Shabbir Ahmed Profile picture
Once a paperboy, now a journalist. Senior News Editor @thenewsminute . Chevening fellow. Opinions expressed here are personal.

Aug 27, 2021, 16 tweets

#Thread: A heist-cum-murder took place at the sprawling estate of Ex-CM #Jayalalithaa at #Kodanadu in 2017

During the robbery attempt, watchman Om Bahadur was killed and as per the chargesheet, the accused stole only 10 wrist watches & a crystal rhinoceros doll from the estate

Subsequent to the heist-cum-murder at #Kodanadu, the main accused Kanakaraj died in an accident 4 days after the crime

Similarly, another accused Sayan's car met with an accident. He lost his wife & child.

Later, the computer operator at the estate died by alleged suicide.

Considering the crime took place at a former CM's bunglow and with all these murky twists in the case, one would imagine that TN police would do a through investigation to bring out the truth.

I took a closer look at the case documents & it reveals some shocking details.

A murder-cum-heist took place at former CM's residence between 12 am- 2am and the Inspector from Kotagiri police station arrives at the spot 7.5 HOURS later!!

The IO says he got the info regarding the incident only at 7.30 am.

During the cross examination, the IO says they did not obtain the signature of complainant Krishna Thaba who is also the security guard at the Kodanadu Estate not because he had injuries in his right hand, but they FORGOT to take his signature on the FIR

Were CCTV cameras installed at the ex-CM's Kodanadu Estate?

The IO says he found there were no CCTV cameras in the estate during his investigation!!

This is a security sensitive location where a ex CM stayed and the IO says they were no CCTVs

Defense lawyer: Isn't it the responsibility of the police officer to visit the place where a person is lying dead?

IO: Gate No 8 was closer, so I decided to visit it first then went to examine Gate no 10 area where Om Bahadur was killed. It was 11.30 am when I visited Gt No 10

The IO in his deposition says they examined the hall area of the bungalow & on the first-floor, locks to the 2 rooms were broke open.

During cross examination, IO admits that he did not click pictures of the 2 rooms on the 1st floor which were broke open despite examining them

No (Mahasar/ Spot map) record was created regarding the hall area or 2 rooms on the first floor which were broke open

No forensic evidence was collected from the hall and the 2 rooms.

One room belong to Ex-CM Jayalalithaa & another room belongs to Sasikala

Defense Lawyer – Did the CM's room have any valuable items?

IO – I have no knowledge about that and when I examined the showcase,I found another crystal rhinoceros piece. Totally there were 2 crystal pieces, and one was stolen.

The police did not reach out to the owners of #Kodanadu estates.

DL – Did Kodanadu Estate manager provide you details of things that went missing from the estate during your investigation?

IO – No

DL – Did you prepare an inventory of the things that were there?

IO - No

During the cross-examination, the IO confirms that the Accused No 1 Kanakaraj, who was the former driver of CM J Jayalalithaa, belongs to Edappadi Taluk.

The IO says he does not know whether EPS & Kanakaraj belong to the same area.

When asked by the lawyer if the ‘political angle’ or motive was investigated, the IO says he did investigate the political angle.

When asked specifically the IO says he investigated the ‘political angle’ in general and not in particular.

How did the cops investigate the accident of Kanagaraj and Sayan:

DL – The death of one of the accused Kanakaraj, has raised many doubts in this case?

IO– I don’t know anything regarding this

DL– Did you enquire about A1 accused Sayan meeting with an accident?

IO– No

After going through hundreds of case file documents, it's clear that there are many glaring loopholes and lapses in police investigations.

This raises a lot of questions. Most importantly, why was the probe in such a sensitive case conducted in a shoddy manner?

BIG QUESTIONS:

FORMER CM'S RESIDENCE CUM MINI SECRETARIAT WAS ROBBED, WHY WAS IT NOT TRANSFERRED TO A SPECIALISED UNIT LIKE CBCID?

WHY WAS NO SENIOR OFFICER ASSIGNED TO SUPERVISE THE PROBE OF THIS HIGH-PROFILE CASE?

WHY NONE OF THE SENIOR POLICE OFFICERS VISITED THE SPOT?

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling