"Please post evidence in the comments if I’m wrong here." Ok, well I'm familiar with the Dancing Israelis story and found a lot that Ian gets wrong or leaves out. This thread will explain in detail what and why (all sources linked at the end) 🧵

https://twitter.com/IanCarrollShow/status/1877547587810603133

First, the post: most claims here are just factually wrong.
- There’s no “hard photographic evidence” the men had foreknowledge. This seems to be a misunderstanding about the declassified photos which bear a 9/10 timestamp. They were in fact taken on 9/11; the FBI found the camera’s dating was “fourteen hours and forty one minutes late.” The docs also state “None of the pictures ... depicted the twin towers prior to the attack,” they were taken after the North Tower had already been hit and thus suggest no foreknowledge.
- The men weren’t “positioned at a vantage point up to a half hour before the attack.” Ian is misreading a witness report of a “utility van for an electric company,” totally unrelated to the Urban Moving van. To be clear: both “Dancing Israelis” witnesses reported only seeing them several minutes after the attack, and as the FBI itself concluded, all evidence suggests they arrived on site after hearing of the event like anyone else.
- There weren’t “numerous fake Israeli moving companies,” the firms were very much real, as I’ll explain in a bit.

A few additional comments about the thread:
Regarding Candace's claim that Stalin was Jewish: the Georgian for Judah is იუდა (yoodah); Stalin's surname is ჯუღა (joogah) + შვილი ("-son"). These are totally different roots so she very likely lied about her "Georgian friend" So her claim about name changes here is basically false: it's a common practice for revolutionaries to change their names or use pen names. Lenin's surname Ulyanov didn't come from his Jewish maternal grandfather, was Russian, and thus wouldn't have "outed him" as quarter-Jewish.

Almost everything said in this thread is factually incorrect (with zero sources). But all this information does actually exist, or has been declassified, and historians have given it a lot of attention over the years.
I’ll quickly run through it point by point: 🧵

https://twitter.com/RealCandaceO/status/1793735908006474204

"447 of the Bolsheviks out of 525 were Jews."
By "Bolsheviks" she later clarifies "Bolshevik Administration," then "Bolshevik commissioners."
Of the actual Commissars* forming the government of the USSR (Sovnarkom) when it was founded, 3 were Jewish: Trotsky, Kamenev, Sokolnikov.

Since the “Ancestral Vril” meme is apparently never going away, a quick run-down 🧵 on PornHub:
1/6 – Solomon Friedman is VP of Compliance at Ethical Capital Partners, the fund that purchased PH's parent company in 2023. He is not "the owner" or responsible for its decisions.

https://twitter.com/BasedTorba/status/1732541774151680117

2 – ECP is currently chaired by Rocco Meliambro (Italian) and managed by Fady Mansour (Arab). With the possible exception of Shayna Miller (member of the advisory board), Friedman seems to be the only Jew in the fund’s leadership.

Eduardo Eurnekian is actually of Armenian-Christian descent and a survivor of the Armenian genocide. He affiliated with the Wallenberg Foundation to commemorate righteous Armenians.
But it's too late. The new meme about Milei's Jewish handlers has thus been determined! This screenshot he provides ofc doesn't refer to Eurnekian as a Jewish-Armenian, but as an Armenian, and Tenenbaum as a Jew; totally flies over Keith's head.

So I tried looking into Keith’s claim that Christian Zionism itself only exists due to Jewish meddling, but there’s seriously zero evidence for it. It’s just tiny bits of speculation connected with pieces of string, the definition of conspiracy theory.
(1/7) His thread's gist is that the Jews financed notable Bible commentator C Scofield. (That's it.)
The case rests on wealthy Zionist Samuel Untermyer, who’s connected to Scofield based on the following passage. Basically, they both attended the same gentlemen’s club at some point...

These people would genuinely have you believe that Jewish functionaries hate Russia—solely on the basis of historical grievances—and yet support Ukraine, Poland, and fucking Germany to that end.
Just make it make sense. Not even touching on the secondary assumption that this impulse directs American foreign policy/anti-Russian sentiment. Simply ignore the entirety of the Cold War and instead focus on speculations about so-and-so seeking revenge on Nick II for oppressing his bubbe...

This new thread is honestly a great example of the widespread confirmation bias on the Right. If you’re only looking for X, you’ll find only X, pin all blame onto only X, and then your applauding midwit followers will eat it up.
I’m blocked but might as well make this a 🧵 One of the authors Keith cites give some crucial context: within the social sciences, of which Boas was obviously a part, the trend was the OPPOSITE and egalitarianism was becoming increasingly pronounced well prior to Boas.

So wrong... The play was about a Jew marrying a Cossack descendant of the murderers of his own family, and then converting to Christianity. The "melting pot" idea is not about multiculturalism. It's the exact opposite: the melting away of Euro cultural/racial distinctiveness. ... t.co/TUcWTHOxsC This was specifically for European peoples and wasn't intended for non-whites. Obviously there's no such thing as "ethnically and culturally European," but Zangwill advocated European cultural amalgamation. He also married an ethnically English woman.

In case anyone could use this, some good resources on Holocaust (quick 🧵):
-
- <🇫🇷
-
-
- <🇩🇪
- holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.com
phdn.org
phdn.org/archives/holoc…
nizkor.com
h-ref.de
imgur.com/a/725A7 Educational resources with an eye to denial:
-
- deathcamps.org
holocaustresearchproject.org/toc.html

Things to note:
Obviously the Holocaust was not "successfully covered up until another government came in." It had been known about to an increasing extent since 1942 by the Allies and foreign press.
The Allies jointly issued a condemnation in December. deathcamps.org/reinhard/allie…

So Elijah has finally jumped on the JQ bandwagon (as has long been expected)
Obviously there aren't 7 "rich people" in Australia, but regardless the headline's from 2018 and was published b/c that year was anomalous: currently the figure stands at 2/7 per their own source. (...)

https://twitter.com/ElijahSchaffer/status/1642166287991472128

If we're actually interested in the number of Jews among Australia's "rich people," just continue reading the article: 23/193 = <12%.
So if you accept that "Christianity is demonized & more trans than the USA," the answer why is somewhere else.

"while CofC was ignored for 25 years until Cofnas took a stab at it"
This is false. There were multiple decent, critical responses to your book prior to Cofnas. For example: David Lieberman published two extensive critiques of your work, in 2001 and 2008.
vivare.substack.com/p/literature-a…

https://twitter.com/TOOEdit/status/1640576527632044032

Then there were the ceaseless discussions on the H-net forums among academics of topics like antisemitism, Judaism, immigration, etc.
In H-ethnic, to name just one example, social researcher Barry Mehler found another false citation which MacDonald actually promptly removed.

🧵My impression—you’ve deleted the most explicit falsehoods and prefaced everything else w the self-fulfilling idea that there’s little evidence Boas was ethnocentric only bc he was ethnocentric, trying to abate gentile suspicion.
As I'll show, you offer no evidence to that end:

https://twitter.com/TOOEdit/status/1612275085397889026

Your grappling with Boas’ desire for J assimilation is untenable. It's not "simply an allegation of fact": you emphasize Boas’ entire career was ideological, devoted to allaying racism, so of course this is prescriptive: “the greatest hope for the immediate future,” in fact. ...

🧵 Debunking a basic bitch Holocaust denial meme repeated by Vincent James on his show last night
The alleged special significance of the number "six million" There were millions of newspaper pages issued prior to the Holocaust.
Here’s a page from the NYT. (Just one paper.) There were 60 pages in this 1903 issue, and new issues every day of every week of every year, and for half a century: Vince’s collection spans well into the 1800s.