollars!

2/ Image
Jun 9 6 tweets 2 min read
Don't think Xi is feeling that much pressure from Trump's trade war. Exports to the US dipped, but exports to the rest of the world largely offset. The overall monthly goods surplus still topped $100b/ is on track to hit $1.2 trillion (gulp)

1/ Image Export volume growth dipped to 8% (estimate based on April prices). Import volumes fell 4% (not good).

Net exports are still driving China's economy.

2/ Image
Jun 9 13 tweets 4 min read
Are inflows into the US over the last 10 years come from the dollar's reserve currency role -- or are they simply from private investors seeking more yield (or greater equity market returns) than they get at home?

A new blog

1/

cfr.org/blog/dollars-g… I think the answer is clear: dollar reserves (the level of dollar reserves, not the dollar's share of global reserves) have been constant for the last ten years, and dollar reserve growth hasn't been a significant source of financing for the U.S. for a while

2/ Image
Jun 6 6 tweets 3 min read
The craziest bit of the US trade data so far this year is undoubtedly trade in pharmaceuticals. Makes the swings with China look modest.

1/ Image The massive March v April monthly swing tho washes out of the trailing 12m sum, and what shows are the more structural shifts -- like the huge run up in imports from Ireland

2/ Image
Jun 6 4 tweets 2 min read
Some more interesting (and likely more important) things happening right now, but still wanted to highlight a couple of the details of the US trade data.

Seems pretty clear what is happening here

1/ Image A bit more refined analysis shows the same thing -- namely that US imports from Vietnam and China were inversely correlated in the last few months (as happened with the initial section 301 China tariffs)

2/ Image
Jun 5 6 tweets 2 min read
The Treasury's foreign exchange report is out -- no fireworks (as well, most countries weren't intervening to hold their currencies down last year or early this year), but it does preview some significant methodological changes

1/x Image And true to form, the report indicates that tariffs are the preferred tool to address any future findings of manipulation

2/ Image
Jun 5 5 tweets 2 min read
$10 billion increase in Taiwan's reserves in May

"The foreign exchange reserves of the Republic of China (Taiwan) amounted to US$592.95 billion as of the end of May 2025, ... an increase of US$10.12 billion from the end of the previous month"

1/ Image $10b a month/ $120b a year (annualized) is a lot -- it is roughly 15% of Taiwan's GDP. It is also roughly the number than may be needed to keep Taiwan's exchange rate stable for the rest of the year given Taiwan's massive external surplus

2/
Jun 3 4 tweets 1 min read
Good piece

"The Chinese are as confused about Trump’s endgame as everyone else"

1/

ft.com/content/d64c30… I actually think most of the world now recognizes Trump's desired end game: he wants other countries to accept a big increase in US tariffs (10% base, maybe higher for some, plus sectoral tariffs) & make additional concessions to avoid even higher tariffs

2/
May 30 7 tweets 3 min read
The 2025 US trade data is going to be crazy. The advance numbers show the deficit collapsed in April, after the "liberation" day tariffs on China brought trade to something of a standstill

1/many Image The deficit in consumer goods (a category dominated by pharmaceuticals and China) unsurprisingly collapsed --

2/ Image
May 29 6 tweets 2 min read
Interesting. Conservative German government considering a massive digital services tax ...

(Germany hasn't joined France, Italy and others in putting them on ... )

1/

ft.com/content/39d467… Suspect that Trump's policies have contributed to a shift in German politics (and potentially policy) here; if the US is going to tariff German autos, well, why not tax the US digital giants (or their customers, the actual incidence is debated)

2/
May 27 7 tweets 3 min read
There is, at least in my view, a lot of sloppy analysis about the role the dollar's reserve currency "status" plays in financing the US external deficit.

I understand how reserve accumulation funds the deficit, but not how the "status" of the dollar does ...

1/ many Image There was a time when reserve accumulation by the large surplus countries in Asia mapped perfectly to their external surplus, and their reserve accumulation really did generate large financial inflows into the US

2/ Image
May 26 18 tweets 5 min read
A few thoughts on the JGB sell off last week, as I was surprised that there wasn't a stronger big for duration from Japanese investors pushed out of the JGB market over the last 10ys by low yields and a flat yield curve --

1/ Image For quite some time, Japanese banks were pushed out the curve by a flat curve (especially in a world where YCC limited yields on bonds out to 10ys) --

(chart is just for the regional banks and shinkin, and it is from April 24)

2/ Image
May 26 7 tweets 2 min read
The fact that the Ireland "imports" EUR 50b in IP via royalty payments (mostly to the US) -- and the fact that Ireland now imports EUR 175b in services from the US -- should help frame most discussions of services trade ...

1/ I have highlighted how goods trade is heavily influenced by tax avoidance -- with pharmaceutical trade being the best example. Once you take out tourism (and education) though services trade tends to be much (and I mean much) more distorted ...

2/
May 24 5 tweets 2 min read
Trump has been relatively clear on this.He is looking for unilateral concessions from trading partners + acceptance of the base tariff. EU equally has been clear that it wasn't willing to accept this structural set up. From a good NYT piece by @jeannasmialek

1/ Image I understand why most folks in the market are discounting Trump tariff threats, but I remain worried -- there just isn't a willingness in Europe to do the unilateral concessions Trump insists are needed.

2/ Image
May 24 14 tweets 5 min read
Not sure the global savings glut has ended -- at least not the East Asian savings glut (long-term rates in China and Korea and Taiwan are very low).

Do see evidence tho that the mechanics of intermediating that glut into the US market aren't working right now

1/ many Why do I think there is still a savings glut? Well the savings rate in North east Asia (NIEs, China, Japan) is ~ 40% of regional GDP, which is VERY high (China is high, China is a rising share of the total)

2/ Image
May 23 11 tweets 3 min read
Apart from reflecting a misguided view of America's economic and diplomatic interest, the threatened 50% tariffs on the EU are big -- imports from the EU are 2 pp of GDP, the just pay it cost is ~ 1 pp of GDP. That's well over 2x the term 1 trade action v China.

1/ Image What's more, the reported US asks of Europe reflect a rather stale and dated conception of how to rebalance the bilateral trade relationship -- I was expecting/ hoping for more out of USTR

2/

ft.com/content/9a9077…
May 23 10 tweets 4 min read
It is going to take more than a G-7 communique -- and tariffs -- to bring China's trade imbalance down. Lots more talk about imbalances recently. But no change in trend. China's goods surplus has topped $1.1 trillion. Its manufacturing surplus now rounds to $2.0 trillion

1/Image The rising surplus reflects both renewed nominal export growth (volumes are growing even faster, 10-15%) and weak imports ... with manufacturing imports (including parts for reexport) of $1.5 trillion relative to exports of nearly $3.5 trillion -- a huge gap

2/ Image
May 21 12 tweets 3 min read
In Japan's low for long era (with a flat curve out to 10ys, thanks to yield curve control), the Japanese banks loaded up on ultra long bonds & probably are looking to lighten up.

But there are natural buyers long-dated JGBs too

1/ Image The low for long era (with a different shaped curve in Japan and the US/ Europe) pushed the insurers into foreign bonds & big Japanese institutions like Post bank and Nochu as well. These institutions have yen liabilities, and thus naturally would match with yen bonds

2/
May 21 9 tweets 3 min read
After a couple of months of weak flows, foreign demand for US bonds (in the great valuation adjusted Bertaut Judson data set) was strong in March.

March tho is stale -- it is pre liberation data, and before the dollar/ bond sell off in April.

1/ Image One of the reasons for relatively strong flows in March (and q1) was, well, Japan. but it is stale data. Japanese sales of Treasuries in 2024 were driven by MoF intervention.

2/ Image