Brad Setser Profile picture
CFR senior fellow. Views are my own. Retweets are not endorsements. Writes on sovereign debt and capital flows.
77 subscribers
Mar 26 11 tweets 4 min read
Gearing up for April 1 (the release of China's detailed 2024 balance of payments data ... not tariff day)

In q2 China's reported* current account surplus was about 1/2 the combined surplus of the east of "surplus" east Asia; it then rose a bit in q3 and q4 ...

1/many

* I have doubts about the reported data)Image The roughly $400b Chinese current account surplus in the last 4qs isn't as extreme an outlier as $200b in the 4qs to q2 but it still puts China's current account surplus well below the rest of East Asia. &the goods data tells another story all together

2/ Image
Mar 24 5 tweets 1 min read
Happily, European banks are much less reliant on dollar wholesale funding than they were before the global financial crisis -- and with new opportunities developing in Europe, don't necessarily need a big dollar book going forward

1/3 The COVID shock (and for that matter, balance of payments analysis and Japan's excellent Financial Systems Report) showed that the bid dollar funding need now is in Japan, as Japanese banks have a big dollar book. But the MoF has lots of dollars ...

2/
Mar 23 9 tweets 3 min read
Will be very interested in seeing if the IMF program for Argentina (which Bloomberg reports the Board will discuss this week) provides net new financing in 2025 and 2026 for what looks like an obvious peso overvaluation

1/

ft.com/content/09616c… The standard analysis of Milei focuses on the undeniable fiscal adjustment (helped by very low debt service costs, but still real). But the external balance is going the wrong way -- Argentina now runs a sizable current account deficit

2/ Image
Mar 21 8 tweets 3 min read
The current discussion of a Mar-a-Lago accord presumes substantial inflows into US financial assets from governments seeking to hold safe global assets --

But there were no such flows in the US balance of payments in the fourth quarter.

1/ Image And the fourth quarter isn't an outlier -- the runup in the US current account deficit in 2024 (please take note @IMFNews) was financed privately, official (official = foreign central bank and SWF) demand for US assets was modest!

2/ Image
Mar 19 12 tweets 4 min read
One of the biggest global flows right now is the increase in the foreign assets of China's commercial banks -- it has been running at a pace of about $100b a quarter/ $400b a year for the last two plus quarters ... 1/ Image That's real money. The net global current account (or trade imbalance, if you don't trust the current account numbers right now) is something like $1.5 trillion, so $400b is 1/4 of the total net financial flow that sustains trade imbalances. 2/ Image
Mar 17 5 tweets 2 min read
Trump seems serious about introducing a sectoral tariff on pharmaceutical imports --

But there is a better way to bring the trade deficit down: get rid of the pro-offshoring provisions of the Trump-Ryan Tax code

1/

cfr.org/blog/american-… There 2017 TCJA clearly failed to bring the pharmaceutical industry back home -- in fact, it encouraged the complete opposite, as imports and the trade deficit in pharmaceuticals soared after the 17 tax reform

2/ Image
Mar 16 11 tweets 4 min read
One fact about the global economy should not be subject to debate any more -- the US is more than meeting global demand for reserve assets (a significant change from 2002 to 2014 ... )

1/ many Image And since China has had a policy of limiting its Treasury holdings (and shifting fx reserves over to the SCBs and policy banks) since around 2010, China's share of the Treasury market has shrunk radically ...

2/ Image
Mar 11 5 tweets 2 min read
The US runs a surplus in manufacturing trade with Canada, so if the goal of the tariffs is to reindustrialize the United States, the trade war with Canada is doubly counter-productive

1/ Image Canada is the wrong target, as it is in fact a good market for US manufactures. The best in fact. And raising the price of industrial inputs (like Canada's low carbon aluminum) makes US downstream industry less competitive ...

2/
Mar 11 7 tweets 3 min read
I see that President Trump has said (again) that the only way to get the pharmaceutical industry back to build a tariff wall.

There is a actually another way -- change the provisions of the TCJA that incentivized offshoring.

1/ Image I have been baning on about this for a while. That's because it is obvious in the data. Pharma imports were $112b before the TCJA. They are now $260b.
the deficit in pharma has also exploded ...approaching $260b.

2/ Image
Mar 9 5 tweets 2 min read
Good thread. A couple of additional thoughts.

A) China's central government has essentially no net debt. Let me repeat that no net debt (its financial assets match its liabilities). It could be doing a lot more to support consumer demand.

1/ B) Gerard mentions the importance of all components of domestic demand not just consumption. Fair enough. What worries me is that manufacturing investment has held up the investment component of demand, and it is unlikely that it can be sustained at current levels

2/ Image
Mar 8 7 tweets 3 min read
My regular reminder that foreign governors haven't been the marginal buyer of Treasuries for the last decade, and certainly not the last 3 years ...

1/ Image Official demand has been extremely flat the last two years -- with Chinese sales offset by other countries purchases. China is adjusted for Euroclear -- and Chinese sales were stronger in 23 and early 24 than in recent months ...

2/ Image
Mar 6 10 tweets 3 min read
US import dominance is unchallenged!

Tariff front running seems sure to make the trade deficit great again ... January was a case in point

1/ Image Surging imports led the trade deficit (sign reversed) to pop off the page (the annualized run rate is something like $1.8 trillion ... )

2/ Image
Mar 6 7 tweets 3 min read
An important point from Tsinghua's David Li --

China doesn't have one industrial policy; it has 30!

Just a portion of the insights in Bloomberg's big take on where China's economy now stands.

1/many Image As this chart shows, China has not yet reversed the fall in the consumption share of its economy that occurred after Zhu Rongji's reforms, & coincided with WTO entry. In my NYT piece, I argued that this is China's original sin: it created a structurally unbalanced economy

2/ Image
Mar 6 4 tweets 1 min read
A chart showing imports in some the sectors where the Trump Administration is likely considering sectoral 232 tariffs --

The US imports almost as many pharmaceuticals as it does finished cars (and pharma imports from Ireland are about equal to vehicle imports from Mexico)

1/ Image And a chart showing why tariffs on semiconductors (imports of around $60b) are no substitute for a "CHIPS act" -- imports of semiconductors are only 1/5th of imports of products that use semiconductors

2/ Image
Mar 5 8 tweets 2 min read
I understand the political logic of an IMF/ Milei alliance -- it highlights the IMF's utility to the new US administration.

But increased the IMF's net exposure to Argentina when the peso is enormously overvalued is a classic error --

1/ Image Argentina's fiscal looks better than the IMF expected pre-Milei (though the non transferable USD bills held by the BCRA mask the true fiscal deficit/ true interest expense). The BoP tho looks bad -- the predictable result of an overvalued peso.

2/
Mar 4 9 tweets 3 min read
The tariffs on China (and on Apple, 20% of the $400 import price of an iphone is $80) have rightly been overshadowed by the tariffs on Canada/ Mexico.

But China has said it will retaliate, which means US agricultural exports to China will get a new moment in the sun

1/ Image One thing about agricultural exports is that they are, well, seasonal. The biggest US ag export to China by far is soybeans, and the '24 harvest has already shipped out ...

2/ Image
Mar 4 8 tweets 2 min read
CNY fix is still fixed. Mid point of today's band was set at 7.174 -- essentially unchanged from yesterday.

1/x Image Spot is at 7.29 -- weaker than the fix no doubt, but not yet at the edge of the band.

Nothing that yet suggests a weaker CNY is part of China's reaction to the Trump tariffs (of course, the move could come with a lag)

2/ Image
Mar 3 7 tweets 2 min read
A few quick thoughts on the 25% tariffs on Mexico and Canada -- a move that is likely to be considered one of the most self destructive economic policy steps in recent history.

1/
tariffing the US auto supply chain -- and imports of autos from Canada and Mexico that have a ton of embedded US content -- while leaving the market for imports from Korea and Japan open is a bit mad.

2/
Mar 2 16 tweets 4 min read
Enjoying Chokepoints by @edwardfishman. It is by far the most detailed history of US sanctions policy available, & expertly explains how financial sanctions became a central part of how the new great game between the US, China, Russia and others is played

1/ Why have sanctions become such an integral part of US and European leverage? The global reach of the dollar and the euro, fear of OFAC & the fact that sanctions can be rolled out against a nuclear power w-o the risk of war. 2/

penguinrandomhouse.com/books/726149/c…
Mar 1 7 tweets 3 min read
American pharmaceutical companies now pay tax in America "last" --

Most US owned big pharma companies have disclosed their 2024 profits, and the amounts they have set aside to settle their US and foreign taxes ...

h/t @Mike_Weilandt for the charts

1/ many Image The bottom line here is simple -- the major US pharmaceutical companies collectively report earning over $50 billion globally and did not set aside anything (that's right anything) to cover their 2024 tax liability to the US federal government.

2/ Image
Feb 28 7 tweets 3 min read
Tariff front running has arrived --

The Donald's tariff threats clearly pushed the January trade deficit to a record level ($150 billion monthly) as import rushed in to beat the tariffs ...

1/ Image Imports of consumer goods for example surged (likely Chinese consumer goods back in January, but there might be even more in February given the risk of a tariff on Mexico ...)

2/ Image