SEEN in Journalism Profile picture
A network for journalists and content-makers across platforms who seek to restore accuracy and impartiality to media coverage of sex and gender
Jan 27 5 tweets 2 min read
Exclusive from @guardian

‘Stephenson is viewed as more open to listening than her predecessor Kishwer Falkner…who oversaw interim advice from the EHRC which prompted alarm that it could effectively exclude trans people from the public realm’

The drama. What nonsense.
/ Image theguardian.com/society/2026/j…
Jan 27 5 tweets 3 min read
‘As soon as we were out of surgery..I couldn’t urinate, I need a catheter..I found extra drainage holes opening up and couldn’t walk for more than half an hour’

The ⁦@Independent⁩ turns the horror of ‘gender surgery’ into a waiting list story
/ independent.co.uk/news/health/tr… Sex-based campaigners have tried for years to get the facts about ‘gender surgery’ in legacy media, with fact checks and personal experiences

Now identity activists are trying to get ahead of the game by publishing them - but blaming those who’ve been trying to raise the alarm
/ Image
Jan 14 7 tweets 4 min read
Finally the BBC covers this, but with an example of total capture

One of the worst ever pieces of coverage out of the Washington bureau, and that includes its ludicrous outrage over Zooey Zephyr.

It’s a disgrace and hopefully will have to be a turning point.
/ Image It can’t bring itself to say male at all, not one time. It describes boys as female, and we’re never told this is about girls sharing a sports field and locker room with boys. The key question about the definition of sex is deliberately omitted.
/
bbc.co.uk/news/articles/…
Jan 7 8 tweets 4 min read
In the 36 hours after Max’s post and the @guardian report he highlighted, we’ve seen so much more non-UK conversation about how bias is embedded in language.

Max is on record on how ‘uncomfortable’ he is with ‘gender critical’ conversation, but naming Jan Crawford has had a
/ /positive effect. Affirmation is so profoundly embedded in global style guides that even starting the conversation is an achievement.

Thanks and well done also to @jeremymbarr for finding out about this little exchange.

We want news outlets to be in a position where instead
/ Image
Dec 27, 2025 12 tweets 7 min read
On the US equivalent of the Cass Review - published last month - which UK legacy broadcasters here haven’t yet looked at.

Useful (and unusually self-aware) analysis in @Newsweek, by a US bioethicist and philosopher, and a US psychiatrist and associate professor.
/ Image Both were contributors to the US review, and both understand how the politicisation of ‘gender’ protocols means that actual children’s health can come second to a politically tribal approach.

Basically, they want you to read it despite its origin.
/
newsweek.com/liberals-shoul…
Dec 9, 2025 9 tweets 3 min read
There are lots of things wrong with this. It’s the correspondent hit on Woman’s Hour on Sandie Peggie.

It treats the Tribunal judgment in Sandie Peggie as if it were equal to or even superior to the Supreme Court judgment, and as if it had bearing on what other employers do.
/ It’s not an ‘overlap’ - the judgment ignores the SC on what makes a women’s space, a women’s space - the fact that only women are allowed in.

It also commits the error - as most media coverage has (see BBC Online👇), of starting its background timeline with the changing room
/ Image
Nov 29, 2025 8 tweets 3 min read
BBC thinking after FWS was that it would be enough to put ‘trans’ in front of ‘woman’ to satisfy due accuracy’. Some stories had exactly that edit but female pronouns were still used. It’s moved a long way from that - due to sustained public pressure 🙏
/ bbc.co.uk/news/articles/… This has the clarity of ‘biological male’ and uses neither male or female pronouns. Only this year she/her was being used for Abbi Taylor, Joanna Rowland-Stuart and Zoe Watts.

It’s not far enough but it is a proper and substantive shift. We thank (and the BBC should thank)
/ Image
Nov 27, 2025 12 tweets 4 min read
If any gratitude you feel to Scotcast for platforming Naomi Cunningham is putting you off complaining about the trigger warning, don’t let it. It must never happen again.

Here are the Editorial Guidelines on Harm or Offence. Screenshots follow.

bbc.com/editorialguide… 5.4.34👇

This applies equally to any content describing men as women. It has never been applied to such content.

1 Naomi Cunningham is being treated differently

2 There is the implication that she is being offensive.
/ Image
Oct 25, 2025 8 tweets 4 min read
Please read from @BorisSpider14, who’s a campaigner in the US. The scale of US medicalisation is not hidden from families, but is curated and hidden from politicians and the media. Legacy media in particular will rely on and report only ‘official’ data and won’t pick up
/ /the work of whistleblower or independent/alternative journalists (see the failure to show any interest at all in the WPATH files by @_CryMiaRiver as a prime example). The reason an organisation like say the BBC is so far behind (and can never catch up) is because they
/ Image
Oct 19, 2025 4 tweets 2 min read
Even readers new to the issue will be shocked by this.

Let’s see if this tribunal makes network news. Sandy Peggie didn’t.

‘When the nurses protested, they were stunned to be told they had to be educated by Henderson to become more inclusive, the tribunal will be told’
/ Image dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1…
Oct 6, 2025 7 tweets 4 min read
This content, featuring a middle-aged man, is specifically directed at young people. It propagandises innate, fixed, gender identity and the idea that no one can change ‘who you are’.

To do this it weaponises sympathy for him as a supposed victim of ‘conversion therapy’.
/ Image It’s profoundly cynical, generated for ABC Queer (@ abcqueer Insta) - ‘home of stories *and advice* for young LGBTQIA+ Australians’

Middle-aged men need the concept of trans kids to exist. Researchers like Anja Ravine need ‘trans kids’ to exist.
/
abc.net.au/news/2025-10-0…
Sep 25, 2025 4 tweets 2 min read
‘I draw the line at the belligerent slogan’

‘Dawkins told @Telegraph that the trans-activist community had become ‘astonishingly vicious’, hounding people out of their jobs and calling for women who disagreed with them to be decapitated and physically assaulted’
/ Image ‘So powerful has this postmodern counter-factualism become, that newspapers refer to ‘her penis’ as a matter of unremarked routine’

‘I feel very strongly about the subversion of scientific truth’

By Science Editor @sarahknapton
/ Image
Sep 10, 2025 5 tweets 3 min read
Mark Rowley of the Met defends the arrest of Graham Linehan.

It’s weak in itself but he gets away with it because although @Emmabarnett is unafraid to push him hard, she seems completely unaware that ‘discretion’ is always applied to complaints from women about transactivists.
/ It was intro’d fairly, pushed hard and the background on GL was great. But how is it possible after years of abuse, and two weeks of prominent women coming out and relating their horrific experiences, that flagship teams still aren’t aware of this chronic bias?

/ Image
Image
Image
Sep 4, 2025 10 tweets 4 min read
‘Journalists have an obligation to ensure that a report of what was heard in court is accurate and not misleading’

There’ve been several reports today which breach that clause of IPSO guidance.

This in @guardian is one of them, and not just because it says Brooks is a woman.
/ Image It also doesn’t report any of the admissions Brooks made under cross-examination about his own behaviour.

It’s not just an IPSO issue. Court reporting has ‘absolute privilege’ (ie is not vulnerable to defamation) if it is both accurate *and fair*
/
theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/s…
Sep 3, 2025 4 tweets 3 min read
Here’s the R4 Today interview with Max Hill and Shami Chakrabarti on Glinner.

The utility of this programme lies its general obeisance to the official Overton window of any controversial story.

In this case we are not permitted to discuss the imbalance of response: the
/ /infiltration of police forces and police institutions by transactivism; the strange power of a few apparently vindictive individuals across years of complaints; or the under-prosecuted extreme violence of threats of dismemberment, rape, and murder made by gender activists.
/ Image
Image
Image
Image
Aug 11, 2025 4 tweets 2 min read
It’s this case, and it’s the prosecutor who’s made the point about pronouns.

‘A transgender Metropolitan Police volunteer officer accused of rape will be referred to by his biological sex throughout his trial’
/ Image Here’s the link



and here’s what the BBC did telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/08/1…
Aug 6, 2025 4 tweets 2 min read
There is no low to which the @Independent will not stoop Image Story will be posted in a sequence of screenshots
/ Image
Image
Aug 4, 2025 5 tweets 3 min read
We’ll show the extent of the international media blackout on Giggle vs Tickle, but first - this is the domestic Australian news agency, @AAPNewswire

‘Ms Grover denies findings she rejected Roxanne Tickle from the app because she did not look like a c*sgender woman’ (our *)
/ Image It’s free to read with an email address.

The language is captured throughout.

However, at least it is coverage, and fairly full coverage, and it includes a picture of Tickle.


/aapnews.aap.com.au/glance/news/wo…
Aug 1, 2025 5 tweets 2 min read
There are two legal firsts here. It’s so newsworthy but has been slightly under the radar because pool isn’t a ‘big’ sport.

The fact that as well as an FWS first, it’s the first in 15 years to use the sport exception in the EA2010 is a great story.
/ Coverage will come we’re sure, but it should have been in the diary. Also if there’s an ‘activist’ sport newsroom and a non-sports editor asks ‘is this worth it?’ then they’re likely to get told no, it’s niche, or they haven’t the resources (thinking of broadcasters here).
/ Image
Image
Jul 31, 2025 7 tweets 3 min read
‘Some 3,000 children and teenagers who identify as trans will be ­recruited to the study, led by a team at King’s College London, which will ­follow them for five years’

@thetimes
@eleanorhayward Image ‘All under-18s referred to specialist NHS gender clinics will be invited to join the trial, Pathways Horizon, which has no lower age limit and *will run alongside a study of puberty blockers’*



@Transgendertrd
/ thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/…Image
Jul 30, 2025 4 tweets 2 min read
The BBC ‘trans’ page, just now, because it won’t put a trans tag on stories that shows trans people in a negative light. Always the victim, never the perpetrator.

There are two stories that should be on this page tonight that are missing.
/ Does it matter? Of course. There are at least nine stories involving serious sexual crime, murder or child abuse, by trans-identified people in the past couple of years, that don’t appear on the trans page. How can the public assess risk - and by the public, that includes
/ Image