David Slack Profile picture
TV Writer: Person of Interest, Teen Titans, Law & Order, Lie To Me, Magnum PI https://t.co/SQYmrHthAU
Kelly Sue DeConnick Profile picture 1 subscribed
Nov 18, 2023 8 tweets 3 min read
Just to clarify:

The “writer is a person” language in our new WGA contract is not just a platitude.

It has a huge impact on who gets paid and how much, and it protects writers from being paid to “rewrite” AI nonsense for a fraction of the fair rate. If AI text was allowed to be source material, studios could generate millions of “ideas” to claim as IP.

When a writer came in with an original idea, they’d search the AI library, find something vaguely similar, and pay the writer less.

But they can’t — because of our contract.
Nov 7, 2023 9 tweets 2 min read
When it comes to AI protections, SAG-AFTRA isn’t just fighting to protect their lowest-paid members.

They’re fighting to protect every performer in their union — and thousands of other jobs in the entertainment industry.🧵 hollywoodreporter.com/business/busin… The AMPTP’s “last best final” proposal would allow them to body scan performers making *more than minimum* in TV and features.

Performers would get paid once. But studios would be allowed to profit off their AI likenesses without their approval forever — even after they’re dead. The Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers is seeking to secure Al scans for Schedule F performers - guild members who earn more than the minimum for series regulars ($32,000 per TV episode) and feature films ($60,000). The companies' suggested clause would require studios and streamers to pay to scan the likeness of Schedule F performers. SAG-AFTRA is seeking to attach a compensation for the re-use of AI scans as AMPT member companies would also need to secure consent from the performer. The language currently in the AMPTP's offer would see the studios and streamers secure the...
Nov 5, 2023 7 tweets 2 min read
At this crucial moment in SAG-AFTRA negotiations, here’s some WGA history that SAG members should know.

In our 2007-08 strike, our leadership wanted to hold out a little bit longer to get the best deal. But 30 wealthy WGA members thought they knew better.🧵 These 30 wealthy writers drew a few of our leaders into an ambush meeting and told them: “You’re done.”

They insisted that we take the DGA deal or they would start scabbing.

The betrayal by these 30 wealthy writers — The Dirty 30 — forced WGA leaders to end our strike early.
Nov 5, 2023 5 tweets 2 min read
“Last Best and Final.”

Carol’s three favorite words — because they’re a classic unionbusting trick.

The WGA got “last best finaled,” and you know what we did? We kept right on negotiating for the AI protections we needed.

Because AMPTP rhetoric doesn’t change the facts.🧵 The fact is that the studios and streamers don’t want to quit the entertainment business. So they’re gonna have to make a deal at some point.

The fact is that they are desperate to get actors back to work before they lose any more money.
Nov 1, 2023 14 tweets 3 min read
A few high-profile members are pressing SAG-AFTRA negotiators to take a deal.

A unique challenge for Hollywood unions is that some members think success in *individual* negotiations makes them experts in union negotiations.

If anything, the opposite is true. Here’s why:🧵 When you get offered a job in Hollywood, that’s an individual negotiation. In this type of negotiation, the Venn diagram is two circles that are mostly overlapping.

You want to work for the company, they want to hire you, and you just need to settle a few issues to make a deal. A Venn diagram in which the circles labeled “Company” and “Worker” are mostly overlapping.
Oct 25, 2023 9 tweets 2 min read
Instead of negotiating in good faith, it seems studios, and their anti-union allies are using scare tactics and outright lies to try to trick SAG-AFTRA members into pressing their leaders to take a bad deal.

Don’t confuse their fiction with facts:🧵 FICTION:
“Money from the new streaming percentage would go to the Union, not the members.”

FACTS:
This is a b.s. scare tactic. *All* residuals go to the union, which processes them and sends you checks. Been this way for decades. This is nothing new and nothing to be afraid of.
Oct 25, 2023 7 tweets 2 min read
These stories in the trades have some SAG-AFTRA members concerned.

First, these are likely a kernel of truth under a steaming pile of studio spin.

But let’s cut to the chase. Is Fran Drescher eccentric? Hell yes.

And there’s enormous power in that.🧵
Before talks had broken off, sources say, the four CEOs who attended SAG-AFTRAS negotiations had been taken aback by Drescher's negotiating style, which involved bringing a doll (a heart-shaped plush toy with a smiley face given to Drescher by an 11-year-old fan) and saying Buddhist inspirational quotes. She also alarmed the CEOs when she proclaimed, "I don't care if we are here for a year" in order to achieve the unions ends, sources maintain, which a union source denies. A source close to the union explains that Drescher uses a "less contentious" bargaining process and...
Drescher opened the first Zoom meeting with the A-listers by asking to take a screenshot, or selfie of sorts, according to two sources familiar with the session. The source close to the union maintains that Drescher wanted to take a screenshot in order to preserve the historic moment in the life of the union; SAG-AFTRA collects the history of its union as part of its general operations. Perry politely declined, expressing that he would prefer to get down to business.
CEOs are used to being in rooms with people they can control. People who are afraid of them.

From the start of this negotiation, Fran has made it clear that they cannot control her — and she is not afraid of them.

That scares the shit out of CEOs and gives SAG-AFTRA power.
Oct 23, 2023 17 tweets 3 min read
Since the CEOs walked away from negotiations with SAG-AFTRA on Oct. 11, the AMPTP and Molly Levinson’s unionbusting crisis PR firm have been spinning out nothing but propaganda and outright lies.

With negotiations resuming tomorrow, it’s time to set the record straight.🧵 MINIMUMS:

SAG-AFTRA is seeking a significantly larger increase in minimums than the WGA and DGA got. But there are good reasons for that.

First, a 5% increase after 2 years of 6+% inflation isn’t a raise at all — it’s a pay cut.
Oct 22, 2023 12 tweets 2 min read
Heard a rumor circulating among SAG-AFTRA members that the WGA “finally figured out their deal when writers put pressure on the union to find a solution.”

This is 10000% WRONG.

And this rumor is unionbusting b.s. Here’s why:🧵 First, this claim about the WGA is completely false.

There was never any widespread pressure from WGA members asking our leaders to cave.

That just did not happen.
Sep 26, 2023 9 tweets 2 min read
As WGA leaders meet today to finalize our deal, we begin a new era for writers — and for labor in our industry.

But we also begin to face the final and most insidious form of unionbusting propaganda: a years-long effort to sell the lie that our strike was not worth it.🧵 Over the coming days, months, and years, the studios, streamers, and their surrogates will take every opportunity to undermine what we have won together.

They will seize on the inevitable consessions and compromises made by our NegCom as proof that we “failed.”
Sep 21, 2023 7 tweets 2 min read
Okay. This is some bullshit. This morning, all the CEOs “cleared their schedules” in order to make a deal. But now, some anonymous source says if we don’t take what they’re offering by end of day tomorrow — they’re just gonna trash the rest of the year? Absurd.🧵 Does anyone believe those CEOs wanted to clear their schedules and be in that room today? Hell no. They pay Carol for that.

They were there because they had to be — because our power demanded it.
Sep 15, 2023 10 tweets 2 min read
Now that the WGA has confirmed the possibility of a meeting, I really hope this is the start of genuine good faith negotiations by the studios.

But if they’re following the old unionbusting playbook, which they have so far, it’s possible this is a trap.🧵 deadline.com/2023/09/writer… With the caveat that I have no inside info about this negotiation, here’s how this unionbusting trap works:

They’ve already done the simple version on 8/22: Set a meeting, get everyone’s hopes up, then dash them.

But there’s an even more insidious version of this trap.
Sep 11, 2023 20 tweets 5 min read
People are understandably confused about how Drew Barrymore could be scabbing against the WGA and not against SAG-AFTRA.

So let’s take this opportunity to increase our union literacy. 🧵 Unions are complicated. They come in all shapes and sizes and can operate in a variety of different ways.

For example, both the WGA and SAG-AFTRA are called “guilds” rather than unions because they represent independent contractors instead of employees.
Sep 10, 2023 4 tweets 1 min read
It is not too late for @DrewBarrymore to stop this and do the right thing.

If her concern is paying the crew, it seems like someone who was born rich and has starred in hit movies since childhood might be able to find a better solution than working with scab writers. #WGAStrong And by the way, do you know why @DrewBarrymore was born rich and got richer?

Because her father, grandfather, great aunt, great uncle were all in UNIONS.

Without rights and residuals negotiated by unions, Ms. Barrymore would have just a fraction of the wealth she enjoys.
Sep 9, 2023 9 tweets 3 min read
After today’s WGA message called out the studios’ and steamers’ failure to get on the same page, the AMPTP has released a statement of their own — and they’re trying to rewrite the past. But there’s just one problem:

We have receipts.🧵 Two days after the AMPTP pulled their dirty trick of trying to go around our negotiators by releasing their version of their 8/11 counter directly to the public, the WGA released this detailed timeline of events: wgacontract2023.org/announcements/…
Sep 7, 2023 9 tweets 2 min read
Studio CEOs should be talking about their response to out 8/15 counter, but instead, they’re suspending big overalls. Why? Simple.

1. They need the money.

2. They’re hoping to trick a group of high-level writers into publicly criticizing the Guild. 🧵 deadline.com/2023/09/warner… Through this strike, our biggest strength has been the unwavering solidarity of our membership. And this includes the overwhelming majority of showrunners — as demonstrated by their constant presence on the picket lines and generous donations to help people weather the strike.
Sep 1, 2023 6 tweets 1 min read
“Whatever short-term financial gain the studios represented by the [AMPTP] hoped to gain by forcing the first dual strike of writers and actors in 40 years has long since been overshadowed by all that they are losing.” #WGAStrong #SAGAFTRAStrong latimes.com/entertainment-… “The writers and actors have already won the battle of solidarity and righteousness; the question now is how long before the studios get over themselves and make a deal.”
Aug 26, 2023 4 tweets 2 min read
When Molly Levinson tweeted this resounding call last year, it seemed like she was someone who stood with the workers.

But I guess her call wasn’t that resounding because now — just over one year later — she has sided with the AMPTP and signed on to help them union-bust.
Image It’s disappointing that Ms. Levinson, who held herself out as a champion of labor and fair pay would seemingly abandon her values to help billionaire CEOs making $30B in profit every year try to screw workers out of a reasonable cost-of-living raise the studios can easily afford. Cost of WGA Proposal* Company Disney Netflix Warner Bros. Discovery Paramount Global NBC Universal Amazon Sony Apple Annual Annual Cost % of Cost Revenues Revenues S72 mn 565 mn §45 mn §43 mn $33 mn $31 mn $24 mn $17 mn $82.7 bn 0.088% $31.6 bn 0.206% $43.1 bn** 0.104% $30.2 bn 0.143% $121.4 bn 0.027% $514.0 bn 0.006% $88.8 bn 0.027% $394.3 bn 0.004% *In practice, the above totals over-estimate the impact to the companies' bottom lines, as many of the costs will simply be absorbed into the budgets of individual television and film projects. **Combined company projection
Aug 23, 2023 5 tweets 2 min read
In a desperate move, the AMPTP has released their proposals publicly. Not only are these proposals still inadequate, they are an attempt by the bosses to divide our members, hoping we’ll start arguing with each other over which parts we can and can’t live with. Don’t fall for it. They know they can’t beat our negotiators in the negotiating room, so they’re trying to negotiate directly with us. Don’t let them.

Writers are used to this slimy move. When we’re making a deal, producers will call us complaining our reps are crazy and asking for too much.
Aug 5, 2023 9 tweets 2 min read
As expected, the studios have used today’s meeting as an excuse to push out dishonest talking points aimed at breaking union solidarity. Don’t let it work.

The WGA will tell us what really happened, but let’s decode the bullshit in this “article.” 🧵 First, the studios identify two “non-starters” among our proposals. This is a ploy. They’re hoping members will push to give up these important proposals just to get another meeting with the AMPTP. They’re trying to get us to negotiate with ourselves.

Hard pass, Carol.
Jul 22, 2023 15 tweets 3 min read
The studios claim they shouldn’t have to share revenue for the success of the shows we make succeed because they assume all the risk.

Well.

To paraphrase a famous actor: There’s more than one type of risk, motherfucker. While the studios and their new hedge fund besties may assume some modest financial risk, any losses just go on a balance sheet next to the C-suite’s golden parachutes.

The workers in this industry, on the other hand, risk a hell of a lot more than that.