Jacob Edenhofer šŸ‡ŖšŸ‡ŗ šŸ‡ŗšŸ‡¦ Profile picture
BA, PPE @warwickuni / MPhil, Comparative Government @UniofOxford & @SomervilleOx / DPhil student in Politics @NuffieldCollege & @Politics_Oxford
2 subscribers
Dec 3 ā€¢ 29 tweets ā€¢ 9 min read
Ok, I'll bite - mainly because the idea that accommodating the radical right on immigration is almost bound to work electorally seems to be rather popular among mainstream politicians.
Let me try to provide a basic overview of the party competition literature and, in doing so, explain why there are good reasons to be sceptical about the claim that accommodation will reap electoral rewards. This doesn't mean that accommodation never works -- just that there is little reason to be as confident about its radical-right-dampening potential as many
Nov 24 ā€¢ 24 tweets ā€¢ 9 min read
RIP Walter Korpi -- one of the key figures in the development of the "power resources theory". Let me take this opportunity to connect some recent work in (labour) economics to this way of thinking about the welfare state and the political economy of redistribution. Most (political) economists think about redistribution and the welfare state in terms of the Meltzer-Richard-Romer model (see šŸ‘‡) for a summary of the demand- and supply-side assumptions. The famous macro-level prediction is that, as the right-ward skew of the income ... Image
Image
Image
Image
Nov 8 ā€¢ 14 tweets ā€¢ 4 min read
@kyleichan has a very interesting post, arguing that -- because China is more dependent on the US than the other way around -- Trump's desire to ratchet up the trade war with China might work to the advantaged of the US. While I'm not qualified to assess high-capacity.com/p/beijing-bracā€¦ the overall argument, I think the post under-estimates the political costs that the first trade war engendered for Trump. Here are three interesting papers documenting these costs.
1. @fetzert , and Carlo Schwarz. 2021. ā€˜Tariffs and Politics: Evidence from Trumpā€™s Trade Warsā€™.
Oct 20 ā€¢ 12 tweets ā€¢ 5 min read
Interesting podcast, which reminded me of this book chapter:
@benwansell and @jrgingrich. 2021. ā€˜The End of Human Capital Solidarity?ā€™ In Who Gets What?: The New Politics of Insecurity, eds. Frances McCall Rosenbluth and Margaret Weir. 52ā€“78. cambridge.org/core/books/absā€¦ x.com/voxeu/status/1ā€¦ I seem to remember that one of the authors did a thread on this when it came out, but I can't find it. In lieu of linking to thread, I'll post some of favourite passages from their chapter.
Their chapter is especially important against the backdrop of the flattening or even Image
Oct 17 ā€¢ 10 tweets ā€¢ 4 min read
It's the political selection stupid (at least in the US). The supply-side dynamics of US politics over the last ~40 years or so seem like an underrated factor in explaining elite-level polarisation and its downstream ramifications. Let me collect some explanations.
1. The cost of running for office have increased. Given these high opportunity costs (in terms of money and time), only wealthy people take the risk of running in elections, and even they rely heavily on campaign contributions. That is
Oct 14 ā€¢ 52 tweets ā€¢ 11 min read
Let me celebrate today's Nobel Prize for Acemoglu, Robinson, and Johnson by summarising the work of the first two laureates on the relationship between inequality and democratisation. In fact, AR kicked off the literature on redistributive theories of democratisation. 1/n Most summaries will focus on their contributions to the historical political economy of development, but their work on democratisation shouldn't go unmentioned today.
The synthesis of their work is presented in AR's "Economic Origins" book -- the

2/ncambridge.org/core/books/ecoā€¦
Oct 13 ā€¢ 9 tweets ā€¢ 2 min read
Interesting paper, which also raises deeper questions about the (unintended side) effects of the distributional ramifications of technocratic poliycmaking on politics. Let me sketch some thoughts.
To be clear: This is not suggest that central bank
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/joā€¦Image independence is a bad idea. In fact, I believe trying to mitigate commitment problems via delegation is very important. If, however, that type of delegation engenders (regressive) distributional effects and voters cannot hold those that craft these policies accountable in
Oct 3 ā€¢ 22 tweets ā€¢ 6 min read
Den Tag der deutschen Einheit verstehe ich als Aufforderung,
- die historisch nahezu singulƤre Leistung der ProtagonistInnen (in Ost u. West) der friedlichen Revolution zu wĆ¼rdigen,
- mir die durch die Wiedervereinigung gerissenen Wunden sowie deren Persistenz zu vergegenwƤrtigen, und
- indes nicht die Integrationserfolge aus den Augen zu verlieren.
Mein komparativer Kostenvorteil besteht in der (leider zu oberflaechlichen) Kenntnis von Teilen der sozialwissenschaftlichen Literatur. Ich hoffe dennoch, dass diese Arbeiten zu einer
Oct 2 ā€¢ 18 tweets ā€¢ 5 min read
The book by @CharlotteCavai1 that Marc mentions in his thread is required reading imo for anyone interested in comparative political economy. I'm not qualified to review the book, but would like to draw your attention to some especially interesting cambridge.org/gb/universitypā€¦ x.com/MarcHvidkjaer/ā€¦Image points.
CavaillƩ defines "fairness reasoning as the thought process through which individuals reason as if a third-party judge ruling on the fairness of a given situation" (p. 32)
She then discusses 3 questions
1āƒ£ When does fairness matter relative to self-interest?
Sep 14 ā€¢ 13 tweets ā€¢ 4 min read
Immigration is back on the German political agenda. Here are some of my favourite academic works on the political and economic dynamics of immigration in Germany.
1. The book by @dhdannychoi, @MathiasPoertner, and Nicholas Sambanis is mightily
press.princeton.edu/books/paperbacā€¦ impressive, both empirically and substantively. Key lesson: It's the norms, stupid. See also the @scopeconditions episode with @dhdannychoi.

2. This interview with Christian Dustmann (@RF_Berlin) is definitely also worth a read. scopeconditionspodcast.com/episodes/donghā€¦
rfberlin.com/interview-dustā€¦
Aug 20 ā€¢ 39 tweets ā€¢ 13 min read
In light of the debate about the extent of inequality in the US, I thought it might be helpful to summarise how political scientists think about the demand for and supply of redistribution. The literature is vast -- so this šŸ§µis intended only a bare-bones introduction. /1 For some empirical background, see this thread by @MortenStostad (though not every graph is uncontested). In general, inequality has risen in most advanced industrialised democracies since roughly the 1980s -- though the extent is debated.
Should we ... /2
Aug 16 ā€¢ 13 tweets ā€¢ 4 min read
Ich mƶchte diesen Tweet von @kuhnmo ā€“ dem ich en gros zustimme ā€“ als Anlass nehmen, um einen kurzen Ɯberblick Ć¼ber relevante Arbeiten aus der Ɩkonomie und Politikwissenschaft zu diesem Thema zu geben. Die Literatur zeigt, dass mehr Gesetze dann gut sein kƶnnen, wenn sie ... /1 dabei helfen, die unvollstƤndigen VertrƤge, die Gesetze darstellen, zu vervollstƤndigen. Was damit gemeint ist, fasse ich auf dieser Folie (šŸ‘‡) zusammen.
Wenn durch weitere Gesetze bzw. Novellen bestehender Gesetze Doppeldeutigkeiten beseitigt werden, wird die durch unvolls. /2 Image
Aug 15 ā€¢ 12 tweets ā€¢ 4 min read
Seems like a good time to re-read some polsci classics.
1. This @JPolEcon piece by Barry Weingast and William Marshall.
journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/26ā€¦

Image 2. Diermeier, Daniel, and @rbmyerson. 1999. ā€˜Bicameralism and Its Consequences for the Internal Organization of Legislaturesā€™. American Economic Review 89(5): 1182ā€“96. aeaweb.org/articles?id=10ā€¦
Image
Aug 12 ā€¢ 11 tweets ā€¢ 4 min read
The climate policy sequencing literature has spent much of the past five years or so rediscovering the insights by Dewatripont and @gerardrolanducb. This doesnā€™t devalue the contributions of the sequencing crowd, but itā€™s still extraordinary. A true modern classic.
Image Here are some references for those interested in the climate-related sequencing literature.
@jonasmeckling, Thomas Sterner, and @GernotWagner . 2017. ā€˜Policy Sequencing toward Decarbonizationā€™. Nature Energy 2(12): 918ā€“22. nature.com/articles/s4156ā€¦
Aug 7 ā€¢ 24 tweets ā€¢ 8 min read
Indeed - this seems to be an instance of autocratic learning. Fico and his cronies seem to have learned from OrbĆ”n that EU membership, including generous EU funds, are compatible with democratic backsliding and high FDI inflows, driven by multinationals. For more, see šŸ‘‡ Let me elaborate on 3 points.
1āƒ£How we got here and why this is an instance of autocratic diffusion

In the table below I summarise the literature on the strategies OrbƔn has employed to foster the consolidation of his regime. Many of these strategies are familiar to those Image
Aug 5 ā€¢ 23 tweets ā€¢ 6 min read
For those interested in serious economic and political analysis of the impact of immigration in the UK, see in particular the Deaton Review's relevant section (h/t @TheIFS). Some examples below. academic.oup.com/ooec/issue/3/Sā€¦ Dustmann, Christian (@RF_Berlin), Yannis Kastis, and Ian Preston. 2024. ā€˜Inequality and Immigrationā€™. Oxford Open Economics 3(Supplement_1): i453ā€“73. doi:10.1093/ooec/odad052. Image
Aug 3 ā€¢ 16 tweets ā€¢ 5 min read
Programmatic accommodation of far-right challengers often entails rhetoric that erodes norms of civility and normalises far-right positions. This, a growing body of research shows, can help incite violence, especially with a "transmitter" as powerful as social media. On normalisation:
Bursztyn, Leonardo, Georgy Egorov, and Stefano Fiorin. 2020. ā€˜From Extreme to Mainstream: The Erosion of Social Normsā€™. American Economic Review 110(11): 3522ā€“48. aeaweb.org/articles?id=10ā€¦
Jul 29 ā€¢ 21 tweets ā€¢ 6 min read
The economic geography of the knowledge economy meets the political geography of a single-member district, plurality electoral system See Jonathan Rodden's well-known book, though I'd also recommend ...
amazon.de/-/en/Jonathan-ā€¦
Jul 24 ā€¢ 12 tweets ā€¢ 5 min read
Happy to circulate a new @cage_warwick working paper, which is joint work with @fetzert and @Prashant_Garg_.
Using original data on high-street vacancies in England and Wales, we investigate the political ramifications of local decline. Brief summary šŸ‘‡ Image Motivation & contribution
The literature on populism has produced robust evidence of a reduced-form causal between:
ā–¶ļølocal economic shocks and negative spatial externalities (crime, homelessness, mental distress)
ā–¶ļø lregional exposure to shocks and
Jul 23 ā€¢ 11 tweets ā€¢ 3 min read
Interesting article. Ultimately, however, I think Wolf over-estimates the potential for citizens' assemblies (CAs) to redress the ills of representative democracy.
This is not to say that CAs are never a good idea. Instead, my tentative thoughts are is a call for more clearly specifying the scope conditions of pro-CA arguments.
As set out in thisšŸ§µ, these arguments fall largely into four groups. Put succicntly:
1āƒ£ CAs result in greater congruence or improved responsiveness.
Jun 25 ā€¢ 36 tweets ā€¢ 12 min read
Foucault died 40 years ago. His work is not easy to read for someone trained in quantitative social science, but in a fascinating essay @ethanbdm draws on (among others) Foucault reflect on the "perils of quantification" in policy analysis.
bostonreview.net/forum_responseā€¦ "In truth, the very notion of the ā€œaimsā€ of public policy is shaped in a deep way by the dictates of quantification. We donā€™t quantify because we are utilitarians. We are utilitarians because we quantify. Reflecting on similar themes, Michel Foucault perhaps put it best,