Christophe Rigon / Soto² 🪸 - Scybernethician Profile picture
Cognition/Modeling, 2d cybernetics & enaction, techno-hermeneutics, epistemic & creative cognition, self-design & lived bio-logic. Meaning & sense making.
Nov 18 7 tweets 2 min read
[ Cybernetics, Enaction & the End of Functionalism ] 🧵🪸

To understand enactive modeling (as any scientific and rational representation is an evolutionary model experimentally correlated), one need to understand its socio-historical roots in the cybernetics functionalist style Image , and how this functionalist cognitivist style has been "metabolized and digested" comprehensively into the embodied enactive style of thinking:

👉 [ What WAS Cybernetics ]

bsky.app/profile/scyber…
Nov 9 19 tweets 3 min read
[ Understanding the Connectionist ("genAI") Epistemological Disruption ] 🧵 🪡

I will quickly articulate some key rationals in this thread to explain the disruptive role of "generative AI" & their unexpected success, which is also at the foundation of my "scybernethics". Image In a nutshell:

connectionist modeling is a de-construction of one pillar of traditional natural & cognitive science: functionalism.
Nov 2 4 tweets 1 min read
Thanks to Hui's "Machine and Sovereignty", I begin to have a more deep understanding of Hegel's dialectic and phenomenology, and see many resonances with my scybernethics journey (outside naïve projections).

Ex, in §5. "Individuation of the Spirit as historical Process"

1/3 Image 1. Technologies as sensorimotor externalizations.
2. Computers as quasi second-order machines (machine², i.e. machines simulating machines and machining us).

2/3 Image
Oct 25 10 tweets 2 min read
[ Politics of Modeling: Why I don't like PP-FEP ] 🧵

As an enactive thinker (more than "enactivist"), my problem with PP-FEP is political: the politics of modeling / style of thinking in science of cognition. For me it is too much on the empirical side, a pure product of the actual dominant utilitarianist scientific trend. It's probabilist foundation ("Bayesian inference"), and locally global conception, while "efficient",
Oct 6 32 tweets 4 min read
[ Relating Tekhne and Episteme (Enacted Biocognition) through Implicit Processual Memory ] 🧵🪡

Understanding technicity/Tekhne imply to understand modern technologies as the production of machines *externalizing and concretizing our normative, first body then mind, gestures*. Soul Leaving Body - William Blake. This understanding allows us to shed light on the nature of technical artifacts, notably automatic computing machines, and their power to shape our embodied minds, but also to highlight certain crucial keys to better understanding ourselves and extending our self-knowledge.
Sep 21 10 tweets 2 min read
[ The Quality of Numbers ]

When I began my spiritual journey at the age of seventeen (1982), having been confronted with the idea of ​​death, the first books I read were "The Reign of Quantity and the Signs of the Times" by René Guénon and "Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind" by Suzuki.
Image
Image
Then I began to be interested in the symbolism of numbers, that is, numbers not as quantities but as *qualities*: one as unity, two as duality, three as trinity, etc. (I recently discovered that Pierce also followed this path), and also in heraldry and symbolism in general. Image
Sep 20 8 tweets 2 min read
[ Mechanical Computation & Abstract Weaving: Old Story ] 🧵🪡

Walking in the south of France (Pézenas), I was surprised, while visiting an old private mansion with medieval architecture intended to promote the arts and crafts, to find myself in front of a Jacquard loom (1801). Image The correspondence with the "computer" is obvious:

1. Use of "binary" punch cards to automate a complex task, like the first electronic computers: hole/no hole = 1/0 (Boolean binary logic).
Sep 17 6 tweets 1 min read
[ Don't Fall into the Cognitivist Relational Realism Trap ] 🧵🪡

There is now many very good philosophical argumentations against the substancialist metaphysic of Being (cf. image 👇, cited by Vervaeke). Image But because they are caught in a linguistic cognitivist and formalist expressions (declarative knowledge coupled with propositional logic), they tend to fall into an opposite "Relational Realism" trap by searching for an "ontological" ultimate ground.
Sep 5 5 tweets 2 min read
[ What is "Reality"? ]

A techno-socio collective historical norm? A personal phenomenological experience? Both? Neither?

Exploring: What is this space between and around the logical and distinctive "it is" and "it is not"?

1/3
Image 2/3 Image
Sep 1 11 tweets 2 min read
[ From Numeric Diachronic Computation to Original Biocognitive Com-putation ] 🧵🪡

Like "information", "computation" has become a modern buzz word: everybody use it but very few really understand its deep meaning and its techno-cultural shift in the last century through Gödel, Shannon-Weaver, Turing-Church and Von Neuman-atomic bomb techno-historical arc.
Aug 26 9 tweets 2 min read
[ Scybernethic & Allagmatic ]

"However, since a structure [Form] is given as the result of a construction, we can say that the operation [Process] is what makes a structure appear or what modifies a structure." - Simondon

It's totally coherent with the operation as an enaction. In the enactive paradigm, the "form" ("thing", coherence, structure, etc) is thought as "enacted" from the "process" (operation, trans-formation, dynamic, etc).

While this articulated thinking is itself originally coming from our 1P-3P "form", our self/ego enacted perspective.
Aug 25 26 tweets 3 min read
[ TechnoPhilosophy: What Humans Cannot Do ] 🧵

Because crucial socio-normative power issues are at stake, many articles on "What machines cannot do" are published. I propose here a counterpoint to better reveal the limits and blind spots Image of the current standard of academic rationality, not to weaken it but on the contrary to strengthen it in the face of machine-based process logics and increase our intelligibility of the deep logics currently at work on a global scale.
Aug 24 14 tweets 3 min read
[ Toward the Automatic Scientist ] 🧵

As I have predicted more than a year ago, and while 3P-Only/materialist scientists are still caught in a neurocentric conception of the mind, the industry is pushing toward "self-modifying" ANN models leading to the "automatic scientist". Image Here is a blog post that details this strong strategic trend, with supporting publications:

"The AI ​​Scientist: Towards Fully Automated Open-Ended Scientific Discovery.

👉 sakana.ai/ai-scientist/
Image
Aug 23 24 tweets 3 min read
[ Learning from Simulations: Why Natural Evolution is NOT an Optimizing Process ] 🧵

In my scybernethics journey, I have learned one important thing: that you can test general complex *principles* about life and cognition, like "emergence" or "evolution" by simulating them and not only grasping them abstractly. This is crucial because there is two things that we can't think directly intellectually: complex distributed systems and evolutionary ones.
Aug 16 5 tweets 1 min read
[ From Sentience to (EU) Welfare Legislation ]

A welcome & important initiative, as we are living in an excessive competitive/predatorial world which consider living beings, including ourselves, as objects or "commodities/tokens". Its a necessary but sad *ethical* observation. But this necessary legislation (vs personal ethic) to contain ultra-liberal non-ethical behaviors has a *non-neutral epistemological consequence* : driving us inexorably toward "rule-based" & more and more complex collective cognitivist conceptions difficult to apply effectively. Image
Aug 13 5 tweets 2 min read
[ Beyond Intentionality & Agency: Noetic Phenomeno-Epistemology ] 🧵🪡

In my scybernethic enacted framework, I have developed what I called "Experimental and Experiential Epistemology", a way to study, explore and experience our (pre)noetic mind through computer simulations Image of artificial cognition ("AI") and a-life models of emergences (CA, connectionist models, swarms, evolutionary processing, etc), based on iterative cycles of modeling/observations/phenomenological inquiry/comparative study with scholar literature.
Jul 27 17 tweets 2 min read
[ The Collective Drift Towards Erroneous Conceptions: the example of Memory ]

The "cognitivist" mentality (computo-representational functionalism) has allowed AI to cause our collective memory to drift towards erroneous conceptions, Image which are nevertheless crucial for understanding cognition and the mind, that is to say, consciousness and our own perceptions of ourselves.
Jul 26 6 tweets 1 min read
[ Academic Discourses on Normativity as a Second-Order Gesture ] 😉

From the normalization of normativity (the normativity of normativity) to self-normativity.

An interaction in 4 steps with the automatic doxa (LLM + RAG): 1. What is "linguistic normativity"? How could it be related to "vital normativity"?

2. Is it legitimate to speak about vital normativity without speaking about linguistic normativity?

3. Are there any philosophers who integrate both vital and linguistic normativity?
Jul 25 5 tweets 5 min read
[ Scybernethics Meta-Thread: Terminology 2 ]

"Mind as a Gesture":

"Modeling":

"Anthropo-Functionalism":

"The Mind-Mind Problem (MMP)": x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
"Second-Order Rationality²":

"Homeostasis":

"Place of the Synthesis":

"In-Formation":

"Forgetting/Amnesia":

"Induction":
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
x.com/search?q=%40ki…
Jul 25 16 tweets 3 min read
[ Knowing - Cognitive Sciences - Trends and Perspectives, Varela, 1989 ]

1. Information

"Information, I would say, is like a modern phlogiston that would explain the structure of knowledge by relying on a pre-existing order of things. The keystone of cognition is precisely Image The keystone of cognition is precisely its capacity to express meaning and regularities; information must appear not as an intrinsic order but as an emergent order of cognitive activities themselves.
Jul 24 6 tweets 1 min read
[ The Advantage of the 1P Disciplined Perspective ]

The first-person phenomenological perspective has a great advantage over the classical 3P-Only/Cartesianist scientific point of view: being able to also study its intentional object through *negation*. Image Where behaviorist science is condemned to accumulate occurrences to infinity in order to generalize them, a phenomenologist can also simply study a psychological/cognitive phenomenon *directly* through its voluntary repression.