Karl Kanthak Profile picture
Strategic research, analysis, & communication. Written, recorded and live presentations.
Nov 19 15 tweets 7 min read
🧵 THREAD: How the ACIP Deviates from the USPSTF — and Why That Matters for Preventive Medicine
1️⃣
Preventive medicine is supposed to be founded on caution.
When you intervene on healthy people, acceptable harm must approach zero.
Therapeutic care is different — you accept risk to relieve suffering.
That’s the moral geometry of medicine. karlkanthak.substack.com/p/how-the-acip…Image 2️⃣
The USPSTF (U.S. Preventive Services Task Force) recognizes this.
Its analytic framework measures both benefit and harm at every stage of a preventive intervention.
Each arrow in their model is a question that must be answered with data, not faith. Image