This is probly obvious and I'm just slow on the uptake but I think part of what's going on w/ conversations about AI and writing instruction is that a student can either use AI or learn to write and there's not really a middle ground there. The technology impedes learning writing If I use a hydraulic jack to lift weights in a gym, I'll learn about using a hydraulic jack, but I simply won't develop the skills and capacities that actual weightlifting develops, other than very minimally by unracking the weight plates. AI use is like that relative to writing.

There are bigger outrages but a senior historian writing that historians are less productive and innovative now (and suggesting maybe the field should thus be radically reorganized or even ended) with no real discussion of material conditions is *bananas* insidehighered.com/opinion/blogs/… Dude just retire already

Jha's op-ed follows Biden administration talking points basically to go 'you can safely forget covid.' This has at least two basic kinds of moves. One is to try to get people to overestimate their personal safety. As part of that, he says is that one booster a year is sufficient. In a report published in May, the CDC said that after 6 months the effectiveness of the vaccine against hospitalization falls to 24%. If Jha had any interest in helping people make informed choices, this is the kind of thing he'd talk about. cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/7…

13yo and 9yo relayed a conversation they had with one of their grandmas via zoom. The idea was 'say you had a genie or god-like powers, where you couldn't do mind control or whatever but you could change big picture things, what would you do?' The grandma said 'I'd make people naturally more kind.' 13yo thought that was weird, and was like 'well, the first thing I'd do is stop climate change, that seems obvious? maybe trash capitalism too, because that seems like a widespread problem?' I'm just nodding like 'oh, hmm, huh, interesting.'

Several things make me very angry about Catherine Liu's 'I'm socialist but culturally conservative' routine. One is that the class vs demographic identity categories thing misunderstand both class and identities. The working class are the vast majority in this society for every demographic group. Most black people, immigrants, trans people, etc, are workers. The implication that workers are always Joe The Plumber or whatever is super condescending to loads of workers. I'm angry about another aspect of this condescension, which is the whole 'workers

Angela Nagle's article on why leftists should support migration restriction is terrible garbage in its politics and it's also poorly researched. I wouldn't think it's worth engaging but people in milieus I care about for some reason are engaging her. So, some thoughts. First, as counterpoint to her repugnant call for stricter use of E-Verify people should read this by the National Employment Law Project. s27147.pcdn.co/wp-content/upl… The gist: lots of negative effects in the penumbra of e-verify, and a clear alternative=confer legal status. I'll that I wish