Tymofiy Mylovanov Profile picture
President, Kyiv School of Economics; Minister of economy, Ukraine, 2019-2020; Associate professor, University of Pittsburgh
89 subscribers
Dec 4 5 tweets 2 min read
Kelin, Russia Ambassador to UK, on peace: We stand for diplomatic solution, but we don’t want on our border a puppet state created by Western governments, adversarial to us, where the Russian language is discriminated and the Russian Orthodox Church has been ousted. 1/ Q: Most of the world would say you guys started this fight.

Kelin: That is not true. It is said by those who do not want to learn history. Things started in 2014 after the illegal turnover of the legal government in Kyiv by people based on Nazi ideology. 2/
Dec 3 10 tweets 2 min read
Europe is rearming at a speed not seen in decades.

SAFE, the new €150bn EU defence fund, already filled: 19 states applied, Poland alone asks for €43.7bn, writes The Economist.

1/ Image SAFE + the National Escape Clause open a massive spending channel.

NEC lets states add 1.5% of GDP to defence over four years, unlocking roughly €650bn.

This is the spine of “Readiness 2030”.

2/
Dec 3 8 tweets 2 min read
Alexander Stubb writes in FA the post-1945 order is collapsing. The world is shifting from rules to hard multipolar power.

Three blocs — West, East, South — now drive geopolitics. Middle powers like Brazil, India, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Turkey decide outcomes.

1/ Image He warns the West has 5–10 years to prove it can act without double standards, share real power and treat the global South as an equal partner. If it fails, the next order will run on deals, not rules and small states will get crushed.

2/
Dec 3 9 tweets 2 min read
Germany spent decades preaching pacifism

Now it is buying tanks, building suicide drones, deploying troops abroad and committing €460 billion to rearmament

Isaac Stanley-Becker in The Atlantic shows how a nation built on “never again” is preparing for war again. 1/ Image Lt. Gen. Freuding says the old U.S.-led order is “really cut off.”

During Trump’s freeze on Ukraine weapons, Germany received no warning. German officers now hunt for information through their embassy because their Pentagon contacts have gone silent. 2/
Dec 3 4 tweets 1 min read
Rutte: If it takes too long for Russia to compromise in the peace talks, we’ll keep the weapon flow to Ukraine going, thanks to the U.S., Europe, and Canada.

Sanctions are also biting Russia. Together, they will pressure Putin and change his calculus. 1/ Rutte: I'm glad the U.S. president broke the deadlock with Putin and started the peace process.

Last night's talks were important, but I won’t comment on every step. We’re closely coordinating with the U.S. More steps are to come. 2/
Dec 2 6 tweets 1 min read
Russia enters new US sanctions on Rosneft and Lukoil with serious economic cracks.

KSE Institute shows oil earnings in October fell to $13.1B, as Moscow sold barrels at $54, far below global prices.

1/ Image Russia’s budget hole keeps widening.

January–October deficit hit 4.2T rubles and will likely break the revised 5.7T target in December’s spending surge.

The Kremlin now borrows at record speed: 4.5T rubles in domestric government bonds already, up 135% year-on-year.

2/
Dec 2 5 tweets 1 min read
Andriy Yermak’s quit changed Ukraine’s peace team - The Telegraph.

Yermak led negotiations, rejected any territorial concessions.

Now figures like spy chief Budanov, who has already met US Secretary Driscoll and speaks of Trump’s “crucial role” in ending the war, will lead. 1/ Image NABU raided Yermak’s home over a $100M energy graft scandal.

Hours later, he quit as head of the presidential administration. His exit ends years of dominance inside Zelenskyy’s circle.

2/
Dec 2 4 tweets 2 min read
Putin: If Europe starts a war, then soon Moscow will have no one to negotiate with

Russia has no intention of going to war with Europe. But if Europe starts a war, Russia is ready right now.

[Russia is exhausted after three years of war in Ukraine and not ready to face NATO] 1/ Putin: Europe has removed itself from the Ukrainian settlement.

The Europeans have no peaceful agenda and are now hindering US efforts to resolve the situation.

They are living under the illusion of their original goal of inflicting a strategic defeat on Russia.

2/
Dec 2 5 tweets 2 min read
Zelenskyy: The hardest issues on peace talks are three: territory, frozen Russian assets in Europe and security guarantees.

I can’t decide on EU-held funds, only discuss them with partners. We need strong guarantees from the U.S., Europe and others.

1/ Q: Some say you face a choice: a bad deal now or a worse one later after Russia’s offensive in Pokrovsk. What’s your response?

Zelenskyy: There are no easy decisions. I can make tough ones, but any deal must be fair, transparent and never made behind Ukraine’s back.

2/
Dec 2 8 tweets 2 min read
37-year-old Mykola Zakhozhyi left home on his motorcycle to check Russian positions near his Kyiv suburb. He never returned.

Russian soldiers seized him in the woods, kicked his head until he blacked out and poured diesel on him, threatening to burn him and others – NYT. 1/ Image Russian troops moved Mykola through camps and jails. Guards lined prisoners up and made them run a gauntlet of kicks and punches.

They slammed men into metal door frames and jumped on their backs as they lay on the ground. 2/
Dec 2 6 tweets 3 min read
Kasparov: Recall ambassadors, low down diplomatic ties, but Europe is doing business as usual. More than 500K visas were issued for Russians last year. Putin's laughing at you.

You want to be serious? Send French military jets to Ukraine. Show you’re willing to take a hit. 1/ Kasparov: We pray for Ukrainian heroism, but you can't do it forever. Europe preparing for war — behind this is one thought: how can we look so strong for Putin to be afraid to attack us?

They can't comprehend that European soldiers will be dying. I find it unacceptable. 2/
Dec 1 4 tweets 2 min read
Hodges: Europe and Ukraine know the U.S. has a primary interest, which is business with Russia. Europe sees it cannot count on the U.S.

Unsatisfactory outcome for Ukraine could send millions more Ukrainian refugees into Central and Western Europe. 1/ Hodges: The administration's approach has always been doomed from the start because they didn't care about the origin, history or geography, and approached it as a massive real estate deal.

Rubio said in the beginning, Ukraine, you're gonna have to give up some territory. 2/
Dec 1 4 tweets 2 min read
Q: Is the U.S. cutting Europe out of the talks and will Witkoff push Ukraine into concessions?

Kallas: I’m worried the pressure will fall on the victim — Ukraine. Russia started this war, continues it and hits civilians daily. Any deal must keep that reality front and center. 1/ Q: Does the EU reparations loan hurt peace talks?

Kallas: No. It strengthens Europe’s leverage over Moscow. Russia owes Ukraine damages.

Using frozen Russian state assets is the right base for reparations. I understand Belgium’s concerns, but we need to move forward. 2/
Dec 1 5 tweets 2 min read
Belarusian opposition leader, Tsikhanouskaya: Helping Ukraine is a priority.

Its victory is crucial for many countries, especially Belarus. As long as Lukashenko serves Putin, he remains a threat to Ukraine, the EU, and keeps Belarus under Russia’s pressure. 1/ Tsikhanouskaya: The ideal scenario is Ukraine getting all support to secure a just peace. Russia turns inward and stops backing Lukashenko.

A democratic transition begins in Belarus, free from Moscow’s pressure and no longer propped up by the Kremlin. 2/
Dec 1 11 tweets 2 min read
Historian Antony Beevor: "For Russians, conspicuous cruelty is a necessary weapon of war."

The atrocities in Ukraine aren't aberrations — they're rooted in centuries of uniquely brutal warfare.

And the West failed to see it coming — The Telegraph. 1/ Image Russian mass rape, torture, and murder in Bucha aren't the work of rogue soldiers — they're systematic. The 19,500 missing Ukrainian children show what Russian conquest really means. 2/
Dec 1 6 tweets 1 min read
Europe faces a hard choice: sovereignty or dependence on Trump’s America.

Three times Trump pushed Ukraine to concede to Russia. Three times EU leaders scrambled to stop him. The transatlantic relationship is effectively over, writes Martin Sandbu for FT.

1/ Image Will Europe act as a rule-maker or accept life as a rule-taker under Washington?

EU must build a plan for EU–US decoupling to limit how MAGA America can pressure Europe again.

2/
Dec 1 4 tweets 2 min read
Kuleba: There are tasks and missions in life, when you just cannot afford having plan B.

In the case of Russia's war against Ukraine, when the conflict is existential, having no plan B is the best way for you to try to defend yourself and to survive. 1/ Kuleba: I appreciate everything that has been done for Ukraine. This is not me saying that no one did anything to help Ukraine. But history is ruthless and we are judged by whether our deeds were sufficient. Enormous effort was done, but it was still not enough. 2/
Dec 1 5 tweets 1 min read
“Drone operators are hunted. You feel it from your first day.”

As casualties rise, Ukraine relies on civilians to fill drone units. Training lasts just 15 days before deployment near the front. Dozens of women now serve or train, with more joining monthly — The Guardian.

1/ Image Dasha, 37, commands a mixed unit near the eastern front. “It’s not about proving anything. It’s about necessity. Everyone is stretched. Everyone is adapting.”

2/
Dec 1 8 tweets 3 min read
Zelenskyy: The peace plan looks better now. The points related to territory were discussed for 6.5 hours yesterday.

Tomorrow I will receive the US feedback. Then the US will receive Russia’s reaction. After that, we will see approximately where we stand. 1/ Zelenskyy: Russia’s military suffered its largest losses in 4 years this October — 25,500 soldiers killed. 2/
Dec 1 10 tweets 2 min read
NATO is preparing for a bad scenario: defending Europe from Russian invasion with limited US support.

A November wargame in Romania's Carpathian mountains revealed the stark reality and the dangerous gaps Europe must urgently fill — Bloomberg. 1/ Image A French brigade deployed in Transylvania showed what NATO's future looks like as Trump reduces US forces in Europe.

European soldiers under French command defended the continent largely alone. Romanian officials says reinforcements could take weeks to arrive. 2/
Dec 1 4 tweets 2 min read
Putin is not negotiating. He is stalling the West.

Dan Hoffman, former CIA station chief: Putin has not shown any hesitancy to engage in negotiations with the Trump Administration because talks help him avoid sanctions and block weapons for Ukraine. 1/ Q: What could come from this round of talks?

Hoffman: Russia declined a ceasefire, made no concessions, and shows no interest in real negotiations. The talks serve only one purpose for Moscow: delay. 2/