SCOTUS Wire Profile picture
Supreme Court and judiciary news, redistricting and elections. Analysis is my own.
Jul 21 6 tweets 2 min read
🚨 The Second Circuit has vacated a district judge's order releasing a Columbia student from ICE custody, holding that federal district courts generally lack jurisdiction over habeas petitions challenging the legal basis for a noncitizen's removal. Image Judge Livingston said the INA's exclusive review scheme channels legal and constitutional challenges arising from removal proceedings to the immigration courts and, ultimately, a petition for review in the U.S. Court of Appeals, leaving district courts without jurisdiction.
Jul 21 5 tweets 2 min read
🚨 In a 2-1 vote, the D.C. Circuit has denied former President Joe Biden's emergency bid to block the DOJ from releasing Special Counsel Hur's interview transcripts and audio recordings sought by the Heritage Foundation under FOIA. Image The majority held that Biden failed to show he was likely to succeed on the merits. It found the public has a strong interest in evaluating Special Counsel Hur's decision not to charge him, and that DOJ's extensive redactions left Biden's remaining privacy interests outweighed under FOIA Exemption 7(C).
Jul 17 6 tweets 2 min read
🚨 The Third Circuit, sitting en banc, has struck down New Jersey's ban on semi-automatic rifles and its ban on magazines holding more than 10 rounds, ruling both violate the Second Amendment under Bruen. Image Judge Freeman wrote that the ban on semi-automatic rifles violates the Second Amendment because the firearms are commonly possessed for lawful purposes, and the State failed to identify a historical tradition of analogous firearm regulations that justifies prohibiting them.
Jul 9 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 In a 2-1 vote, the Fifth Circuit ruled Texas cannot offer in-state college tuition to undocumented immigrants under its Dream Act, holding federal law overrides the state policy. Image Judge Smith said the case turns on the plain text of federal law, which bars states from giving in-state tuition to undocumented immigrants based on residency unless the same benefit is available to all U.S. citizens regardless of where they live. Texas's law did exactly that.
Jul 9 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 In a 2-1 vote, the Seventh Circuit upheld Illinois's ban on AR-15-style rifles and large-capacity magazines, reversing a federal judge who had struck down the state's Protect Illinois Communities Act after trial. Image The majority said the ban survives the Supreme Court's Bruen test because America has a historical tradition of restricting particularly dangerous weapons, likening AR-15s and 30-round magazines to weapons historically subject to special regulation, such as Bowie knives.
Jul 8 5 tweets 2 min read
🚨 Judge Sparkle L. Sooknanan sharply refuses to stay her ruling dismantling DHS's expanded SAVE system, leaving the agency caught between two directly conflicting federal court orders after a Florida judge ordered the same features restored. Image The dispute centers on DHS's expanded SAVE system, which let states use Social Security numbers and bulk searches to verify citizenship and immigration status for voter rolls and certain other lawful purposes. Judge Sooknanan ruled those changes violated federal law.
Jul 8 6 tweets 2 min read
🚨 In an extraordinary move, the full 7th Circuit took over a case from a three-judge panel before any merits decision, allowing Florida to resume its lawsuit against the American Academy of Pediatrics that alleges it misled families about treatments for transgender minors. Image Florida sued the American Academy of Pediatrics in state court, alleging it misled families about medical treatments for gender dysphoria in minors through its clinical guidance, policy statements, and advocacy. A Chicago federal judge later blocked that lawsuit.
Jul 2 5 tweets 2 min read
🚨 In a 2–1 vote, the Fifth Circuit ruled that immigrants who entered the U.S. without inspection but have lived here for years cannot be held indefinitely without an individualized bond hearing. The court held the Fifth Amendment requires a hearing by 90 days of detention. Image The majority said Congress cannot define the scope of the Fifth Amendment by labeling someone an "applicant for admission." While the INA mandates detention, the Constitution independently protects people who have lived in the U.S. for years and developed substantial ties.
Jun 24 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 In a 2-1 vote, the Sixth Circuit ruled that the DOJ cannot force Michigan to turn over its unredacted statewide voter-registration database under the Civil Rights Act of 1960. Image Judge Mathis, joined by Judge Cole, said the Civil Rights Act of 1960 only covers voting records that election officials "acquire" from others, such as voter-registration applications. Michigan's statewide voter database is created and maintained by the state itself.
Jun 22 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 Judge Sparkle Sooknanan has struck down the Trump administration's expanded SAVE voter-verification system, ruling that federal agencies unlawfully created a centralized database containing Social Security and citizenship data to facilitate mass voter verification. Image The court ruled the agencies violated the Privacy Act, the Social Security Act, and the APA, and found they proceeded despite knowing the citizenship data contained accuracy problems that could wrongly flag eligible U.S. citizens as non-citizens.
Jun 22 5 tweets 2 min read
🚨 The Supreme Court reinstated a New York man's murder conviction, holding that federal habeas courts cannot overturn state convictions based on legal rules the Supreme Court has never clearly established.

Justices Sotomayor dissents, joined by Kagan and Jackson. Image The case stems from the 1979 disappearance and murder of six-year-old Etan Patz. Pedro Hernandez confessed multiple times in 2012, and a New York jury convicted him of kidnapping and felony murder. The Second Circuit had ordered habeas relief based on the trial court's response to a jury question about the confessions.
Jun 19 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 A federal judge rejected former President Biden's bid to block the Justice Department from releasing redacted audio recordings and transcripts from Special Counsel Robert Hur's investigation. Image Judge Friedrich ruled Biden is unlikely to succeed on the merits because the Privacy Act does not clearly bar disclosure, and DOJ reasonably concluded that the public interest in records relied upon by Hur outweighs Biden's diminished privacy interests after redactions.
May 27 6 tweets 2 min read
🚨 Callais plaintiffs accuse Louisiana of dragging out the redistricting process and concealing the state’s true election deadline to keep an allegedly unconstitutional race-based congressional map in place for the 2026 elections. Image Plaintiffs argue that Louisiana’s leading proposed congressional map, SB121, preserves the race-based structure of the current majority-Black 2nd District, emulating the 2022 and 2011 maps.
May 26 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 A Florida judge declined to block the state’s new congressional map for the 2026 elections. Image Judge Joshua Hawkes says Florida courts cannot block the state’s new congressional map by temporarily reinstating the old 2022 map, because state leaders contend that map itself contains unconstitutional race-based districts.
May 26 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 A federal court has blocked Alabama from using its new congressional map, ordering the state to use a court-imposed map with 2 majority-black seats for the 2026 elections. Image The three-judge panel finds that Plaintiffs are likely to succeed on their Section 2 claims even after Callais.

It also finds that Alabama intentionally discriminated against black voters in violation of the 14th Amendment.
May 14 4 tweets 1 min read
🚨 The Supreme Court has temporarily restored nationwide access to mail-order abortion pills, staying a 5th Circuit ruling pending appeal. Image Justice Thomas dissents, arguing that shipping mifepristone for abortion violates the federal Comstock Act. He says the manufacturers cannot claim irreparable harm from losing profits tied to what he described as a criminal enterprise.
May 12 5 tweets 1 min read
🚨 A panel of judges is considering blocking Alabama's 2023 congressional map a second time after the Supreme Court vacated its first injunction last night. Image
Image
Plaintiffs have already filed for a Temporary Restraining Order. The Court invites them to file motions for preliminary injunctions under Section 2 and the 14th Amendment, briefing the effect of Callais.
May 7 5 tweets 2 min read
🚨 The U.S. Court of International Trade struck down President Trump’s 10% global tariff on imported goods, holding he exceeded his authority under Section 122 of the Trade Act. Image The majority said Congress only gave presidents limited emergency tariff powers under Section 122, aimed at specific international payments crises tied to the old Bretton Woods financial system.

The Trump administration unlawfully used that law to target modern trade deficits.
Apr 29 13 tweets 2 min read
🧵 In today's Voting Rights Act ruling, the Supreme Court has fundamentally reshaped how courts apply Section 2 to voting maps, especially in relation to politics, making future Section 2 lawsuits extremely difficult to win.

The changes: 1. For the first time ever, the Court holds that compliance with Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act can be a compelling interest to use race, but only when properly construed.
Jan 31 4 tweets 2 min read
🚨 A federal judge has issued a writ of habeas corpus ordering the release of an asylum seeker and his 5 year old son, holding that ICE administrative warrants fail the 4th Amendment's probable cause requirement.

Read the 3-page ruling here: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.usco…Image
Image
Image
This is honestly the most unhinged opinion of a federal judge that I've ever read. The scathing and antagonistic language is one thing, but he makes a sweeping holding that the 4th Amendment requires an independent judicial officer, not administrative warrants, with ZERO analysis.
Jan 21 4 tweets 2 min read
🚨 A New York judge has STRUCK DOWN the State's congressional map under the NY Constitution.

Justice Pearlman orders the IRC to redraw NY-11 into a Black/Latino influence district by linking Staten Island and lower Manhattan, dismantling Republican Nicole Malliotakis's seat. Image
Image
Image
The new map must be in place by February 6th, 2026. The current NY-11 has existed since 1980.

Pearlman's test largely tracks the current framework used for Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act as applied to redistricting.