Jeff Sharlet Profile picture
NYT Bestseller THE UNDERTOW: Scenes from a Slow Civil War. THE FAMILY (book & Netflix). THIS BRILLIANT DARKNESS. Words+pics @VanityFair. Teach @Dartmouth.
51 subscribers
Jul 21 8 tweets 2 min read
I think it’s important to know how much FOX News is putting into conspiracy theories around the Butler PA assassin. There are many reasons for this, but bottom line is how dangerous it is: this is civil war thinking. Thread 1/ Today on Fox, Wisconsin Senator Ron Johnson said he’s seen persuasive evidence of a second shooter. (He’s talking about a YouTube.) He says a mysterious man in a suit told local law to send photos to someone who has “gone dark.” (That is, he has no proof.) 2/
Jul 19 11 tweets 2 min read
Evaluating Trump's speech according to democracy's laws of physics makes as much sense as declaring what we don't know about black holes "impossible." Fascism exerts a different gravity. The speech fuses the base; it's the "confidence" of the base that draws in "undecideds." That's how fascism "works." It doesn't have to be how fascism wins. But defeating it, I suspect, means at least a larger number of us discarding our reassurance narratives. Looking at the awfulness dead on, & fighting *that,* not what we wish it was.
Jun 11 20 tweets 8 min read
I was going to go to Vegas to report Trump's first rally as a felon--not for "news" but to listen for tone, for the mood of fascism as it mutates. But I decided it was too hot, so I stayed in VT & watched 5 hrs of it from an obscure rightwing network. And I made pictures... 1/ Image The image above: “Costumes of sorts,” proclaims one of the two broadcasters, Vanessa Broussard. Then, as if on cue, right behind her, a “costume”--the man in the sombrero. My article continues w/ the juxtaposition of the grotesque & the absurd in service of fascist hysteria: 2/ Image
Jun 2 7 tweets 2 min read
Trump returns to Fox today. Strongman rhetoric from get-go, in response to q on how best to seek "revenge": "Lotta people said, 'We have no choice but to elect Trump, because he's only one who can withstand this." Basic fascist trope: Great Leader can do what mortals can't. 1/ Q&A continues as if everyone knows that the fundamental fight is America, as embodied in Trump, vs. "Intel," as in intelligence agencies, as in "deep state." By making it a given, Trump & Fox sweep their viewers into conspiracism as if it's simple as "they sky is blue." 2/
May 25 7 tweets 2 min read
This Jew thinks it’s perhaps not widely understood in non-Jewish circles that Israel’s war—I think it can correctly be named a genocidal campaign—has led to a rhetorical civil war among US Jews. With, of course, not the “two sides” some insist cover all but a dozen or more. It’s not the main event, to any of the “sides.” But it’ll reverberate long after the war ends. It’ll probably have a significant impact on US politics, probably in ways that aren’t yet clear; you can’t draw a straight line from now to the future.
May 24 4 tweets 1 min read
I’ve been listening to Trump in the Bronx. My record of both taking on Trumpist fascism, starting from the golden escalator, and not telling anti-Trumpers what we’d want to hear when it’s not true, is solid. So here’s the awful news: he’s doing what he does *very well.* One of the things Trump knows how to do is put on a show. For a show, you need a good stage. That’s what the Bronx was for him tonight: not the folks there, but white tv viewers who want to think it’s not racist to vote for Trump watching Black & brown people cheering him.
May 21 15 tweets 3 min read
I’m Dartmouth faculty, & I voted for this censure—the first in 255 yrs, in response to the first use of a militarized SWAT team in 255 yrs. A local story with larger implications as college presidents inadvertently advance the far right’s 30-yrs war on higher education. I’m not interested in celebrating the censure of our president. It was unhappy work made necessary by Dartmouth’s unprecedented militarized response. I’d have rather been meeting with students yesterday than with faculty. But *nobody* is safe when a college SWATs itself.
May 6 13 tweets 3 min read
I join many Jewish colleagues @dartmouth in rejecting our administration's apparent belief that it can speak for "Jewish safety," much less increase it by permitting a SWAT team and riot cops to menace all regardless of identity. 1
Image
Image
Jewish communities, like the country as a whole, are deeply divided by Israel’s war in Gaza. The College’s leadership does not have the right to elevate one set of voices and experiences as representing all Jews. 2/
May 5 13 tweets 3 min read
Regardless of your view on protests, the militarized response—which has ramped up with what some call “the Palestine exception”—will not end there. Absent a big—& politically diverse—pushback, this is the new norm for campus protest. 1/ Maybe you disagree with Gaza protests, or some language you’ve heard from them. Do you approve of *militarized* response to civil disobedience? Because going forward that will be the standard response to protest over many issues. 2/
May 4 16 tweets 3 min read
I am a Jew. This week, a trustee of @dartmouth, the college at which I've taught 14 years, @GovChrisSununu, declared a protest there "100% antisemitic." A protest in which Jewish students, faculty, & staff took part. Sununu's statement isn't just wrong--it's antisemitic. 1/ Christian "Zionists" & others who weaponize antisemitism for their own political projects will say, "But there has been antisemitism at protests." YES. There has. I've heard it and seen it here, too. That's a problem. It's not the main one, & their "answer" makes it worse. 2/
Apr 30 10 tweets 2 min read
US fascists are having a field day. American Jews (I'm one) troubled by real antisemitism w/in *but not definitive* of protest panic & support anti-democratic crackdowns. Protesters who know their own honest good faith insist there's not even a trace--& again, US fascists gloat. A few of Mike Johnson's favorite things: liberals who support crackdowns; leftists who insist, against evidence, that there is ZERO antisemitism anywhere; news orgs that focus on higher ed, Johnson's foe, instead of Israeli crimes; Israeli crimes.
Mar 25 7 tweets 2 min read
Too chillingly on the nose: Timothy Ryback on his new book, TAKEOVER: Hitler's Rise to Power: "In the run-up to the 1932 election, told his followers, 'Be there, it's going to be wild.'" publicsphere.news/p/q-and-a-a-hi… I hesitated before tweeting this. I've reported on & written about rightwing movements 20 yrs. Never beaten like, for instance, Russian counterparts. But plenty else. I was never afraid. Not brave; just didn't feel afraid. Now? Yes.
Mar 3 9 tweets 2 min read
So much "everybody knows" thinking in political discussion right now. Like "everybody knows" Dobbs will be Trump's downfall. Maybe! But it's not just the recent Times poll that gives Trump historically high numbers w/ women. Then there's another "everybody knows," which is that unless Biden changes course on Gaza, he's cooked. A) for many, it's too late. B) For far more, the much bigger numbers of those who don't "support genocide" but also don't consume news, they *like* Biden's awful policy.
Feb 14 10 tweets 3 min read
Today's NYT headline--its phrasing, the story that follows, its placement--more than anything Maggie Haberman ever wrote persuades me that the paper's political default is now the kind of center-right that imagines responsible people can contain fascism by coopting bits of it. 1/
Image
Image
This NYT headline really is "fake news": not a deliberate lie but willful delusion, casting a race that realistically probably *couldn't* be lost as a victory because the Democrat ran to to the right of the "Republican," an almost non-entity candidate. 2/ Image
Feb 4 5 tweets 2 min read
What's rightwing media chattering about? This NBC tracking poll showing Trump catching up w/ Biden & growing his lead over 6 months. If you were give Biden all of Stein, West, & RFK (much lower than other polls), those who say they won't vote for president, he'd still lose. Image I'm not telling anyone what to do. Let me repeat that before people scream at me that I'm trying to "force" them to vote Biden. Each makes their own decision. But the fascists know what's on tap. We should, too.
Jan 27 10 tweets 4 min read
WaPo that exemplifies how rightwing & fascist frames shape stories written by otherwise good reporters with good intentions. Problem 1: Why is this presented at an election story? Stakes, not odds, as @jayrosen_nyu says. Lives are at stake. & yet nut grafs don't explain. 1/
Image
Image
Third graf doesn't pivot to tell us what's going to, you know, *happen,* or what it will mean to people involved; instead, it reduces all that humanity to a question of polls for Biden. Giddyap, horse race! 2/ Image
Jan 23 13 tweets 5 min read
I live in VT, work in NH, wander it often. Welcome to the so-called moderate state. III, upper left: III percenters. Designated terrorists by Canada. Designated patriots by Trump. 1/ Image I write about the III Percenters in my book THE UNDERTOW: Scenes from a Slow Civil War (@wwnorton), which, yeah, I'm hawking, because after 20 yrs covering the Right, it's my best effort to say this is what's happening. Here in NH. Everywhere. 2/ Image
Jan 6 30 tweets 10 min read
When I launched THE UNDERTOW I did an event w/ a NYT politics reporter who scoffed at use of "fascism." When pressed, he didn't seem to know what it means. Here's my definition, informed by years of reading and... "fieldwork." With illustrations! A thread. 1/ Image The dude w/ the gun lives near me. Here in Vermont. First point of defining fascism: Not just violence, by a reverence for violence as a purifying force, as an exhilarating, even titillating experience. By the way, here's the hand holding that gun: 2/ Image
Dec 28, 2023 5 tweets 1 min read
The most amazing thing about Nikki Haley's pandering racism--wait, there's nothing amazing about it. She's been at it for years, going back to 2010, when she told "Confederate heritage" groups--white supremacists--that the Civil War was about "tradition" v. "change." 1/ Back in 2010, long before Trump said the white power riot in Charlottesville featured "very fine people on both sides," Nikki Haley--the GOP's new "moderate"--told white supremacist leaders "you see passions on different sides," but there was no "hate" involved in slavery. 2/
Sep 15, 2023 8 tweets 2 min read
Lousy source but it’s a whole lot of smoke. Satisfying to see an anti-queer fascist revealed as hypocrite. But—it does. Not. Matter. Her downfall won’t hurt the fascist movement a bit. Here’s why… 1/ dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1… So maybe now Noem won’t be VP. So what? Her fascist views are interchangeable with those of many others. “But doesn’t this ding their ‘fam values’ shtick?” Nope. Fascism *depends* on constant betrayals that create a culture of hate, backstabbing, & paranoia. 2/
Sep 3, 2023 80 tweets 20 min read
Friday, my 14, wary of school, answered a teacher’s query about this weekend by saying we’re going driving in VT’s Northeast Kingdom. “You should go to the Museum of Everyday Life!” said teach. “We went last weekend!” said kid. 1/ @rumblestripvt @sevendaysvt @chedgar31 The truth is we’re going to Bread Puppet & the Museum of Everyday Life because the 14 likes to drive. Or, at least, be driven. It is a way they have of driving off the spleen. And lately I’ve been introducing them to @rumblestripvt. This thread is to introduce it to you. 8/