Tymofiy Mylovanov Profile picture
President, Kyiv School of Economics; Minister of economy, Ukraine, 2019-2020; Associate professor, University of Pitt...
Jul 10 12 tweets 3 min read
For the first time since 2022, Ukraine has a coherent theory of victory. Instead of grinding down the Russian army at huge cost, Kyiv now destroys Russia's capacity to wage war.

It targets the revenue, fuel, and the supply lines that feed the front — Christian Caryl, FP. 1/ Image Former DM Zagorodnyuk calls this strategic neutralization. Render Russian forces ineffective by cutting their support, rather than storming their positions.

The proof of concept is the Black Sea Fleet. Naval drones drove it from Sevastopol without a single Ukrainian warship. 2/
Jul 10 5 tweets 2 min read
Browder: Putin started a war because he stole so much money that he became afraid of his own people.

The easiest way to stop people turning against you is to create a foreign enemy. That is Machiavelli 101. 1/ Browder: If Putin used a nuclear weapon, he still would not win the war.

Ukraine is too large and too dispersed. China and the Global South would step away, and Putin would become a fully defined war criminal. 2/
Jul 10 4 tweets 2 min read
Browder: Ukrainians were never Russia's enemy.

The Kremlin manufactured that enemy. It called Ukrainians Nazis and fascists and accused them of things they never did. Crimea then sent Putin's approval ratings through the roof. 1/ Browder: Putin has been stealing since his days in the St. Petersburg mayor's office.

Putin and about a thousand people around him stole one trillion dollars from the Russian state before the war. 2X
Jul 10 4 tweets 2 min read
Browder: Putin will never negotiate an end to the war.

Russia does not do diplomacy. Everything is win or lose. Nobody should negotiate with Putin because he will stop only when somebody stops him. 1/ Browder: Putin can't leave power. If he ends this war, he won't be in power anymore.

He needs the war to stay in power, and he needs power to stay alive. That is why negotiations aren't going to go anywhere. 2X
Jul 10 6 tweets 2 min read
McFaul: Trump used to tell Zelenskyy: You don't have the cards. Zelenskyy answered: This is not a game, this is a war.

Now Trump sees that Zelenskyy has cards. The balance of power is changing, and that is why he may be more willing to help Ukraine. 1/ McFaul: The West's biggest mistake was worrying too much about what Putin thought.

That started long before the full-scale invasion. It was a mistake at the Bucharest NATO summit, during the war against Georgia and in the response that followed. 2/
Jul 10 5 tweets 2 min read
McFaul: Putin is weak.

A strong leader gets information and makes new decisions based on it. Putin doesn't.

He gets information only from the FSB, SVR and the red folders they prepare for him. 1/ McFaul: A strong leader does not fear independent society or Alexei Navalny. Putin feared Navalny. He fears independent organizations. Fear is a sign of weakness, not strength. 2/
Jul 10 7 tweets 3 min read
Mark Carney: Russia is a direct adversary.

The threats we face are changing rapidly, from hybrid warfare to hypersonic missiles and autonomous warfare. 1/ Carney: Burdens are shifting away from the United States, towards Canada and Europe.

Before I became Prime Minister 18 months ago, we spent 1.5% of GDP on defense. It now goes to 4% in the next two years. 2/
Jul 10 7 tweets 2 min read
Saakashvili, ex-president of Georgia: The Ankara agreement gives Ukraine a Patriot license, but bureaucracy and production setup will take months.

Ukrainian Patriots will not appear before next year, Ukrainska Pravda. 1/ Image Saakashvili: Putin trapped himself. If he agrees to a ceasefire, Russia becomes a North Korea and a satellite of China.

While Putin remains in power, there will be no ceasefire; the war will sharply escalate. 2/
Jul 10 8 tweets 2 min read
The billionaires who got rich under Putin are starting to get nervous.

Andrey Melnichenko, Russia’s biggest industrialist, says the war is breaking Russia's economy — and if nothing changes, the country ends up broke, isolated, or run by China, The Economist. 1/ Image Melnichenko is not anti-Putin opposition. He is an insider whose factories supported the war economy. Like most oligarchs, he lived by Putin’s rules: make money, but keep out of politics.

He speaks now because tycoons can no longer ignore the rot. 2/
Jul 10 9 tweets 2 min read
Putin is pretending he is crazy and will never stop.

He is a rational player. At some point he will stop. But first, Russia must feel five to ten times more pain than it does now, I told the WSJ. 1/ Image Ukraine struck Russia's largest refinery in Omsk, more than 1,500 miles from Ukrainian-controlled territory.

Russia left Omsk without air defence because it considered the refinery out of Ukraine's reach. Ukrainian drones hit its crude distillation unit. 2/
Jul 9 5 tweets 2 min read
NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation Vandier: Patriot production is limited — the US can't supply the Gulf, Pacific, and Europe at once.

We need more from all sources. Ukrainians are already building their own ABM system. 1/ Vandier: NATO acquires massive deep precision strike ammunition. Expensive weapons hit hardened targets.

Cheap mass-produced ammo saturates the front. Any massive troop gathering sits under a strike umbrella. That's deterrence by denial.

2/
Jul 9 13 tweets 3 min read
Zaluzhnyi: Do not assume Russia has lost the war.

Russia has not achieved its original political objectives. But it still fights, occupies substantial Ukrainian territory, and shows no intention of accepting terms that would mean defeat, — for Telegraph. 1/ Image Zaluzhnyi: Ukraine cannot yet claim outright victory either.

Kyiv has stopped Russia’s main goals and damaged its economy and military. But Ukraine still depends heavily on Western money, weapons, technology, and air defense. 2/
Jul 9 15 tweets 3 min read
A Russian ex-convict spent a decade in Ukraine under a fake identity, built weapons for the front, and married three women who never knew his real name.

Now Interpol wants him, and Ukraine may hand him over. His real name is Ruslan Puptaev, Babel. 1/ Image Born 1987 in Kyrgyzstan, raised in Russia’s Ulyanovsk region. Convicted twice — theft at 16, assault at 19.

Russian courts gave him 9 years. 2/
Jul 9 11 tweets 3 min read
For the first time since the 2022 mobilisation, ordinary Russians are scared. Petrol is rationed and Ukrainian drones hit refineries far from the front.

55% now say people around them feel anxious, up from 40% a year ago. The war has reached everyone — The Economist. 1/ Image Drone attacks once hit only cities like Kursk and Belgorod. On July 6th Ukrainian drones struck Russia's largest refinery in Omsk, 2,500 km from the front.

The southbound Moscow trains that once carried families to the sea now run spookily empty, crowded with uniforms. 2/
Jul 9 5 tweets 2 min read
Stubb: Russia won't end this war from economic pain or battlefield losses — 1 dead Ukrainian to 8 Russians.

What changes it: Russian population turning against the war. Oil strikes, cancelled Crimea summer camps, internet shutdowns. Pressure forces ceasefire and negotiations. 1/ Stubb: US foreign policy is transactional right now — they'd say so themselves.

They sanctioned Rosneft earlier, hitting Russia hard. Now they're reversing that decision.

2/
Jul 9 7 tweets 3 min read
Volker, ex US-NATO Amb.: Zelenskyy has figured out how to deal with Trump.

By making clear that Ukraine wants a ceasefire and wants to end the war, he puts the spotlight on Putin, who doesn't. That gives Trump the best chance to pressure Russia. 1/ Volker: Europe needs Ukraine inside NATO. Russia is a threat to all of Europe.

Ukraine is already one of Europe's most capable countries in defending Europe, fighting Russia and producing the defence technology, industry and know-how everybody will need. 2/
Jul 9 11 tweets 2 min read
Petr Pavel: Ukraine may have about two months to force talks before Russia’s September elections.

After Sept. 20, Putin could declare a general mobilisation and shrink the window for peace, — The Telegraph. 1/ Image Pavel: Putin is unlikely to mobilise before parliamentary elections because it would be deeply unpopular. But once the vote is over, the political cost changes. 2/
Jul 9 7 tweets 3 min read
Stubb: Finland and Sweden wouldn't be in NATO without Russia's attack on Ukraine.

Europe wouldn't be ramping up its industry without the lessons learned from Ukraine. NATO needs Ukraine as much as Ukraine needs NATO.

1/ Stubb: Three years ago, if someone told me Europe would be doing tens of billions in European defense industry deals and actually sharing the burden — I would have taken it and run.

2/
Jul 9 13 tweets 3 min read
More than 70,000 women serve in Ukraine's military. Around 10,000 fight on the front line: medics, snipers, tank drivers, drone pilots. Every one is a volunteer.

The Times spoke to 3 of them about the war they fight against Russia and the war they fight against sexism at home.1/ Image Alya's first patient had both legs smashed by an artillery shell. He wasn't screaming. She noticed two things: how young he was, and how calm.

So she matched him — pulse, breathing, talked him through the painkiller. She never learned his name. She doesn't know if he's alive.2/
Jul 9 7 tweets 2 min read
At 69, Tetiana Tepliuk defended Azovstal under full encirclement, then spent 7 months in Russian captivity. Now 74 — she is back on active duty.

Soldiers call her "Khreshchena." The Godmother. — U24.

1/ Image In the bunkers, she refused to eat her own rations.

Khreshchena: "Every evening, we were given a spoonful of sugar and a spoonful of honey. I saved it and gave it to two soldiers — the sugar to one, and the honey to the other."

2/
Jul 8 5 tweets 2 min read
Applebaum: Putin's war has finally reached Moscow.

Muscovites have lost cell service, struggled to use ATMs and come under drone attacks.

They understand Russia isn't winning. Putin won't fall tomorrow, but it has shifted the mood of Russia's business and political elite. 1/ Applebaum: Russia's system will eventually change.

Nobody knows who will succeed Putin or how that person will be chosen. There is no Politburo or ruling party to pick the next leader. The successor will emerge from Russia's elite groups. 2/