Jon Mackenzie Profile picture
Writer and presenter @TheAthleticFC. Noticer™. Not CEO of AS Monaco. Out of possession is nine tenths of the lore.
2 subscribers
Feb 2 46 tweets 11 min read
I was in two minds about how to frame this Monday’s #DidYouNotice thread because…

Did you notice how Spurs’ half time changes earned them a point against Manchester City this weekend? Image Seems simple enough, right? But then… is this about Spurs or City? Because in many respects, this game was a parable about the state of modern football, showing how much the game has changed in recent years. Let me explain.
Jan 26 52 tweets 11 min read
It’s been fun noticing recently with the upheavals in the managerial situations at some of the big European clubs.

And that brings us steaming back to the topic of last week’s thread because #DidYouNotice how Michael Carrick’s ‘risky’ approach earned him a win over Mikel Arteta? Image Now, before we begin, I want to begin with a caveat. When doing analysis like this, it’s important to not just follow the results and make hard and fast conclusions on the basis of insufficient evidence.
Jan 19 45 tweets 11 min read
Just as surely as night follows day, so follows a Did You Notice? thread off the back of a weekend of fixtures.

And what a fixture we have to talk about today because… #DidYouNotice that Michael Carrick found a way of exploiting Man City’s press on the way to a 2-0 derby win? Image People who have followed me on here for a while will know that I bang on about how important the out of possession side is in the modern game.
Jan 12 39 tweets 10 min read
I was a little hesitant about doing a thread today because in some respects the Darren Fletcher tenure doesn’t deserve scrutiny given he’s essentially interim coaching and so shouldn’t be held to the same scrutiny a tenured head coach/manager should… [thread] Image …but I felt as though the game itself was quite instructive from the point of view of what is required within the modern game, particularly when it comes to the question of “Why is rest defence important?” and so…
Dec 29, 2025 39 tweets 11 min read
You may have thought that being in the middle of Betwixtmas would mean that you got a break from noticing for a week. You were wrong…

Because #DidYouNotice how Unai Emery turned things around against Chelsea at the weekend, getting Villa another win from a losing position? Image We all know the cliche ‘a game of two halves’ but this was more accurately a game of three thirds, the first two of which were completely dominated by Enzo Maresca’s Chelsea. So in order to explain how Emery shifted the momentum, we need to start with Chelsea’s approach.
Nov 24, 2025 27 tweets 8 min read
Monday may bring with it the misery of a new working week but it also brings with it the chance to notice…

And today is a banger if you’re North London whatever the weather because #DidYouNotice that Arsenal completely dismantled Spurs’ back five in the first half of the NLD? Image That’s right, Thomas Frank switched up to a back five for Spurs’ visit to the Emirates which, at least on paper, seems a relatively conservative decision - taking a player from higher up the pitch and dropping them into the back line. Image
Nov 10, 2025 39 tweets 10 min read
Monday can only mean one thing: noticing. And guess what? Today we’re noticing out of possession and HAHAHAHAAHA I LOVE OUT OF POSSESSION.

More specifically, #DidYouNotice how Manchester City have improved the defensive side of their game so let’s strap in and explore how. Image Let’s set a little bit of context. We all know how City have struggled with defensive transitions over the last few seasons…

…which is an issue a lot of elite teams who try to hold high territory possession have found: Image
Nov 3, 2025 34 tweets 10 min read
It’s Monday… and on Monday’s we notice.

And today we have a real treat because #DidYouNotice we got a masterclass from Pep Guardiola on how to cause problems for Andoni Iraola's famous press…? Image In fact, all three of City’s goals came from them exploiting this press to some degree or another...
Sep 29, 2025 31 tweets 7 min read
It's a Monday... you know the drill...

So #DidYouNotice how Martin Odegaard changed the game for Arsenal in their comeback 2-1 win against Newcastle this weekend? Image If you did notice it, you're not the only one... here's what Eddie Howe had to say after the game:
Sep 21, 2025 13 tweets 3 min read
There seems to be a bit of a debate going on about whether or not Guardiola/City specifically planned to play low block and counter vs Arsenal. Don't have any big opinions but these are some points I think are important: * Guardiola post-match makes it sound like City intended to play with more control in and out of possession but suggests that Arsenal limited them on both fronts hence why they were reduced to transitions
Sep 10, 2025 9 tweets 2 min read
One of the things that the Liverpool-Arsenal game got me thinking about was the gradual shift we're seeing in build-up intentions in the European game. In the first half, Arsenal were able to press Liverpool well enough to prevent them from getting the sort of settled possession that they want to build their more direct attacks.
Sep 2, 2025 18 tweets 5 min read
Guys, I have to get this off my chest because I'm analysing Brighton vs City and the City out of possession approach is blowing my mind... This is the set up vs goal kick. Here's the thing. City are going m2m with their front 5 players. Nothing odd there on paper until you realise they're going m2m against the GOALKEEPER as well. So it's CF->GK, WFs->CBs, CMs->CMs... Image
Sep 1, 2025 31 tweets 7 min read
It’s a Monday and on Mondays, we notice so…

#DidYouNotice how Arne Slot swung the game in Liverpool’s favour against Arsenal this weekend? Image It’s pretty clear when you look at the per half data that @markrstats put out that this was a game of two halves… Image
Aug 18, 2025 36 tweets 7 min read
In this week’s #DidYouNotice, I want us to have a think about Man United’s build up. You can catch the video at the end of this [thread]: Image Because there has been a lot of criticism of their build up under Amorim and rightly so.
Mar 31, 2025 35 tweets 10 min read
It’s Monday! And the first Monday after my annual leave! So what better way to spend it than by noticing how my beloved Andoni Iraola lost to Manchester City!!!

So, yes. Here’s a thread on how Pep Guardiola used Bournemouth’s famous press against them [thread] Image Let’s start with some pressing theory: under Iraola, Bournemouth use a kind of press that I like to call “hybrid” pressing.
Mar 17, 2025 42 tweets 11 min read
It’s Monday and so we’ve got some noticing to do…

And what a game we have at our disposal today with Newcastle’s first trophy win in 70 years which was achieved through Eddie Howe's creative use of this guy [thread] Image It was actually an incredibly interesting game on a number of levels but I think it can only truly be appreciated by viewing it through the lens of the 2-0 win Liverpool managed against Newcastle in the PL a few weeks ago. Image
Mar 10, 2025 43 tweets 10 min read
It’s Monday, so we notice.

And today we’re noticing things about the Man United - Arsenal fixture which I thought gave us a new angle on some of Arsenal’s same-old problems in possession… [thread] Image Across the last few seasons, we’ve spent a lot of time talking about Arsenal’s ball progression.

The fact of the matter is, when they’re looking to build from the back, Arsenal have tended to play around the opposition block.
Feb 3, 2025 29 tweets 9 min read
Ok. Ok. Settle down. I know it's a Monday afternoon and the transfer window is about to close but we are obliged to notice something before the day is out.

It couldn't be anything but Arsenal and let me tell you, I'm positively frothing to talk about their pressing [thread] Image Over the last few months, Arsenal have been quite interesting out of possession. Last season, they tended to defend out of a 442 shape (actually much more often a 442 diamond) with Martin Odegaard joining the front line next to the striker. Image
Image
Jan 27, 2025 27 tweets 8 min read
Dearly beloved. We are gathered here this Monday afternoon to notice something from the weekend's football.

And oh me oh my... today we're actually talking about Manchester City! Because I noticed how important Josko Gvardiol was to City's win against Chelsea [thread] Image Last season, Pep Guardiola trialled a system which used full backs in a more traditional way - as width providers higher up the pitch.
Jan 20, 2025 38 tweets 10 min read
Ah yes! Another Monday afternoon on our gradual trudge into the future…

Which means we notice! And today I’m noticing something that has maybe gone largely unremarked at Spurs given the general misery of things recently… but Postecoglou has been evolving… [thread] Image During his time at Spurs, Postecoglou has been accused of being too tactically inflexible by a lot of people (myself included tbh).
Jan 17, 2025 9 tweets 2 min read
Positional play simply refers to a playstyle in which the positions of the players are used to generate tactical advantages. There is nothing about this definition that precludes players from changing positions in a "non-ordained" way. There's a concerted effort by a group of people on this app to persuade you that positional play is actually synonymous with the worst form of rigid structuralism you can find in football. They are doing this to give their approach more clout.