I don't like either proposal, but John's (flat rate relief) has been discussed a lot, so let's concentrate on Tom's. @TimesMoney@JohnRalfe1@PensionsMonkey 2/X) @pensionsmonkey says that, as now, 75% of withdrawals would be taxable. There would be no upfront relief on contributions to workplace schemes because a 1:1 employer match provides sufficient incentive. Govt would match contributions to non-workplace schemes.
Sep 3, 2019 • 18 tweets • 9 min read
1/X) Tomorrow, Government & UK statistics Authority respond to @LordsEconCom report on RPI. A quick thread...
@LordsEconCom 2/X) The Committee believes law requires UKSA “to attempt to fix the issue with clothing prices”. This change would have to be approved by the Chancellor.
Jun 3, 2019 • 9 tweets • 3 min read
1/9) Despite his four ovens, @jbrokenshire’s proposal looks half-baked. Most obviously, letting 1st time buyers raid pensions for deposits bids up prices to the extent that supply is fixed & the buyers would be buying anyway.
2/9) This transfers wealth from 1st-time buyers to existing owners. Like other demand-push policies, it worsens the relative position of people it purports to help.