Ahmed Jamal Pirzada Profile picture
Economist at @BristolUni. Interested in macroeconomics. Retweet is not endorsement. From #Bhera/#Islamabad!
Aug 2, 2023 11 tweets 4 min read
With the Army Chief now part of SIFC Apex Committee, we may see the biggest regulatory capture of our history. The military, which already runs 50 commercial entities, is now effectively in a position to bypass any law which collides with its interests. dawn.com/news/1272211 According to the new law, the SIFC, which includes army chief, has the powers to "recommend, where appropriate, additional incentives or relaxation in the regulatory and policy framework" for any 'individual' investment proposal it deems fit. Image
May 21, 2023 10 tweets 4 min read
🧵 Here is one way to understanding why taxing 'reserves' may be a bad idea. To understand this, lets consider Lucky Cement as an example. Note that its balance sheet shows 132bn in 'reserves' (see at the very end). But what r these 'reserves'? That is where it gets interesting. Image In simple terms, these were profits that were not paid out in dividends but were held back. But held back as what? Note, Lucky Cement has only close to 1bn in cash and deposits. This only means these profits were invested in different types of assets - both short and long-term.
Jan 31, 2023 7 tweets 3 min read
🧵 Debt restructuring of 1999-2001: Pak external debt servicing burden back in 1998 was 41% of its foreign income (same as today). In the following year, Pak went on to seek debt relief from Paris Club. As a result, $3.3bn of its debt was rescheduled over 20 yrs with 10 yr grace. $610million worth of Eurobonds were also restructured in Dec 1999 to comply with the requirements of Paris Club that Pak should secure similar treatment from other private creditors. Another $415million which was owed to commercial banks was also restructured in the same month.
Dec 31, 2022 13 tweets 4 min read
🧵on Growth: As of 2018, Pakistan had one of the lowest capital-to-output ratio across the world. This has decreased from the peak of 3 in 1977 to 1.6 in 2018. This 🧵 explains why it matters and what we can do to reverse this. Let's first put this in perspective. The decline in capital-to-output ratio we see for Pak is the exact opposite of what we see in the region. The ratio has remained stable for India. However, both Bangladesh and China have accumulated much more capital over the same time period.
Dec 27, 2022 13 tweets 3 min read
🧵 Understanding DAR's Folly:
Imagine, u think rupee will loose its value by a significant amount in near future. It will then make sense for u to convert whatever rupees u hold to $. If everyone believes so and starts doing the same, rupee will indeed end up loosing its value. Govt will then be forced to increase both fuel and electricity prices. Inflation will increase, growth will slowdown, and the electorate will complain a lot more. Now here comes a tricky problem: should govt let it happen? or, prevent it with administrative measures?
Nov 25, 2022 6 tweets 2 min read
1/5: Let's be a bit more careful here. Bloomberg's model estimates the probability of default to be only around 17% just a month before default. So, if the model is to be trusted, 10% is pretty bad. 2/5: As far as CDS is concerned, the paper assessing Bloomberg's model clearly suggests that CDS is a better indicator than whatever the Bloomberg model is telling us. Hard to disagree when the model only throws out a default probability of 17% one month before it happens.
Jun 3, 2022 10 tweets 4 min read
THREAD: Here is an interesting question we may want to ask ourselves. Between 2010-2013, global commodity prices were record high, government was also running large fiscal deficits, but CAD remained under control throughout this period. Why? The story is quite simple. Govt borrowing (net) from external sources remained almost negligible. Public external debt only increased by about $8bn between Jul-08 and Jun-13. And since there were less dollars in the system, there was less to spend on imports during this period.
May 25, 2022 10 tweets 3 min read
(THREAD: 1/n) This figure shows how much the world owes Pakistan (+ve bars) and how much Pakistan owes to the world (-ve bars). The net amount Pakistan owes to rest of the world (net IIP) has increased from $29bn in 2005 to $127bn as of Dec-21. The scary part is that ... (2/n) ... this is not bec rest of the world thinks of Pak as an attractive place to invest. If this was the case (e.g. India), we wouldn't have to worry too much. The world would invest in us (e.g. FDI) and the country would produce enough in future (i.e. exports) to pay it back.
May 23, 2022 4 tweets 1 min read
This may get messy. Looking forward to the next TBill auction now!

"The MPC noted that the market rates should be aligned with the policy rate and in case of any misalignment after today’s policy decision, SBP would take appropriate action." If TBill rates were up because market was anticipating SBP to raise rates, then nothing interesting will happen. TBill rates will stay roughly the same.
But if TBill rates were up due to liquidity drying up for all sorts of reasons, then we may see a bloodbath. Fingers crossed!
May 22, 2022 5 tweets 2 min read
What do urban middle classes want from PTI in exchange for supporting it? What is the nature of exchange which makes this mutually beneficial? When thinking about traditional politics, one can imagine what the vote base of traditional parties want from the parties they support. This is mostly bec the vote base of traditional parties is organised along the lines of baradris, local elites, traders, farmers, & various elite groups. For good or bad, these groups have well defined interests which they like to extract in exchange for extending their support.
May 6, 2022 12 tweets 3 min read
(Thread: 1/n) Do u know there is no legislation in Pak which allows khokhas to operate? According to a study by @Anwarshah77Shah et al. and funded by @RASTA_PIDE, CDA issued 646 licences to such businesses between 1986-1992 but later destroyed many, citing them as security risk. (2/n) A survey 2009 found that only 250 of the khokhas operating in Islamabad had such permission. CDA issued 235 new licenses in the same year, taking the total to 485. For context, the then mayor claimed that there were more than 2000 khokhas operating in the city illegally.
May 5, 2022 21 tweets 6 min read
(Thread: 1/n) Thank you for sharing your thoughts engaging me in the discussion. I shared similar views back in Dec-21 but later gave up on this line of reasoning. I dont promise that most of u will follow this. So, here is an extremely technical response: (2/n) The key issue is that these are very different injections and cannot be added together to draw conclusions for inflation outlook. The OMO injection here is to stabilise repo market. Repo rate is the short end of the yield curve and CBs want this to be closer to policy rate.
May 3, 2022 11 tweets 3 min read
(1/n) This is one of the least appreciated policies which Raza Baqir had to implement and which possibly cost him an extension. His predecessor expanded the size of SBP balance sheet (via lending to govt) by almost 6 trillion in just one year - an extremely inflationary policy. (2/n) Raza Baqir took on the task of reversing this to contain inflationary pressures over medium to long-term. Over the three years of his tenure, he decreased SBP's holdings of government bonds by more than a trillion.
Apr 10, 2022 11 tweets 4 min read
Partly agree and partly disagree. First the agreement part. PTI govt could not implement any meaningful reforms to improve productivity of economy. Broader policies were hijacked by technocratic & business elites: amnesty schemes, untargeted subsides & protectionist policies. The few times I had the opportunity to interact with some of policymakers, I felt a sense of paralysis. Most were almost always waiting for the right time even when they knew the whole rent seeking enterprise was unsustainable. In the end, old ideas came back to dominate policy.
Mar 2, 2022 8 tweets 2 min read
You decide to invest your money in KSE100 for five years. Is it a good investment? Not really! This figure shows the annual return on your investment at the end of 5-year period. You may end up being lucky and earn as high as 55% or end up being miserable and earn as low as -14%. On average, u can expect to get an annual return of 16%. However, the standard deviation is also quite large at 17%. Meaning, investing in KSE100 index over a 5-year period comes with considerable risk. If u r risk averse, you may be better-off investing in bonds than in KSE100.
Dec 29, 2021 6 tweets 3 min read
(1/n) Wat explains the increase in quantity of exports during recent years? Short answer, favourable exch. rate regime (red bars). If it wasn't for this, exports would have been 5-10% lower than wat we see today. Possibly even worse, had we continued with fixed exch. rate regime. (2/n) While global economic conditions did have a significant negative effect on Pak export performance during 2020 (blue bars), the sharp recovery since then meant that the effect has been positive during most of FY21. See -ve blue bars during 2020, followed by +ve bars in FY21.
Dec 29, 2021 4 tweets 2 min read
SBP shouldn't get nervous. An imp reason why spreads between policy rate & govt securities remained stable during previous round of monetary tightening was because SBP ended up buying 5 trillion worth of govt securities. You dont do this if you want to bring inflation down. Also, I am not sure why everyone is assuming treasury yields should move one-to-one with the policy rate i.e. no change in spreads. If market anticipates that govt's repayment capacity will weaken in the future, treasury yields may go up by more than one-to-one with policy rate.
Dec 28, 2021 6 tweets 3 min read
(1/5) The new auto policy does not appreciate the changing nature of trade and continues to focus on the end product as its policy objective. At @eagpakistan, we had proposed an alternate way forward. See here: drive.google.com/file/d/1QQP0tI… Image (2/5) We started with looking at the changing nature of trade in recent decades which is increasingly dominated by different components of the supply chain rather than the end product. ImageImage
Dec 27, 2021 5 tweets 2 min read
(1/4) A sharp reversal in (real) credit uptake by govt during 1st quarter of FY22. After increasing to more than 10% above trend at the end of FY21, credit uptake in real terms is back at its trend. This means demand side pressures driving CAD may subside. But there is a catch. (2/4) In previous periods, every time govt decreased its borrowing from banks in response to increase in borrowing costs, it ended up increasing its borrowing from SBP. So far, this time around, we are not seeing this. However, in its place, there is something else going on ...
Nov 20, 2021 9 tweets 6 min read
(Thread: 1/n) Yes, textile machinery imports have gone up. But, it turns out that all of the increase in textile exports in Jul-Oct 2021 is due to increase in international prices. Let's look at the details & think about what this means for policy ... (2/n) I have used the information provided by the PBS to decompose the increase in dollar value of textile exports into 'price' and 'quantity' effects. It turns out that the contribution of 'quantity' to increase in textile exports is negative, whereas that of prices is positive.
Oct 29, 2021 11 tweets 2 min read
(Thread: 1/n) I dont know how World Bank has reached this conclusion. It is near impossible to work this out frm just lookin at data. This is imp because using reserves to defend the currency can be quite different frm providing dollars to the market. Let's consider an example... (2/n) Say, the govt issues Euro bonds worth 1 billion. After the issuance, the foreign currency gets transferred to the SBP by investors. What happens next? Since it is the fiscal authorities which issued the bond, SBP credits govt account by an equivalent amount in rupees.