Lisa Fagin Davis Profile picture
Executive Director, @medievalacademy; @simmonsslis prof; paleographer, codicologist, manuscript blogger; PhD; @brownuniversity @Yale alum
Dec 28, 2022 18 tweets 7 min read
I know we're all obsessed with the stream of discoveries about #receptiogate, the revolving-door website updates, & Rossi's doubling-down claims of innocence that are easily disproven, but I also want to talk about her #fragmentoogy work, which is troubling in several respects... As many of you know, I have been working closely with @FragmentariumMS and many other scholars for decades to develop best-practices for cataloguing, data-modeling, and digital reconstructions of dismembered manuscripts, i.e. #fragmentology
Dec 27, 2022 5 tweets 2 min read
One of the astonishing parts about this update is that Rossi admits to "colourising" b/w photos! Plaigerism aside, & whether the "colourising" really happened in this case or not, the idea of taking a b/w photo and quietly colorizing it is incredibly misleading! ImageImage Tacitly editing images of fragments seems to be her MO: adding borders where there are none, cropping for consistency of size, inserting a mis=matched binding, adding fake flyleaves, colorizing b/w images. How can readers trust such a deceptive author?
Dec 25, 2022 5 tweets 2 min read
Look, people, it's not that hard. The rules of #Fragmentology are simple and finite. 1) If you are going to piece a dismembered manuscript back together online, do it with intellectual honesty. 2) If there's are missing leaves, show us where it is by indicating lacunae, as in this screenshot of my own work on the Beauvais Missal:
Aug 18, 2022 6 tweets 3 min read
Spending the afternoon @BeineckeLibrary photographing Wilfrid #Voynich 's scrapbook of press clippings heralding the "news" of the manuscript's decoding and attribution to Roger Bacon, and found this marvelous bit of editorial snark from the Providence Tribune, April 22, 1921: Am now looking for an excuse to use the expression "I don't give two whoops in a rain barrel!"
Aug 9, 2022 67 tweets 23 min read
OK, people, you worked hard to get me to 10K followers, so here is your reward! An epic 62-Tweet thread about the #Voynich manuscript coming your way, starting NOW! 1. First things first. The #Voynich manuscript (VMS from now on) is a real object. Please always keep that in mind! It is a medieval manuscript (more on that in a minute) that belongs to the @BeineckeLibrary at Yale University, where it has been MS 408 since it was given in 1969.
Jul 28, 2022 13 tweets 6 min read
Remember a few weeks ago when I gave a lecture @imc_leeds about my reconstruction of the Beauvais Missal & announced that leaf no. 113 had landed in my inbox the day before? Now that I’m caught up on other things, I can work on placing it in the reconstruction. Here’s how… Step 1: identify recto & verso. Generally a straightforward task…look for the binding holes (i.e. the gutter), which, in a manuscript that reads left -> right will be on the left of the recto side. In this case, the leaf is heavily trimmed on all sides, so no binding holes!
Jun 10, 2022 16 tweets 6 min read
Ever heard of Cistercian numerals? I hadn’t either until yesterday, and after hours of diving down lots of rabbit holes, I’m here to tell you all about this fascinating chapter in the story of medieval numeration! We all know about the two dominant numeral systems in the European Middle Ages: Roman numerals and Arabic numerals. Roman numerals are good for labeling and expressing a single number like a date, but Arabic numerals won the fight for numerical supremacy...
Jun 8, 2022 10 tweets 4 min read
Here's something else really interesting about @sims_mss 266: evidence for how it was made. By splitting up the 4-column scroll into four separate sections of a codex (Bible/Romans/France/England), the scribe had to carefully plan how the genealogical diagrams would be laid out. Image As I mentioned in yesterday's absolutely chaotic thread (sorry, was trying to simultaneously board a plane and Tweet, always a bad idea), the branches at the bottom of ff. 12v/13 redirect all over the manuscript, as the survivors of Troy scatter across the Mediterranean: Image
Jun 7, 2022 8 tweets 3 min read
What happens when you take a text that supposed to be a scroll and record it in a codex instead? Chaos! Here’s @sims_mss 266, the same Universal Chronicle that I edited and translated in my book, La Chronique Anonyme Universelle. openn.library.upenn.edu/Data/0001/html… Image @sims_mss The Chronique is characterized not only by different histories in parallel columns, but also by a complex and lengthy genealogical diagram that records the lineage of humanity from Adam to the fifteenth century. Image
Mar 16, 2022 8 tweets 4 min read
Check it out, folks, VCEditor now lets me show reconstructed formerly-conjoint bifolia of the fragmentary Beauvais Missal! SO COOL! For example, here's a quire from August of the Sanctorale section. I've found 5 of the original 8 leaves of the quire, including two formerly-conjoint bifolia (in bright green): Image
Mar 7, 2022 4 tweets 1 min read
Today is the feast day of St. Thomas Aquinas, who is absolutely definitely and for real the patron saint of illegible handwriting. Here's his script in Vatican Library, Vat. Lat. 9850, written 1260-1265. Image digi.vatlib.it/view/MSS_Vat.l…
Jan 30, 2022 15 tweets 6 min read
Well, you asked for it, so here it is: a brief history of the mighty ampersand! #BreakfastPaleography The character we know as the ampersand [&] is used in nearly every Latinate language as a stand-in for the word [and]. But it didn’t start life as an abbreviation. It is actually a ligature, a Latin combination of two letters: [e] and [t], or [et], which in English means [and].
Jan 25, 2022 13 tweets 6 min read
OK, folks, brace yourselves because here comes the ultimate #BreakfastPaleography thread, in which I will follow the development of the wonderful, magical, mysterious and apparently very flexible letter [g] over the course of more than 2,000 years! Image We’ll start in Rome, then jump up to the British Isles before heading back to the Continent. Buckle up, ‘cause here we go!
Dec 22, 2021 8 tweets 3 min read
So I thought about going to a museum in Boston today before Omicron shuts them all down but it's damp and foggy and cold and so I think I'll spend the day thinking about interesting paleographical features of the #Voynich manuscript instead. Here comes a Voynich paleography 🧵 ImageImage Among the most unusual symbols in the manuscript are these, known to Voynichologists as “gallows.” There are four, classified by the number of legs and the number of loops. For convenience, we call them (l-r, t-b) f, p, k, t. Image
Sep 2, 2021 12 tweets 3 min read
That's all, folks. Here comes a thread on the Vinland Map, one of the OTHER controversial objects at the Beinecke (and here you thought it was all about the #Voynich)... The story of the map's time in New Haven is fascinating. In the 1960s, the Italian-American community was furious that the map, when thought to be authentic, "proved" that other explorers from Europe had crossed the Atlantic before Columbus (gasp!) (nvm that we knew that already)
Apr 11, 2021 16 tweets 5 min read
I don’t know if this is a serious question or not, but I’m going to give it a serious answer. Here’s a thread on “So, you think you’ve solved the #Voynich Manuscript. What next?” Image 1) Have you done the reading? If not, you’d better. There are actual factual things known about this manuscript, and if you’re solution isn’t consistent with those facts, then forget it. Here come some facts:
Dec 6, 2020 8 tweets 4 min read
In honor of the Feastday of St. Nicholas, let’s take a close look at some scenes from his life as illustrated by Gottschalk of Lambach in the late 12th c., @StaBi_Berlin Theol. Lat. q.140: digital.staatsbibliothek-berlin.de/werkansicht?PP… This manuscript is a collection of Saint’s Lives and begins (f. 2r) with a visual table of contents: Gottschalk presenting his finished book to the Virgin and Child, with saints around the border. St. Nicholas is in the center right, as Bishop of Myra.
Aug 27, 2020 21 tweets 8 min read
OK, brace yourselves, because here comes a REALLY LONG THREAD on liturgical calendars, starring the great Sherborne Missal (a.k.a. @BLMedieval Add MS 74236): access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ar… Ever found yourself flummoxed by medieval liturgical calendars? I’m here to break it down for you, using the extraordinary Sherborne Missal because this calendar HAS IT ALL! access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ar…