Restrictions of any kind at all once vaccine supply has outstripped demand are completely ludicrous. It's amazing that an explanation is even necessary, but, well, here we are. All we need to break this down is some simple logic. Here goes...
When it comes to a circulating virus, there are four conceivable paths a person can take:
1) Face the virus at some point. Survive and you develop immunity. 2) Gain immunity via vaccination 3) Die of some other cause first 4) Live the rest of your life in sterile isolation
Now, I think the evidence by now is overwhelming that lockdowns and mask mandates don't work, but let's give the biggest benefit of the doubt to the pro-lockdown side and, for the moment, cede that ground. We won't convince them now. For their benefit, let's assume the NPIs work.
I've given some thought to this Delta Variant brouhaha, and have a hypothesis. If you're nervous about a return to lockdowns, I wouldn't be. Renewed mask mandates are slightly more conceivable, but I'd also bet against those happening. So why am I optimistic? Here's why...
The Delta Variant appears to be easily transmissible, but milder, frequently producing symptoms similar to a cold.
Late April is when we saw mask mandates begin to wither at the national level. That this was 2 1/2 weeks after vaccine demand peaked was not a coincidence. This is when the government's primary aim shifted from sustaining lockdowns to pushing vaccination.
This is a great, authentic, and devastating thread, and I agree with everything @annbauerwriter expresses. But at the end, she asks for stories of hope, reasons why we shouldn't feel too down. Here's mine. (1/)
In 2008, I survived a bout with cancer, with significant symptoms. I was too weak to run. Walking winded me. Night sweats, weight loss, clouded mind. This happened while I was engaged to be married. All I wanted in the world was to feel normal again one day. (2/)
You know how people who grew up poor see it as sinful to waste food, because they have experienced a world where food isn't a given? Well, my experience battling cancer gave me that same aversion to wastefulness, only in my case I cannot tolerate wasting time. (3/)
Since vaccines came available, there's been an odd phenomenon: Many of the most ardent pro-lockdown, pro-mask zealots show euphoric excitement - sometimes to the point of tears - at receiving a COVID vaccine. They share photos far and wide... (1/)
And then, having received the vaccine, they go straight back to double masking, staying isolated, and shaming all who don't do the same that the vaccine changes nothing.
If you truly believe the vaccine works, this makes no sense. If you don't, why were you so excited to get it?
This is obviously unscientific and seems irrational.
Up until now, my theory has been that these most ardent zealots have completely lost touch with rational cost-benefit analysis and are effectively living "virtually," a meme and narrative based existence where selfie = truth.
A realization has been weighing on my mind lately: As we in America emerge from the pandemic, our traditional geographical/cultural alignments are, and will, prove a significant psychological hurdle we need to clear as we return to normal. Thread upcoming... (1/)
First off, others can continue to debate the wisdom of lockdown policies and mask mandates if they wish. Me, personally, I'm done with those serious debates. Not because I am tired of them (though I certainly am), but because they are no longer serious debates. It's over. (2/)
We have abundant data from a full year, and scientific consensus from before the Chinese snookered some and found convenient ideological allies in others: Lockdowns do not work. They only inflict harm. Mask mandates do not work. They only perpetuate power and fear. Period. (3/)
To be a hardcore mask advocate, you must simultaneously believe the following:
1) Dr. Fauci's guidance against masks in March 2020 was to preserve supply for health-care workers, despite the fact this had been the consensus opinion at times with no pandemic (or fear of shortage)
2) Reams of data spontaneously appeared in Spring 2020, confirming the efficacy of cloth and surgical masks vs. COVID-19 (though the public has not seen any such reams of data - only a few weak examples of correlation), cementing the new consensus.
3) Masks have been so effective as to make the "old" virus (flu) disappear almost completely, while failing to move the numbers significantly against COVID. This proves the masks work AND that COVID is dangerous. Even though the consensus is that masks prevent COVID transmission.