Holden Thorp, dormant account Profile picture
No longer posting here. Find me at https://t.co/XDPSRqYk69 and link below for other platforms.
Potato Of Reason Profile picture 1 subscribed
Mar 21, 2023 4 tweets 3 min read
In light of @Nature's excellent editorial about why it makes sense to comment on politics (all the way, in their case, to making an endorsement), this is the Pew finding that is most relevant. Following the admonition to stick to science is conceding 1/n Image the idea that scientists can be sidelined in policy decisions. "Stick to science" infantilizes scientists and tells us to sit at the kids table and let the adults decide. We must fight back. Here's the editorial: 2/n nature.com/articles/d4158…
Nov 20, 2022 9 tweets 3 min read
People are rightly focused on how the grad students at UC will get what they deserve for carrying most of the load of the most productive research entity in the world. But it's worth thinking through the underlying problems that created the situation. 1/n link.springer.com/article/10.100… The underfunding of grad stipends is a symptom of the idea of supply-side science, which I reference in the piece above and is laid out here in another great piece by @NaomiOreskes. 2/n
link.springer.com/article/10.100…
Oct 21, 2022 4 tweets 1 min read
Here's my more serious take on the @eLife gambit/imbroglio. There are many reasons we can all come up with why it won't work or is a bad idea. But they're going to try it and you have to give them credit for trying to shake things up. @mbeisen 1/n The addiction to journals starts at the institutions, so the question is whether this will dislodge that. Doubtful in my view having approved hundreds if not thousands of tenure cases. 2/n
Jul 7, 2022 7 tweets 4 min read
This one will ruffle feathers. Here's my editorial on why we shouldn't tolerate any of the excuses for not adopting inclusive teaching and creating an inclusive learning environment. @vijisathy @DrMrsKellyHogan 1/n science.org/doi/10.1126/sc… I went to the @HdxAcademy meeting and debated Lujana Maroja at the UNC Public Discourse program to try to understand the arguments on the other side. Here is Maroja's essay where she disagrees with me. 2/n hxstem.substack.com/p/my-debate-wi…
Aug 20, 2020 5 tweets 1 min read
Some folks have asked me about the colleges reopening/closing. As I said in my column in May, I expected colleges to be "mostly online;" that has held up amazingly well. Over the last few weeks, I've watched a lot of people that I have worked with over the years 1/ struggle to make very hard decisions, and I'm sympathetic to the challenges they have. But two things I think are getting a little lost. One is that reopening for undergrads potentially endangers research activity and clinical activity when the hospital is nearby. 2/