Thread by @Rnb129

Some people are so clueless, or deliberately treacherous, that they don't call out the #GalwanValley attack for what it is - UNPROVOKED attack on an Indian CO coming to talk peace. You think our journos won't know this?

And yet, they ask where's Modi's nationalism or his 56"!

Remember, there was NO gunfire in the #GalwanValley incident. It was close combat. The CO goes to talk. His party of 20 is attacked with cement and iron rods laced with barbed wire. The CO got struck in the eye and fell into the ravines. Another fell after a hit to the head

This is not some intelligence leak like Uri or Pathankot, where troop movements or Army truck positions are leaked, and questions are natural. This is open treachery, to invite for talks then ambush with brutal clubs. What sane civilisation can prevent THAT? #GalwanValley

Keep a close track of those politically opposed to this Govt. While it's fashionable to "demand answers", who do they demand them from? The peacemomgers who sent a CO to talk or the treacherous Chinese who clubbed him with cement rods of barbed wire? #GalwanValley

If it's so easy, how hard was it to pop Musharraf's head off in Agra 2 years after Kargil? How hard was it to pounce on Yousuf Raza Gilani who was here for the 2011 Cricket World Cup semifinal? You learn the hard way ONCE, that only one side is playing in the spirit of the game.

And THAT, is when govt responds. The question in a breach of trust and decency is never "HOW", but "WHAT NEXT?". And that's how India decided to fight fire with fire. Once the CO was hit, the last-mile soldier wasn't going to await instructions. Outnumbered 15:1, casualties 1:2

That's exactly what President Roosevelt did after Japan attacked Pearl Harbor in 1941 - again in the middle of deescalation tensions. Nobody asked how. They all demanded what next. The President got authorisation for war from Congress, and it was a near unanimous YES.

The one NO vote, to 470 YES was a peacenik who claimed that as a woman she would never vote for war. What people of her ilk never understand is that nobody wants a war or to lose your own people. But when war is THRUST upon you, you have no choice!

How one can blame the Indian Govt, when the PLA committed what appears to be a blatant war crime flouting the last of the Geneva norms, beats me!
But such are the internal challenges that Modi faces.

Okay, so will they at least will him into decisive retribution? No they won't.

Just check the responses on Twitter. There's anger directed at Chinese products for a start, and these very "intellectuals" are mocking that as a pusillanimous "Bhakt" response #GalwanValley

There were snide jabs on @CNNnews18 last night by Zakka Jacob asking an officer wouldn't the response be different if it were Pakistan? This is China, he noted gleefully, so this Government has been shown it's place! He didn't show OWNERSHIP at all, like it was some random govt!

Good on that officer to put his snooty tongue where it belongs. All he had to do was point out that in response to provocation, 43 Chinese died so where's the question of "different treatment"? #GalwanValley

Zakka kept on with his Pak-China hyphenation until he was rudely reminded Pak sends terrorists, but China sent their own Army, so they aren't even the same thing! Sad that for some people, yesterday was just a stick to beat the Govt with. #GalwanValley

Forget news for a few days. It's so predictable.
1. 20 martyred --> What's 56" doing?
2. If Strongly worded address --> war is not the solution
3. If call for deescalation --> 56" is now 5.6"
4. If Army takes action --> Where's proof?/Why should we believe you? We believe China.

And why should the Government take anyone into confidence BEFORE doing anything? In a war?

What does the Opposition want? For the PM to live tweet war plans?
#GalwanValley

In all this time, Chinese media has blacked out the incident, no official confirmed the body count. Xi of course won't speak.

Whereas India has given regular updates on casualties of both sides, and details of the skirmish.

But our media wants to know why Modi is silent!

All nice to say "People don't want war"
But they hide one truth.

"Dushtane Kandaal Dure Vilagu" (Run Away From Evil) as we are taught sounds nice to hear.

But are we ever taught how to defend when it's the Dushta who provokes and chases with intent to destroy you? #ChinaGetOut

There's a border skirmish. You ask to meet the CO of the other side to talk it out. There isn't much of an agreement, which is fine in a border dispute.

But wouldn't your blood boil, when they then come back with more men, each armed with THIS? 👇

#ChinaIndiaFaceoff