This is the second afternoon session, Sandie Peggie vs Fife NHS Trust & Dr Upton at the Employment Tribunal in Dundee. J No questions from us. NC?
NC No
J That was your chance to follow up on your objection q
NC Nothing further
J Thank you SP. You may go. Concludes C case
J We would like written submissions, partial or skeleton, with at least a list of authorities by noon tomorrow and parties can

The afternoon session will start at 13.20 with a private case management meeting. We expect to be admitted after the private matters are concluded. Sandie Peggie vs Fife NHS Trust & Dr Upton at the Employment Tribunal in Dundee.

Second morning session continuing cross examination of Dr Maggie Currer on final day of evidence about to start:

NC Re the 1 line para of letter of 5 Jan re SP being referred to NMC: want to set a few things out. If the NMC does take FtP claim she'd be able to see evidence of referrals. Or arising from other hearings. So other evid may come to light
MC I understand
NC U seem to be acknow a referral has been made. It's what u were told in a face to face mtg
MC I never thought she had been referred. Pending the Ix results, if found if she'd broken

We are due to begin live tweeting day 9 of Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton at the earlier time of 9.30am.
Today is the final day of evidence and will begin with Dr Maggie Currer returning to the witness box. A reminder about our reporting:

We resume after a break for an issue with the bundle not containing all of the new pages

JR This is new evidence recently produced. The BGC from Jan 2024. We wont say others names. [reads re trans have all the rights and the only way we can get round this is ??] What did u make of this by SP?
LN I just need a moment to think. I think she's trying to find a quicker way around this , going forward
JR Can u describe any more
J Can u put yr mic down?
JR what do u mean?
LN Only way we can do this is to say we werent told about this.

Our scheduled start time in Peggie v NHS Fife & Dr B Upton for this afternoon's session is 1.30pm. Two witnesses are scheduled for today, both emergency nurse practitioners: Lindsey Nicoll and Fiona Wishart but if there's time a new witness for the Claimant may give evidence. A reminder about our reporting:

Part two of morning session in Peggie vs NHS Fife & Dr B Upton will continue here. No witness evidence this morning, discussions about timetable, further material and additional witnesses. See our coverage here.
archive.ph/lCyHK Judge & Panel return.
J - we've got the docs, JR have you looked at these
JR - don't object, simply object to 2 add'l witnesses
J - we consider in principle that it is permissible to call add'l witnesses in response to what R's late witnesses says. And in principle, to recall

Scheduled start time in Peggie v NHS Fife & Dr B Upton is 10 am. Our reporting will be on this thread. Two witnesses scheduled for today:
Lindsey Nicoll, emergency nurse practitioner Fiona Wishart, emergency nurse practitioner Our previous coverage is found on our Substack here:
open.substack.com/pub/tribunaltw…
Reporting on Part 1 here:
tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/peggie-vs-fi…

We will shortly be live tweeting the afternoon session of day 8 of Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton to hear the examination of Dr Maggie Currer (MC), Deputy Clinical Lead). It is due to start at 2pm. A reminder about our reporting:

Day 8 morning session 2 will continue here. The morning 1 session of day 8 can be found here

https://x.com/tribunaltweets/status/1948634213789347997

Good morning.
Day 8 morning session of the July hearing of Sandie Peggie v NHS Fife Health Board and Dr Upton will be reported on this thread.

The start time is 10am.

We expect witnesses Peter Donaldson (PD) and Jim Borwick (JB) both IT experts and Dr Maggie Currer (MC) A reminder of our disclaimer:

Day 7 afternoon session 2 follows here. We resume:
J - AH you will take an oath
AH - takes oath
J - ask for slow testimony
JR - full name
AH - mary anne hamilton
JR - how long with fife
AH -since 2006
Role
AH - was HR advisor

Good afternoon.
This is the first afternoon session of the 7th Day of the July hearings of Peggie v NHS Fife and Dr Upton.

We anticipate restarting at 2pm

Please see earlier posts linked below for this mornings coverage, notices and abbreviations This morning's coverage:

https://x.com/tribunaltweets/status/1948288981646348529

Welcome back to Part 3 of the morning session on DAY 7 of the July hearing of Sandie Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton.

Angela Glancy who led the investigation (ix) continues on the witness stand.
Find previous reporting on our substack [HEARING RESUMES 12:11]

NC - I'm going to ask a few Qs about ix now. So looking at email top of page from DU to u. U have contacted him about meeting 26th April and he asks if u want his full statement including Xmas eve incident. We see u talk about dates but dont answer

Welcome back to Part 2 of the morning session on DAY 7 of the July hearing of Sandie Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton.

Angela Glancy who led the investigation (ix) continues on the witness stand.
Find previous reporting on our substack NC - DU phone log, no mention of it in iv. Aware of notes when you interviewed him?

Good morning.
Day 7 morning session of the July hearing of Sandie Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton will be reported on this thread.

The start time is 10am, though there may be delays.
We expect witnesses Angela Glancey (led investigation) + Anne Hamilton (HR advisor) A reminder of our disclaimer

Day 6 afternoon, second session will continue here. J - you are still under oath
NC - afternoon KS. Back to doc disclosures and when 6th Feb, told you had further searched emails - JR said completed, previous, KS found another 4 emails...
J - slower and louder
NC - JR said KS had performed another search, 4 more emails sent over

We will hopefully be reporting from Day 6 of the July hearing of Sandie Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton.
The first session was in private + ran into lunch. At 1.15pm when Naomi Cunningham (NC) will continue her cross of Emergency Dept Consultant Dr Kate Searle (KS). We begin.
J - before we start - considered press release of 18 jul, addressed in submission. No order in realtion to it. Can sit late if needed. Assume you are Miss Harris. Which oath?
Takes oath.
J - explains need for slow answers and speaking up.

We will shortly be reporting from day 6 of the July hearing of Sandie Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton.
The first session is due to start at 11.30am when Naomi Cunningham (NC) will continue her cross examination of Emergency Dept Consultant Dr Kate Searle (KS). A reminder of our disclaimer

We're tweeting the second afternoon session of Peggie v Fife NHS Board and Dr Upton.
Naomi Cunningham will be cross examining ED consultant Kate Searle. NC Good afternoon Dr Searle. I'd like to ask u some questions about documents first. That's MCs 5.2 email that yr cced into. Did u receive it?
KS Yes
NC Have u seen this case mgmt order before?
No
NC It's orders that the Rs provided. It says asap but Rs must supply all docs..

The afternoon session of Peggie v Fife Health Board and Dr Upton is due to start at 2pm. We will be continuing with the examination of ED consultant Kate Searle (KS). A reminder about our reporting: