Jason Meisner Profile picture
Chicago Tribune reporter covering the Dirksen U.S. Courthouse and criminal justice issues in Chicago
Potato Of Reason Profile picture 1 subscribed
May 2, 2023 10 tweets 2 min read
Looks like the ComEd Four jury has a question, their first of the day. Leinenweber: The question is, "If on instruction page 43 you don't believe the government proved "beyond a reasonable doubt" can page 48 of the instructions still be applied yes or no?"
May 1, 2023 4 tweets 1 min read
The ComEd Four jury has a question…already! "Please clarify a possible discrepancy with the use of conjunctions and/or" the jury note says.
Leinenweber says "This is precisely the same issue I had with the R. Kelly case."
The problem is the indictment is in disjunctive and instructions are conjunctive
Mar 31, 2023 6 tweets 2 min read
🧵 20 years ago today, I was the overnight desk editor for City News.
My one reporter was busy checking on the usual list of fires and murders.
We were the only 2 journalists on duty in Chicago when a crazy tip came in: Bulldozers were rolling down the street, toward Meigs Field. Image My first reaction was— Probably a construction project getting underway early. But I whistled up Peter Beller at Chicago police HQ anyways and told him “you better go check this out.”
20 minutes later, he called me from his Nokia flip phone. “THEY’RE TEARING UP THE RUNWAY!!!”
Mar 30, 2023 15 tweets 3 min read
Sorry-was delayed getting back to trial... we're still on Cotter's cross. It's been quite civilized, compared to other recent trials... (ahem...RKelly)
ie:
Sir, please answer my question before launching into whatever else it is you want to say.
My apologies.
You're forgiven. Cotter: These job recommendations that came from Mike McClain were exactly that, job recommendations. Some of them got hired... some didn't. Right?
Marquez: "They were job recommendations coming from the speaker"
Mar 30, 2023 8 tweets 2 min read
We're back. Marquez is testifying about a wiretapped recording from 2018 where Marquez, Pramaggiore, and McClain were talking about a bill that Madigan's daughter, Atty. Gen. Lisa Madigan, wanted and ComEd opposed. Cotter: Does McClain ever say to you "I'll just go to the Speaker because he owes us and I'll ask him to ask Lisa to change the bill or pull it?
Marquez: No.
Cotter: Instead, McClain suggests a very sophisticated and extensive strategy to lobby and defeat the bill?
Marquez: Yes
Mar 30, 2023 15 tweets 3 min read
Judge Leinenweber is on the bench in the "ComEd Four" case, asking defense how long they each have in cross.
Lassar, who started Wednesday, says he has "11 minutes" left.
McClain's attorney, Patrick Cotter, is making no promises. Btw, you may have wondered why there are no photos of gov't witness Fidel Marquez coming in and out of the courthouse every day.
Marquez, who made himself scarce after word of his cooperation first circulated in 2019, appears to be getting a private escort treatment by the feds
Mar 29, 2023 11 tweets 2 min read
“You did not believe that ComEd had bribed Mike Madigan, did you?”
“Correct.”
Cross-examination of star witness in "ComEd Four" case underway.
UPDATE w/@RayLong chicagotribune.com/news/criminal-… We're back after the afternoon break. Marquez testifying on cross about ComEd legislation and how the company would have its vendors contact legislators about good things in the bills.
Marquez says the bills "had to be bipartisan" and they couldn't rely on just Democrats
Mar 29, 2023 6 tweets 1 min read
Fidel Marquez is done with direct after about 15 hours of total questioning by prosecutors, starting on Monday.
Up first on cross is Scott Lassar, lawyer for Anne Pramaggiore Lassar asks about the day the FBI confronted Marquez at his mother's home.
Q: They scared the daylights out of you didn't they?
"I was scared."
Q: And you hoped you wouldn't be prosecuted?
"I did not expect to be charged, correct."
Mar 29, 2023 11 tweets 2 min read
Jury is coming back in for "ComEd Four" trial... prosecutor Bhachu says he has about 20 minutes left of direct, which began Monday morning. Recording from April 2019, Hooker tells Marquez that Anne Pramaggiore was thinking of bringing in Mapes as a consultant with McClain
"And McClain would like that," Hooker says.
Mar 29, 2023 12 tweets 2 min read
Tough to tell whether all these emails are landing with the "ComEd Four" jury. But if nothing else, it gives you a visceral sense of what it was like to have to deal with Michael McClain on a daily basis.
Good lord. Bhachu now says he should finish direct “somewhere around lunchtime.”
Mar 29, 2023 19 tweets 3 min read
The "ComEd Four" jury is back in the box and we begin with -- SURPRISE! -- another email from Michael McClain about a political hire.
"Obviously, this came from our Friend and I have not heard anything from your staff ....." McClain wrote to ComEd VP Fidel Marquez. McClain's follow up email on this is beyond snarky, saying the person Marquez gave this assignment to "does not know if this is a Presidential request or God's but she or he knows it comes from her or his boss and then they wait until you write with a status report?"
Dec 8, 2021 5 tweets 1 min read
Uche has been going for a little over an hour. After he brought up the $2 million that Smollett testified the Osundairos wanted to keep quiet, prosecutors objected.
"The jury heard what the evidence was and what the evidence wasn’t on that," Linn says. Uche brings up the security guard: "The witness tells you in an American courthouse he was pressured and threatened to change his story and say 'I did not see a white person.' What in the world is going on?"
Dec 8, 2021 27 tweets 5 min read
Closing arguments are set to begin in less than an hour in #JussieSmollett’s trial on charges of reporting a phony hate crime. Judge Linn is known for keeping jurors deliberating late into the night if need be, so put on an extra pot of coffee…chicagotribune.com/news/criminal-… w/@crepeau The judge has not said publicly if there are time limits on closing arguments, but 26th and Cal vets are guessing about 90 minutes total per side. So the jury should be getting the case later in the afternoon
Dec 7, 2021 12 tweets 2 min read
We are back at the #Smollett trial. Webb confirms he's finished his cross. Attorney Nenye Uche is on redirect. Uche asking if Ola had shown up uninvited before, Smollett says yes, many times. "Let me clarify... uninvited by me," he says.
Dec 7, 2021 27 tweets 5 min read
#JussieSmollett is retaking the witness stand now. Prosecutor Dan Webb is resuming his slightly folksy questioning, getting Jussie to admit that he drove around Lakeview with the Osundairo brothers, but deny that he recruited them in the hoax attack during the ride.
Dec 6, 2021 25 tweets 5 min read
///BREAKING/// #JussieSmollett has been called to testify in his own defense on charged he arranged a fake hate crime attack on himself. Smollett is wearing a gray suit, maroon tie. Just got sworn in. Asked what he does for a living: "I am an artist."
Dec 6, 2021 9 tweets 2 min read
We are back in the #Smollett trial. Next defense witness is Brett Mahoney, who worked on the "Empire" set. Mahoney was the show's executive producer and later "showrunner," writing scripts and working with director and editors to put everything together for the studios. He worked directly with Smollett, including on episodes Jussie directed
Dec 6, 2021 12 tweets 2 min read
After a long in-chambers discussion, we're back and starting the morning testimony in the #JussieSmollett trial. Defense calls Anthony Moore, the security guard at Smollett's building. Moore was making rounds near the Chicago Burger Company on the west side of the building on the night of the attack. He heard someone coming and saw what appeared to be a "white male" coming at him in a ski mask. "I startled him." He saw a second person too but not his face.