More Births Profile picture
Ideas for reversing the collapse in global fertility, the greatest challenge of our age. Humanity is precious. HT to many great demographers and data analysts.
7 subscribers
Jun 1 9 tweets 6 min read
Resisting Birthrate Decline Through Culture: How one part of Japan bucks the trend
Japan's woes are well known, its population long in decline, it's economy stagnating.
Yet one prefecture continues to grow, not through policy but through a pronatal culture.
🧵, please share!Image
Image
Image
For more than forty years, Okinawa has had far higher fertility than any other prefecture (Stone, 2024).

But Okinawa's fertility used to be lower than the 🇯🇵 average (map by @yz7sha).

How did Okinawa manage to develop a pronatal culture, so different from the rest of Japan? 2/9 Image
Image
Apr 27 4 tweets 3 min read
A wonderful paper by Spears et al. showed that population reduction would have almost no impact on climate change.
Why? The main reason is that a baby born today will emit much less carbon than someone born a generation ago, and their children will emit even less carbon. 🧵 Image
Image
Image
Most previous forecasts of how population would impact climate assumed that carbon emissions would continue at the same rate indefinitely.
But per-capita carbon consumption has been falling sharply and will fall even faster in the future as renewable energy takes over. 2/4 Image
Image
Image
Feb 23 13 tweets 6 min read
Knowing birthrates are driven by a stack of factors lets us figure out what is happening in each country and what its 👶 bottlenecks are.
Things like beliefs about children, marriage, housing conditions, religiosity, work culture and more all have a big impact.
🧵, please share! Image In Spain (TFR 1.12), big hurdles include a huge fraction of young people living with their parents (driven by relatively poor employment for young people), the high share of housing that is small apartments, and declining faith among the young. 2/13
Feb 16 7 tweets 6 min read
Fertile No More!
For more than a hundred years, Ireland was both the most religious and the most fertile country in Europe.
But in recent years, Ireland experienced rapid secularization, and its fertility fell to just 1.47 in 2024.
What happened to 🇮🇪, and what comes next?
🧵!Image
Image
Image
First, a bit of history.
By the 1800s, Ireland had become almost entirely reliant on just one crop. Potato blight struck in 1845, and soon famine and mass migration cut the Irish population from 8 million down to 4. Ireland's population is still well below its 1845 peak. 2/7 Image
Image
Feb 9 9 tweets 5 min read
Getting old without ever getting rich
Thailand, with a TFR of just 0.95 in 2024, never even had a chance to get rich before its birthrate collapsed.
A look at how over-zealous family planning combined with cultural factors to put 🇹🇭 on a demographic downward spiral.
New 🧵!Image
Image
Image
Unlike its neighbors Korea and Taiwan, Thailand with a per-capita GDP of just $7000 never got to get rich before facing ultra-low birthrates.
For Thailand, the biggest cause was family planning run amok.
(Below, a wedding dress in Thailand made of entirely of condoms!) 2/9 Image
Jan 24 7 tweets 6 min read
The fastest fertility collapse in the world
In 2024 Chile recorded a fertility rate of just 0.88 births per woman, a drop of 23% in a year and 51% since 2015. No country has seen fertility fall as fast.
A look at how social changes have overwhelmed 🇨🇱 and threaten its future.
🧵!Image
Image
In recent years, Chile has been wracked with protest. In 2018, there were some 151 feminist protests across the country.
Then from 2019 to 2021, these mixed with large youth-led anti-establishment protests, which turned violent and often resulted in brutal police responses. 2/7 Image
Image
Image
Image
Jan 8 10 tweets 6 min read
South Dakota has the highest fertility of any US state and is the only state near replacement fertility.
Why is the birthrate so high in South Dakota and what lessons are there for the rest of America and the world?
🧵, please share! Image
Image
First is religiosity. Some 50% of South Dakotans rate religion as very important in their lives, well above the US average of around 37%.
Higher religiosity is associated with higher fertility both in the US and worldwide. 2/10 Image
Image
Image
Dec 30, 2024 4 tweets 3 min read
How many people really understand the age-fertility curve?
A groundbreaking 2023 paper by Geruso et al. showed that fecundability (the ability of a woman to get pregnant) peaks at age 20 and has already dropped by 2/3 by age 33. This is far younger than almost anyone knew. 1/4Image
Image
Image
The most important way to solve the fertility crisis is to educate young people on how crucial it is to get started early on family. Achieving financial and career success may take a long time, but family can't wait very long! 2/4
Dec 7, 2024 6 tweets 3 min read
The Baby-Money Index (BMI) beats GDP
There is a new metric that is much better than GDP for comparing nations! The "Baby-Money Index" combines national income (GNI) and fertility rate (TFR) to produce a better measure of a nation's true health. (via Atoms vs Bits)
🧵!Image We've known for a long time that GDP and GNI don't fully capture how the people of a country are doing.

In an effort to better measure human thriving the Human Development Index (HDI) was developed by the UN in 2010. 2/6 Image
Nov 28, 2024 8 tweets 6 min read
The first Thanksgiving marked the end of a period of hardship in which 52 of the Mayflower’s 102 passengers perished. Yet the 🚢 survivors now have 30 million descendants!
A look at how early America was able to grow so quickly, with lessons amid today's low birthrates!
🧵! Image
Image
Image
America's first three centuries produced the fastest sustained growth the world has ever known, as the US reached 76 million people by 1900. Most of this was due to high birthrates, not immigration!
Three factors drove this, religious belief, abundant space and early marriage. 2/ Image
Image
Nov 24, 2024 11 tweets 7 min read
Why South Korea’s fertility is so low, and how it will be hard to reverse
The Land of the Morning Calm has a fertility of just 0.72 births per woman, lowest in the world. But low fertility in 🇰🇷 is caused by many factors that will be extremely hard to change.
🧵, please share!Image
Image
Image
On Halloween 2022, in the Itaewon District of Seoul, a crowd crush killed 156 people and shocked the country.
That incident is a good analogy for both educational and economic pressure, and the literal crowding of the whole country into one city, that is crushing fertility. 2/11 Image
Image
Nov 18, 2024 6 tweets 5 min read
POPULATION GROWTH BROUGHT ABUNDANCE, NOT SCARCITY
Most people get the relationship between population and prosperity completely backward.
A look at the revolutionary work of Julian Simon, Marian Tupy and Gale Pooley showing how population growth made us richer.
🧵, please share!Image Intuitively, it feels like more people should mean less for everyone. That is how most natural ecosystems work. We learned in school how the population of the rabbits (the resource) crashes when the population of foxes (the consumer) grows.
But humans aren't like that at all! 2/6 Image
Nov 3, 2024 8 tweets 5 min read
How "Smart Growth" Causes Housing Shortages and Hurts Birthrates
Portland, Oregon has a fertility rate of just 1.0 amid high housing prices and a shortage of single-family homes. Meanwhile, 98.9% of Oregon is rural!
How policies meant to stop sprawl are hurting birthrates, a 🧵!Image
Image
It is no secret that the United States currently has a housing shortage that is contributing to low birthrates. The relationship between house affordability and fertility can easily be seen in maps.
But much of this scarcity is artificially caused by limits on suburbs. 2/8 Image
Image
Oct 17, 2024 4 tweets 2 min read
International adoptions have fallen 95% in the United States, from 22,991 in 2004 to just 1,275 in 2023.

It's not a problem of demand. Many Americans would love to adopt internationally. But there are few children available to adopt with plunging birthrates in most countries. 🧵 Image It's not just adoptions to the US. This is a worldwide phenomenon. International adoption is almost impossible now.

Although abuse sometimes cited, the main reason many 'sending' countries including China and Russia have ended foreign adoption is collapsing fertility. 2/4 Image
Image
Sep 24, 2024 12 tweets 6 min read
Can advanced economies have healthy birthrates?
It seems like an iron rule: as countries develop, their birthrates fall to really low levels.

But it's not set in stone. Economic success and healthy birthrates can go together!

A thread, please share!Image There is no question that the competition between work and family is fierce, leading some to suggest that capitalism itself is incompatible with healthy birthrates.

Can we have both economic success and healthy fertility? Yes! Let's explore. 2/12
Sep 20, 2024 7 tweets 6 min read
When will the UK get serious about falling birthrates?
Fertility rates in the UK have plummeted in recent years to just 1.43 births per woman in 2023.

Fifty years of low fertility are dimming Britain's future, yet its leaders seem blithely unaware.
🧵, please share!Image
Image
Image
When asked this week about falling UK fertility, PM Keir Starmer had a hearty laugh. "What can you do?" he asked.

But British women when surveyed say they want around 2.2 children each, so a TFR of just 1.43 reflects both national crisis and a lot of personal heartbreak. 2/ Image
Sep 2, 2024 6 tweets 4 min read
Understanding plunging Nordic fertility
For years, the Nordic countries had healthy birthrates that were the envy of Europe, helped in part by some of the most generous family policies in the world. No longer.

A look at how cultural forces can overpower pronatal policy.
🧵!Image
Image
Image
In 2015, the fertility of the Nordics averaged 1.76 births per woman, similar the 1.84 level of the US.

By 2023, the fertility of the Nordic countries was just 1.44, well below the 1.62 of the US today.

This though Nordic child policy is what parents in 🇺🇸 dream of. Why? 2/6 Image
Aug 30, 2024 6 tweets 4 min read
From the Wall Street Journal yesterday, we see the headline, Parenting Is Hazardous to Your Health, the Surgeon General Warns.

But this headline is almost certainly false. Studies overwhelmingly show that both mothers and fathers live longer than non-parents on average!
🧵.Image
Image
A study of 4 million Swedish men and women found that parents with children generally live longer than those without, and those with two children generally live longer than those with one child. 2/6Image
Image
Aug 24, 2024 8 tweets 6 min read
Elevating the Status of Motherhood Solves Low Birthrates: The Extraordinary Case of Mongolia
For 68 years, Mongolian leaders have given the Order of Maternal Glory to mothers. This raised the status of motherhood and helped forge a remarkably pronatal culture.
🧵, please share!Image
Image
Mongolia's pro-motherhood culture stands out on a fertility map. Fertility in Mongolia has consistently been 2-3 times(!) higher than neighboring areas in recent years and it has been increasing over the past 20 years, even as its neighbors have seen birthrates plunge! 2/8
Image
Image
Aug 17, 2024 11 tweets 6 min read
The Long Shadow of China's One Child Policy
China's one-child policy is over. Yet the fertility in China keeps falling, and was just 1.02 births per woman in 2023.

A look at China's history of brutal population control, and how echos of past policies reverberate today.
🧵.Image
Image
China's one-child policy was finally ended in 2015. One impetus for its ending was the uproar over the forced abortion of Feng Jianmei in 2012, after graphic pictures went viral in China. 2/11
Image
Image
Aug 14, 2024 11 tweets 7 min read
Why birthrates keep falling in Canada
Canada has enacted many pro-family policies, from parental leave to low-cost childcare. Yet its TFR has plunged from 1.60 to 1.25 in eight years.
What factors are driving this and how can 🇨🇦 and the rest of us change course?
🧵, please share.Image
Image
For much of the 20th century, fertility rates in Canada were higher than in the United States. But now the fertility rate in 🇨🇦 is 23% lower than in 🇺🇸, which itself is at an all-time low.
There are several cultural and housing factors behind Canada's ultra-low birthrates. 2/11
Image
Image