Emily Troutman Profile picture
Watch my talk at Harvard, Why Prevention in Humanitarian Aid Often Fails https://t.co/Z0xUxS7U59
Jul 17, 2022 42 tweets 16 min read
I’m reading the Uvalde report on the school shooting, prepared by the Texas House of Representatives, Investigative Cmte. static.texastribune.org/media/files/d0…
On paragraph 3 and I’m already livid. They start by blaming the teachers. And then they blame the maintenance staff. Police are already heroes. “We warned you…”
Jun 14, 2022 15 tweets 4 min read
This report on the humanitarian response in Ukraine is stunning. I'll tweet a few highlights. I'm not sure whether to laugh or just shake with rage. #Haiti folks will recognize these problems. First off, these two figures. Locals are the ones on the ground but they only got 0.003% of the money. It's shocking, honestly. And I've been doing this story for a decade. We're talking about a billion dollars here.
Jan 13, 2022 16 tweets 5 min read
As a disaster reporter, one of my major obsessions is data. Generation of useless data is one of the top ways that aid groups and governments fail people in need. 🧵 Following international disasters, there's always a lot of graphics and spreadsheets and "dashboards." This gives the impression of SO MUCH information. But it's generally not usable.
Sep 4, 2021 4 tweets 1 min read
Very happy to share my thoughts with Haitians via Le Nouvelliste | Aide : sur chaque million annoncé, dix mille dollars iront aux organisations locales lenouvelliste.com/article/231407… Les clients des organisations d'aide internationale ne sont pas les bénéficiaires de l'aide, leurs clients sont les donateurs. Même si les bénéficiaires de l'aide n'aiment pas l'aide, ils peuvent continuer à la donner tant que les donateurs continuent de leur donner de l'argent.
Aug 19, 2021 4 tweets 3 min read
The EU has released satellite imagery of the damage in Haiti. First impression is that it's very dispersed. That will be a challenge. The red blocks are autogenerated to show destroyed buildings. Not 100% accurate, a snapshot This analysis done by NASA using Copernicus data is more detailed but you can see by all the red in the ocean, prone to false positives maps.disasters.nasa.gov/arcgis/home/it…
Aug 18, 2021 26 tweets 5 min read
Folks are asking: What went wrong with the aid in Haiti after the earthquake in 2010 and is it going to happen again? I spent two years there after the quake, then reported on a bunch of other disasters. 🧵 tl;dr yes First off: nothing that went wrong in Haiti was because of Haiti. The same/similar problems with disaster response happen everywhere. 1/n
Aug 17, 2021 4 tweets 1 min read
Part of the delay in allowing Afghans is how the Global North adjudicates “claims” for “asylum.” A practice that barely exists in the Global South, where refugees just move in. The north’s insistence on “vetting” is a colonial performance entirely driven by fear and racism. Insisting that more paperwork makes us safer is ludicrous. The 9/11 guys had their paperwork perfect. The paperwork has increased over the decades, as nationalism and fear of immigrants took hold in rich countries. Asylum is a RIGHT but it’s treated now as a privilege