Gethin Chamberlain Profile picture
Freelance journalist and photographer. Human rights and labour rights specialist: environment too. Available for assignments.
Dec 10 23 tweets 6 min read
From the moment Alexander "Sandy" Kemp held up his hand to pause the first witness in the Sandie Peggie tribunal so he could write down what had been said in laborious longhand, it was clear what sort of judge was in charge.🧵 Image Never mind that this unnecessary note-taking disrupted the flow of the evidence and the legal arguments, never mind that there was a stenographer in court and the hearing was recorded, Judge Kemp had his own way of doing things and he was sticking to it.
Dec 9 24 tweets 6 min read
Sandie Peggie has been badly let down by a legal system hamstrung by class and sexism. The employment tribunal simply couldn’t accept that a working class woman might be entitled to stand up for her rights. So it rejected her evidence and tried to rewrite the law. Image Her win was a technical one; a grudging admission by the tribunal that NHS Fife made mistakes in handling her case. But the tribunal made it clear that it did not believe that female staff had any right to single sex spaces. Image
Nov 8 18 tweets 6 min read
Umbrellagate: what goes up must come down. How Police Scotland had to say sorry after allowing one man to dominate a peaceful protest by hundreds of women.
🧵 Image Tom Harlow, a drag performer with a track record of disrupting women’s events, arrived early for the September 4 protest organised by For Women Scotland outside the Scottish parliament. Image
Nov 1 9 tweets 5 min read
Women finally got to speak and be heard at a protest in Edinburgh today after a large police presence kept the usual cohort of aggressive men at a sensible distance. The men were there though - and as obnoxious as ever.
🧵 Image Here's a suggestion: if you think you’re the good guys on the right side of history, don’t behave aggressively and get in the faces of people doing their job. Don’t be abusive. And if you do think you are women, stop being so stereotypically male. Image
Oct 5 14 tweets 4 min read
Police Scotland say they can’t explain why they allowed a women’s rights demonstration to be disrupted outside the Scottish Parliament last month. 🧵 Image They said they were unable to provide answers to an FOI request asking why the rights of one counter demonstrator were given priority over the hundreds of women who attended the Women Won’t Wait event. Image
Sep 4 12 tweets 5 min read
Today was a shameful day for Police Scotland. Women must be able to gather together in public to hold their government to account without being harassed and disrupted by an obnoxious man while police stand idly by. No other peaceful protest would be policed this way.
🧵 Image As hundreds of women’s rights campaigners gathered outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh to lobby their government, they found themselves battling to be heard over the noise of a deafening sound system set up next to them by a trans rights activist. Image
Aug 14 11 tweets 4 min read
The National Library of Scotland is urging members of the public to report language they find "harmful or discriminatory” in its collection. Image In a statement on Equalities, Diversity, and Inclusion the library - which is at the centre of a censorship row - warns that “some material in the collection and the language that describes them may be harmful.” Image
Jul 27 8 tweets 2 min read
The Sandie Peggie tribunal so far:
A nurse walks into the NHS Fife hospital women’s changing room. She’s on her period and it’s heavy: she’s concerned she’s bled through her scrubs. She needs to change, urgently. What she really doesn’t need is a man in her changing room. 🧵 Image Only there’s a problem. Also in the changing room is a man, who insists he’s a woman. He shouldn’t be there, because he’s a man; this is how Sandie Peggie sees it. (And how the UK’s Supreme Court subsequently sees it too.)
Jul 21 6 tweets 2 min read
Extraordinary that NHS Fife/Dr Upton’s legal team continue to smear Sandie Peggie, using hearsay to try to discredit her unblemished record.
A working-class nurse has the cheek to challenge a middle-class doctor?
From the outset the policy has been clear: burn the witch.
🧵 Image Today was a new low: the accusation that she was homophobic lobbed in without evidence in the final moments of the session, based on a rumour that she was unhappy that her daughter was gay. Her daughter promptly stood by her.
Jul 18 6 tweets 2 min read
Somebody has to take responsibility for signing off that NHS Fife statement.
The board chair is Pat Kilpatrick, who was appointed by previous Scottish health secretary Michael Matheson.
Neil Gray, the current health secretary, has the power to sack her. He should, tonight. 🧵 Image Carol Potter, the chief executive, allowed this to happen. Did she sign off on the statement? She certainly allowed it to remain on the NHS Fife website even after the information commissioner warned it could be contempt of court. It’s a resigning matter. Image
Apr 10 12 tweets 3 min read
Good news: embattled NHS Fife has a new plan to tackle discrimination.
Bad news: the plan doesn’t mention women once - even when talking about maternity care.
🧵 Image Highlights of the four year plan include delivering “racially conscious maternity and neonatal care” and developing staff LGBT+, Neurodiversity and Diverse Ethnicity networks. Image
Feb 16 10 tweets 2 min read
NHS Scotland has handed £211,477 of public money to trans rights lobby group Stonewall for advice since 2018.
Meanwhile, NHS Fife has ignored the law on single sex spaces for female staff.
Now it is doubling down and threatening to sack a nurse who challenged its position. 🧵 Image That’s on top of £650,535 of public money given to Stonewall in grants by the Scottish Government over the same period.
Dec 5, 2024 12 tweets 3 min read
It’s that most overwhelming time of the year for the NHS. Again.🧵 Image
Image
2023: “a risk of health service becoming overwhelmed” Image
Jul 12, 2024 5 tweets 2 min read
The suggestion that children will kill themselves if denied puberty blockers would appear to be at odds with established good practice on avoiding imitational suicidal behaviour.🧵 The Samaritans say suicide should not be presented as a solution to a problem and that describing someone overcoming a suicidal crisis can help others do the same. They point out there’s rarely a single reason for suicide.
media.samaritans.org/documents/Medi…
Apr 8, 2024 7 tweets 3 min read
If you tell people with an axe to grind that a grindstone exists, that it is free to use and that, moreover, they should use it, it should not come as a surprise when that’s exactly what they do.
How Scotland’s Hate Crime Act has backfired spectacularly. 🧵
#HateCrime Image It’s true that less has changed than many think. But that’s due to a Scottish Government and Police Scotland communications strategy so hopeless that the Hate Monster campaign to promote the law gifted its opponents a new, instantly recognisable Scottish cultural icon. Image
Apr 6, 2024 11 tweets 4 min read
Women have a right to gather peacefully in a public place to talk to each other about the challenges they face. They should not have to do so
surrounded by a hostile mob of men facilitated by Police Scotland. No other situation would be policed this way. 🧵
#LetWomenSpeak Image It is not progressive for men to shout down female speakers and to drown them out with amplified music and rhetoric. Image
Mar 25, 2024 9 tweets 4 min read
Hate Incidents: how thousands of people are ending up on Scottish police databases for non-crimes.
A week away from the introduction of the Hate Crime Act, this is chilling. 🧵
#HateCrime The new law extends the ways people can end up on a list, but Police Scotland have been recording accusations for several years.
This is their handbook:

scotland.police.uk/spa-media/1igm…
Image