𝙲𝚑𝚊𝚛𝚕𝚎𝚜 𝙲. 𝙼𝚊𝚗𝚗 Profile picture
Writer of 1491, 1493, and The Wizard and the Prophet. Also @charlescmann.bsky.social.
Jun 2, 2023 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
It is not only against the ignorant commoner with whom I contest: to defend all women comes to be the same as to offend almost all men, since rare is he that is not interested in building up his sex at the expense of the other.
Benito JerĂłnimo Feijoo, Defensa de la mujer (1726) This 1726 book, written by a Spanish monk, was wildly popular and controversial in its day, with hundreds of books and feuilletons being written for and against its strikingly modern rationalist argument that women were the cognitive, social, and moral equal of men.
May 15, 2023 • 9 tweets • 4 min read
On three occasions I've written something for an outlet that made people very angry who had some power over the outlet—twice before publication, once after. (I mostly cover science, which typically doesn’t get this kind of reaction, but it happens.) 1/7 In the two before-publication cases, my article angered the publisher (in one) and a major advertiser (the other). Both times, my editors ran through what I was saying to make sure it was solid—then sent in their resignations. My pieces ran. 2/7
washingtonpost.com/technology/202…
Mar 30, 2023 • 16 tweets • 6 min read
New Science paper argues horses came to the Americas earlier than previously thought—a conclusion that, if it holds up, rewrites the history of the N. American West. Strikingly, the article is from a team of archaeologists, geneticists, and Lakota researchers and elders. 1/15 Both the findings and the collaboration are, in potential, a big deal. Let me explain why I think this. 2/ gifer.com/en/O3R
Mar 22, 2023 • 16 tweets • 6 min read
Reading this kind of article about what teachers can tell students (“Can we say slavery is wrong?” “No?") under the new dispensation makes me wonder what would happen if teachers gave students primary sources, rather than textbooks. washingtonpost.com/education/2023… 1/15 In this article, for instance, one teacher no longer can give students Howard Zinn’s account of Columbus’s voyage. 2/15 Image
Dec 27, 2022 • 22 tweets • 28 min read
@kevin2kelly @chr1sa Sorry for the slow reply, Kevin. I have a terrible cold. But here's my stab at an answer to your good, hard question. @kevin2kelly @chr1sa The biggest problems w/ journalism now are the economics, which are a disaster. People who are wildly overstretched on the job and under siege financially simply won't do
a good job, period.
Dec 14, 2022 • 10 tweets • 7 min read
This new @BTI report deals with an issue little-known to the public but ever more important: figuring out how to reduce the climate impacts of agriculture. thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-ag…

A tiny bit of background, back-of-the-envelope style, in the thread below. 1/9 @BTI ~3/4 of greenhouse emissions come from industry, transportation, power generation, heating, and so on. We know, in theory, how to deal with this: Electrify everything, then generate the energy in a carbon-free way. This is a huge challenge, but we basically know how to do it. 2/9 Image
Aug 23, 2022 • 19 tweets • 7 min read
Detailed study in Nature last month of how Mayapan—the biggest Maya city in Yucatán in ~AD1100-1450—responded to a century of drought may provide insight into our own drought-plagued future. nature.com/articles/s4146… 1/18 Mayapan was the capital of a confederacy of smaller states, the most powerful Maya political entity at the time. It rose after the decline in ~900AD of the famous city-states in the southern Yucatán (e.g., Tikal). (map: Masson and Peraza Lope 2014) 2/18 Image
Jul 19, 2022 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
Modest proposal, occasioned by chats last night at a wedding with some smart, curious, well-educated 20-somethings: All high-school students should be required to take a course called How the System Works. 1/5 The course would have little political content. Instead it would focus on the physical systems that harvest and deliver drinking water, that generate and deliver energy (esp. electricity), that produce and distribute food, and the public-health system. 2/4
Jul 14, 2022 • 9 tweets • 2 min read
I get what Dr Folta is saying here, but I think it's important to understand that two different things are going on. One is the question, "what is reasonable?" The second is the question, "what is right?" I believe Dr Folta misunderstands the relation between them. 1/9 Dr Folt is making a point about perceived risk, as he mentions here, in a reply to me. And he is 100% right about this, as far as I can tell. But that's not the sphere most people operate in.
Jun 21, 2022 • 8 tweets • 5 min read
A few days ago, a Spanish publisher (@capitanswing) released a Spanish translation of my book, “1491.” News coverage led to a small kerfluffle, with various people denouncing me online. They got mad because my book supposedly attacks the Spanish Conquest of the Americas. 1/7 Image @capitanswing The general thrust of the criticism is that the Conquest was justified – even that it was good for Indigenous Americans themselves. 2/7 Image
May 2, 2022 • 10 tweets • 4 min read
An extraordinary map: the areas in Canada in which their original inhabitants--First Nations, Inuit, and Metis, to be precise--have regained at least partial sovereignty. 1/10 A bit of explanation. In the 1970s, the Quebec provincial gov't decided to develop a huge hydropower project in the James Bay region to the north. Nobody asked the Cree and Inuit people who lived there. They didn't like that--and sued in 1972. 2/10
Jan 14, 2022 • 4 tweets • 2 min read
While trying to figure how to translate the name of a kind of hat worn by the conquistadors, I came across David Carrasco's translation of Bernal Diaz's history of the conquest, and found a few paragraphs that sum up how most historians today think of Aztec human sacrifice. I’d only add that the conquistadors almost never saw these rituals. Instead they saw Aztecs horribly killing (torturing, skinning alive, etc.) captured Spaniards to scare and intimidate them. But there’s little evidence that regular Aztec ceremonies were quite that sadistic.
Jan 7, 2022 • 18 tweets • 7 min read
Readers of 1491 tell me they're surprised by archaeologists' resistance to claims—like this one, from 2020—that the Americas were settled >20K yrs ago based on fragments of stone tools. In part, that skepticism descends from earlier fights. 1/18 One big example: In the 1880s Benjamin Harrison, a grocer and amateur archaeologist, claimed he found ~5 million yr old “stone tools”—chunks of chipped flint—in Kent. They were dubbed “eoliths” (Greek "eos", dawn, and "lithos", stone). (Cyril Chitty 📷 Maidstone Museum) 2/ Benjamin Harrison by Cyril Chitty
Dec 31, 2021 • 15 tweets • 5 min read
Instead of working, I spent the last few days immersed in COVID preprints and papers. FWIW, I emerged with cautious optimism. If I were assigned to write a "state of COVID" piece, I'd sum it by saying the next 6-8 weeks will be awful, but there's reason for hope after that. 1/14 The argument that Omicron will be, for most, less severe (fewer hospitalizations per case) seems solid. Some of this seems due to the inherent properties of the variant itself, but most seems due to lots of people being vaccinated. (Charts from NY Times) 2/14
Dec 15, 2021 • 10 tweets • 4 min read
This Atlantic article says nobody thinks about COVID in the author's small town. I wondered if that were really true. I live in a small town, and plenty of people think about it.

theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/… A few seconds on Google told me his town was Three Rivers, in southwestern MI, pop'n 7,659 in 2019. It's an exurb of Kalamazoo with a weirdly high crime rate (lots of meth, I'm guessing).
Jan 16, 2021 • 4 tweets • 2 min read
This USC-Princeton study in PNAS of the lives lost to COVID has some stunning numbers: pnas.org/content/118/5/… Data thru November suggest the disease has knocked .98-1.22 **YEARS** off US mean life expectancy at birth. To give some idea of how huge that is, recall that annual life-expectancy declines of .1 yr in 2015, '16, and '17 were cited as evidence of social catastrophe--a plague of overdoses, obesity, and suicide hitting the white working class. Case & Deaton wrote a famous book about it.
Dec 3, 2020 • 9 tweets • 4 min read
I see this stuff from time to time, and I always wonder why these guys think that indigenous people had some sort of exclusive monopoly on horrible violence. It’s just not true. 1/9
Every 16th/17th-c. English town of any size had a constant stream of public executions of unremitting awfulness. Here’s an execution in 1586 at St. Giles’ Circus in London: 2/9
Jul 21, 2020 • 11 tweets • 4 min read
There’s a small academic argument about whether Robt. Malthus’s dire predictions were defeated by science and technology. True, S&T greatly lifted farm productivity, but that’s not the fundamental flaw in Malthusianism. TW: nerdy stuff. 1/10


1/10 Malthus famously said that human numbers increase geometrically. If a population was X million in 1800 and 2X million in 1825, it would go to 4X million in the next 25 yrs, and 8X in the next 25 after that. In his scheme, population would double every 25 years. 2/10
Jun 26, 2020 • 7 tweets • 2 min read
I see this a lot, and it's so incomplete as to be unfair. 1) there's no real evidence that Borlaug & co. who did the research for the "green revolution" were motivated by anything other than the desire to reduce hunger. 2) The methods of the GR were strongly backed by the '70s govt's of India, China, N. Vietnam, Mexico, and a host of other governments that can't be described as pro-colonial in any common sense.
Jan 9, 2020 • 13 tweets • 6 min read
Activists often wonder why the public hasn't reacted more strongly to the issue. Favored targets of blame include tribal loyalties, corporate greed, conservative pols’ mendacity, Fox. All play a role, but I think underneath is what I think of as the Obama House Syndrome. 1/11 A picture of the happy family plus a picture of their old Martha's Vineyard house, which is not exactly shabby. Ex-President Obama, surely the most climate-concerned president ever, bought a house last fall in Martha’s Vineyard. Here’s a picture—nice house! Right on the edge of the ocean. $11.5 million was the price, supposedly. 2/11
Jan 2, 2020 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
I saw the new *Little Women* and thought it was great. But I wished they hadn’t shown Alcott’s editor, Thomas Niles, Jr., as a sexist philistine. Both Niles & his firm, Roberts Brothers, were big backers of female writers in the 19th c.—a time when many publishers weren’t. 1/5 In addition to Alcott, Roberts Bros. pub'd Susan Coolidge, Emily Dickinson, Maud Howe Elliott, Julia Ward Howe, Abigail Alcott Nieriker, Caroline Bauer, Juliana H Ewing, Anne Gilchrist, Mary Robinson, George Sand, Helen H Jackson (a big fave of mine), and tons of other women. 2/5