Marco Chitti Profile picture
Architect, Urban Planner, PhD ** I make a lot of typos (and my English is far from perfect). Please be patient**
5 subscribers
Aug 1 5 tweets 4 min read
It's always interesting to note how, unsurprisingly, the history of transportation planning is nested in the shifting larger paradigms of urban planning.

The only two sizable "greenfield" outlying sections of Frankfurt U-Bahn follow two different paradigms of urban integration. Image The only greenfield section part of the overall pre-metro scheme built in the initial phases run either underground or in a freeway median, within an area of interwar (Romerstadt) and postwar modernist development.
Grade-separation was the "gold standard" for everything back then


Image
Image
Image
Image
Jul 31 7 tweets 3 min read
One of the reasons why French tramways tend to be relatively slow is that they often have very curvy and zigzagging alignments. There are two main reasons for that, one linked to the history of urban development in France, the other to how and when French networks developed. Image The historical reason is that France, outside of Paris intramuros, it's not a country of Grand Boulevards and large urban schemes. With one of the most property owners-friendly land regimes, French cities mostly grew with chaotic street patterns during both the 19th and 20th c.
Jul 24 10 tweets 5 min read
Not only Seattle (and many other cities) opt for mined stations in city-center areas, but they also do it in the most bloated way, with full-length mezzanines and wide off-street access shafts.

Let's look at a more sober approach to mined stations from u/c Vienna's U5


Image
Image
Image
First, the Seattle approach (veru common in NA mined stations) is to go with a large cavern encompassing both tracks, a central platform and a "full-length mezzanine, that is a slab above the platform level allowing for horizontal circulation outside of platform space Image
Jul 16 17 tweets 8 min read
Today, the much-awaited, 5, 5 km, 8 station, metro line 6 in Naples was finally (re)opened* (with limited service) after a 40+ years-long saga that is emblematic of how the bad choices and habits of the 1980s still haunt Italy today.

A 🧵


Image
Image
Image
Image
Naples' line 6 has a very troubled history. It was initially planned in the early 1980s as the "Linea Tranviaria Rapida", an LRT-like system mixing at-grade and grade-separated segments crossing the city East-West roughly along the coast. Image
Jun 10 18 tweets 7 min read
A recent exchange in here reminded me that historically there has essentially been two main paths toward level boarding of mainline rail.

The prevalence of one type or the other in a country depends a lot of when and how the railway became a commuter-oriented mobility tool.

A🧵 Image The 19th c. railways had very low platforms, just slightly higher than the tracks, either in wood, masonry, or simply a stone curb filled with gravel. Essentially, a glorified sidewalk.
That was ok for a railway with sparse traffic and generous dwelling times.
Image
Image
Jun 5 13 tweets 6 min read
How does Zurich achieve consistent running times and an elevated average speed on its legacy tramway network despite the fact that it's not fully running on dedicated lanes?

An example of urban integration and conflict management strategies along a segment of line 3

A🧵 Image Tramway line 3 covers the 4.3 km, 11-stop section between its terminus at Albisrieden to Sihlpost /HB in 16 minutes, with consistent running times throughout the say, averaging a pretty good 16 km/h speed.

How does it achieve these performances? Image
Apr 12 11 tweets 5 min read
This 1 km stretch of mixed-traffic alignment of Ulm's tramway lines 1 & 2 along Romerstrasse is an interesting example of how a good level of transit priority can be achieved without a dedicated right-of-way.

Follow me in this virtual trip Image Starting from west and going east, inbound toward the city center, the tram line gets out of its lateral dedicated alignment to merge into mixed traffic after the Gimmelfinger Weg stop Image
Mar 30 7 tweets 4 min read
How it started > how it's going

In the 1960s, Grenoble's Grand Boulevards, built from the 1930s at the place of the late 19th c. fortifications, were transformed into an urban motorway with a major grade-separated "autopont" at the intersection with the N-S Cours Jean Jaurés >>>
Image
Image
The Grand Boulevards were intended to become the major East-West thoroughfare, the urban continuation of the "penetrante urbaine", i.e. the motorway branch feeding into the urban core, a typical element of both French and Italian 1960s traffic and urban planning.
Image
Image
Mar 11 6 tweets 3 min read
A peculiar characteristic of French tramways' urban integration is that they often do not provide for dedicated left-tun phases (hence no dedicated lane) because they preferer to add a tram-only phase in the cycle rather than servicing it alongside the major through phase Image For the same reason, the far-side split stop, very common in the US & Canada, is quite rare among modern French tramways, because of the tram-only phase and that fact that there is no need for a near-side left-turn lane in the buffer occupied by the stop far-side Image
Mar 10 10 tweets 4 min read
Sometimes I feel like people have a hard time understanding that tramways can be very different "modes" with very different performances depending on their urban integration and conflicts with other road users.

So I tried to make a diagrammatic comparison of 4 tramway lines Image The diagram, which is a work in progress, highlights the position of a few key elements that define the performance of tramway vehicles such as stops, signalized/unsignalized intersections and the type of right of way Image
Feb 5 11 tweets 4 min read
Si on me demandait "quel est le projet potentiel de TeC structurant que tu mettrait de l'avant en ce moment pour le Grand Montréal?" ma réponse serait "aucun de projets couramment à l'étude, mais plutôt une 'Trillium-fication' des lignes ferroviaires du CP et CFQG.

Pourquoi? 🧵
Image
Image
Par "trillium-fication' j'entends la bonification du service de train de banlieue SJ afin de permettre un service fréquent cadencé (p.ex. 15 minutes dans le tronc commun, 30 dans les antennes), 7 jours/semaine et avec une amplitude horaire similaire à celle du métro et du REM.
Jan 19 15 tweets 5 min read
The ARTM recently floated the hypothesis of an LRT to serve the eastern island after the REM de l'Est was canceled and the $36bn unrealistic light metro feeder hypothesis

But how does a LRT option interact with the existing transit service? How does it improve it?

A 🧵
Image
Image
The hypothesis (limited to rue Sherbrooke) is of an LRT similar to the recently opened Edmonton's LRT: stop spacing of 1.2 km on average (2.5-3 times the typical Euro tram) and an average speed of 26 km/h

That makes for a 15 km line with 12-13 stops and 34 minutes end-to-end Image
Jan 12 4 tweets 1 min read
My contribution to the IBX discourse.

Transit "modes" mixing different types of right of ways do exist

What seldom exists as a new built projects nowadays, and for good reasons, is a mode with all type A RoW (grade-separated) but a tiny segment of type B/C Image The reason it seldom exists is that passing from totally grade-separated RoW (A) to either dedicated on-street (B) or mixed-traffic (C) means getting rid of an entire category of technological solutions for the vehicle, the driving, the signaling, the platform height etc.
Jan 8 7 tweets 3 min read
Today comes to an end (or a beginning) one of these italian rail planning stories born in the cursed 1980s: the Bari-Bitritto suburban railway finally opens after literally 30+ years in the making.

It boasts the usual "stations in the olive orchard" so dear to S-Italian planners


Image
Image
Image
Image
It was planned in the late 1980s by the FCL (Ferrovie Calabro-Lucane) as a meter gauge diesel line to serve the stadium built for the 1990 world cup and the grandiose scheme for urban development toward the south of the city of Bari that never fully materialized Image
Dec 27, 2023 10 tweets 2 min read
Since we are discussing long-distance bus, it might be helpful to look into a real-life case study

Italy "deregulated" long-distance bus service (interregional, blue in the pic) in 2014

(Pic from @beriapaolo 's Atlas of Transport in Italy. Paolo is the real expert here) Image Long-distance bus service was never publicly-run in Italy, as the national policy favored railway for long-distance trips, but until 2014 it was regulated under a "concession" regime, where private operators were granted the right to run a particular route.
Dec 13, 2023 5 tweets 4 min read
Interesting slides about the u/c "raddoppio in variante e affiancamento" (Double tracking with partial rerouting) of the Bicocca-Catenanuova section of the Catania-Palermo railway.
38 km for €450 million, due to open Feb 2025. The entire project is quoted at €11.5 bn


Image
Image
Image
Image
These images once again bring home the fact that modern railways are just a road with ballast, tracks and catenary on top,what RFI calls "sovrastruttura ferroviaria", that is normally even contracted out separately
Road contractors could find a second life building railway's RoW


Image
Image
Image
Image
Dec 9, 2023 4 tweets 2 min read
T12, the latest addition to Île-de-France tramway network, opens today. It's part of a small family of "express trams" with high average speed (T11, T12, T13) serving tangential corridors feeding into the RER, filling gaps in fast rail transit coverage in the Grande Couronne
Image T12 is made of two different parts in terms of alignement (thus average speed): The tram-train part running on the mainline rail alignement formerly used by a RER C branch (39kph) and a new "fast tram" type of alignement, with a mix of off-street and in-street sections (24kph) Image
Nov 21, 2023 24 tweets 9 min read
La question des déficits des entreprises de transports en commun est au centre du débat au Québec (et pas seulement).

Certains réclament des aides gouvernementaux. D'autres, des coupures de service.

Et si on augmentez la vitesse commerciale ?

Un 🧵 de vulgarisation technique

Image
Image
Image
Comme toute activité économique, la production de ce service publique doit être en équilibre entre recettes et dépenses, c-à-d les coûts de production du service: il faut payer les salaires des chauffeurs, les pièces de rechange des bus, le carburant, l'entretien des garages, etc Image
Nov 9, 2023 16 tweets 4 min read
Une petite réflexion sur ce à quoi il faut s'attendre pour Québec maintenant que le gouvernement a confié à CDPQ Infra le mandat d'élaborer une proposition pour un "mode lourd" pour desservir Québec, en me basant sur ce qu'on connaît du modèle d'affaires du REM

un fil🧵
Image
Image
Prémisse: le modèle de partenariat public-privé promu par CDPQ avec le REM est un unicum mondial parmi les modèles dites DBFOM(Design-Build-Finance-Operate-Maintain) pour un grand nombre de raisons, mais en particulier pour la distribution des risques et le payment des redevances
Nov 3, 2023 17 tweets 6 min read
Dernièrement, on a parlé beaucoup des coûts d'infrastructures qui montent en fleche ici au Québec.

Des tourbillons de milliards qui font tourner la tête et le manchettes de journaux.

Mais qu'est qui se cache derrière ces chiffre changeantes ?

Suivez-moi dans un fil explicatif


Image
Image
Image
Image
D'abord, rappelez-vous qu'il s'agit de projet qui sont encore sur la table à dessin, donc il s'agit d'estimations

Et comment sont-elles calculées? Comme tout exercice budgetarie, c'est un peu comme faire du boudin. On ne veut pas trop (faire) savoir qu'est-ce qu'il y a dedans...
Oct 31, 2023 6 tweets 3 min read
I was roaming on google earth and I saw that the 3D image of Turin is updated...and one can see the "scar" of the under construction M1 metro extension along Corso Francia.

It is interesting because the construction technique is not C&C nor TBM >> Image As the section was judged too short to deploy a TBM effectively and to reduce the depth of the tunnel (and thus of the stations) while avoiding to move all the utilities they opted for a traditional mining technique with consolidation from above (jet grouting injection) Image