Phil Booth Profile picture
Mind 'for hire'; critical friend to just causes. Formerly and currently @NO2ID; still also @medConfidential

Sep 24, 2020, 9 tweets

Helpful #nhsxCOVID19app explainer [Thread] 👇 from @hadleybeeman.

For more technical background, see github.com/nhsx/covid19-a… for, e.g. system architecture (v3) and (predominantly @AWS) infrastructure.

Of course, we're still waiting for the results of the trials...

...and, as the BBC's write-up concludes, evidence that #ExposureNotification works in practice is "scant" - in ALL countries attempting it, not just the UK:

bbc.co.uk/news/technolog…

Efficacy (as in NZ) will most likely come from #QRcheckin, which could've been done months ago.

Bottom line, will I be downloading it? Already have - as I did with the other versions, to see what they did.

Will I be using it? Probably. Not least to avoid having to hand over personal details; combined with regular data deletes/resets.

Will I trust it to keep me safe? No...

...because there is literally no evidence that it will. Plus it's highly dependent on #testing being available, accurate and quick - and we're struggling to get more than 1 out of those 3 right at present.

Meanwhile, #Hands #Face #Space

N.B. Geeks like me may be interested to compare the three #PrivacyNotices:

1) Full notice, updated today (24 Sept):
gov.uk/government/pub…

2) Notice for "young people":
gov.uk/government/pub…

3) "Easy read" notice [PDF]:
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…

Interesting behaviour on the @Android version of #nhsxCOVID19app: it appears you cannot use ANY of the other (non-#ContactTracing) features of the app if you switch off #Bluetooth and/or #Location on your phone - even if you've also switched off 'Contact Tracing' in the app...

...there seems no good reason why this should be, if #Bluetooth and #Location are really only required for #ExposureNotification - why do they have to be switched on (thus, e.g. passing your Location to other apps on your phone) for #QRcheckin, basic advice and #SymptomChecking?

Maybe someone will do us all a favour (and keep @DHSCgovuk honest) by offering a standalone #QRcheckin app?

#FeatureBloat is one thing; denying access to functions on the basis of a feature that is *supposed to be under user control* entirely another!

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling