Share this page!

Enter URL or ID to Unroll

You can paste full URL like: https://x.com/threadreaderapp/status/1644127596119195649
or just the ID like: 1644127596119195649

How to get URL link on X (Twitter) App

  1. On the Twitter thread, click on or icon on the bottom
  2. Click again on or Share Via icon
  3. Click on Copy Link to Tweet
  4. Paste it above and click "Unroll Thread"!
  5. More info at Twitter Help
Paimon Profile picture
Paimon
@Paimon_goetia
Nov 23 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
Biggest advt of greatness of Nehru is that Chaddis have now governed for nearly same time as Nehru & not achieved even tenth of what he did.

Nehru's govt tamed rivers like Damodar (which was called sorrow of Bengal), built dams and irrigation projects like Hirakud & Bhakara Nangal - on whose back Green revolution happened, built industry like steel & locomotive work on whose back India runs even today, heavy engg & space program which ensure that wignats can only seethe on internet as their genocidal fantasies can be returned in kind,
Feb 28 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
Extractive state is one of the tell of "soon to be a failed state".

India is never going to recover from Hindutva & Sanghis.They literally created same economic & social situations that had led to fall of states from bronze Age till now.

Neither will west recover from Nazis. RW need to banned from any kind of scholarship.

They read Roman history & jump to "REEE wahmyn bad, hoe, not reproducing. Barbarians are at gates REEE" overlooking centuries of economic rapine, massacre of families of loyal Foederati, & attempted genocide of Goths before that.
Feb 27, 2024 • 7 tweets • 2 min read
I don't think so as assigning all blame for fall of civilization to women due to them following their biological nature overlooks the reason which created situations where their biological nature selected for 1 in 17 mates.

It is usually patriarchs who create such situation. Religious scribes, mostly being incellic wordcellers on payroll of those patriarchs;& religion' rise happening when collapse was already underway is blind to precedence.

A transition from Hunting Gathering to Agriculture was happening during this time.
Dec 15, 2023 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
Nothing like that.

He was a dehati gangu neech & behaved like a dehati gangu neech.

The type of crab mentality that he showed is there even today in dehat. It is just that western enlightenment & socioeconomic prowess, which is superior to best jeets can field, liberated jeets. Even today in villages, you would witness kanging on sub sub sub castes & intercaste animosities are on par.

The GC/UC common identity is strictly urban, & forged by govt discriminating against them in formative years itself (after +2)

OP is also ignorant of how world works.
Jun 29, 2023 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
Yes, it is not the origin. Origin lies in geography.

IVC was extremely secure compared to Mesopotamia. Mesopotamia was in plains, while you need to cross a Hindukush mountain range, or dast-e-lut & kharan desert, or impassable gangu forests to even reach IVC. There are very few evidences of wars & it is postulated to be a merchant-priest driven society.

Merchant dominant societies (not one in which warriors or intellectuals double up as one) gravitate towards caste. Take example of modern west.
Jun 18, 2023 • 6 tweets • 2 min read
In case of Baniyas, it would be straight - the dhandho seth mentality. I would explain how spirit of moneylending work in case of others.

So you are a Brom in 7th century. You have two paths in front of you. Either embrace dehati stability & institutionalize rot in religion, OR you take the risky path of progress & maxxing human excellence- People before you have taken that path. What kind of person would choose what?

The one who has soul of a moneylender would choose Ist path. It is just that money in his case is not shekels but devotion & supplicants
Mar 14, 2023 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
That disorientation is due to Hindutva.

Both Mandal & Kamandal, and that dehati JP movement; are were crafted in chaddi workshops. Kamandal was necessary to ensure that UCs don't bolt.

Movement was mainly driven by neech (mainly Trad) Broms seething against cosmopolitan Broms. One should also note that persecution of Broms Trad AF.

Have said it many times, as per Hinduism, an ideal Brahmin has to live in poverty & subsist on bhiksha from 5 grahstas, and physically & mentally stunt himself & his children by crazy dietary restrictions.
Mar 7, 2023 • 4 tweets • 1 min read
That is completely different point and you are pointing out who patronized Hindi, while I am taking in term of power structure associated with a language.

Hindi is still a vehicle of Indianization in Madurai, but it is a vehicle of Kulakization in ganguland + When UC elites decided to go all-in on Hindi, power structure was different. English was on same level as French is today. It is great if you know it and it opens avenues to access new knowledge for yourself, but the jobs you can get & migration potential due to it was sparse.
Feb 7, 2023 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
This is not limited to just female foeticide/infanticide and sati.

The spike in "honour" Killing in Haryana was also a result of GoI giving women a share in ancestral property in 2005.

In Haryana, your village and neighboring villages were considered sagotra. This is another artifact of PPP STL of longhouse stability.

Though sagotra marriages were not hit even before, what women getting a share in ancestral property meant was that a women living next village is highly likely to claim property, rather than selling it to brothers
Sep 28, 2022 • 8 tweets • 2 min read
Right, but there is only one king per kingdom, & jeet kangs were rarely sovereign. I think mechanism is slightly different.

Individuals have differences, but collective' personality is determined by inherited culture as those not in lockstep are pared down with each generation. Thus we can extrapolate current temperament and culture to past.

Current Lemur article of faith is that Broms should remain in poverty & out of all secular jobs. I suspect it was not much different in old times too.

Lundlords at that time too would had been genocidal
Sep 16, 2022 • 8 tweets • 2 min read
Traditions.

Children in India are birthed for sake of social security & karma token generation of birthing generation.

Thus subconsciously birthing generation promotes those things which would increase earning potential of birthed generation or bring them intangible goods. Actions which lets you monkey branch is discouraged.

In-fact not limited to India. Individualism is globally rare, and a product of cultural change caused by humanism.

Children have been produced for millenias for social security, or extra pair of hand in field & factories.
Sep 14, 2022 • 7 tweets • 2 min read
I hoped that I would find this question in @ahindu_ birather' long thread, but sadly it was absent. So here is promised critique with background.

@ahindu_ birather, feminists, and scholars all agree on one thing: Lasting marriage is built on oppression of females. That is true, but one should also know the evil they wished for.

Due to seeing daughter as a burden - they would eat into family resources and would take away wealth as dowry- and seeing marrying them in a family of lower status as loss of prestige; Pajeets and Pajeetas
Sep 14, 2022 • 4 tweets • 1 min read
Why should ancients be immune from blame?

Look at state of Indian society and its demographics. Their choice has been a transparently an inferior one.

Also you are missing an important part of argument. It is not just caste, but cultural complex around it that is suppressive. The best of Indians are raised to be betabuxx beyond imagination, and any sign of agency is crush at childhood - a domesticated animal whose survival is for sake of social security of past generation.

No great person would be born in your race, and if born, would be smothered.
Sep 13, 2022 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
It is horrendous. I consider it evil for following reason.

1. Suppose you find a group with outrageously abhorrent culture and practices, you either force them to change their ways or put them all to sword. This "Plz do not marry out of caste birather" is a sign of retardation. 2. It is dysgenic. India had & has castes of highway robbers and prostitutes. It did not occurred to any of the kangs here that this is an abomination, and it took Britishers to make highways somewhat safe.

Every society has caste type structure, but when you formalize it,