As noted in another thread, you are equating contraception with sin. You seem to be equating contraception only with sex outside of marriage, and that is often not what contraception is used for.
Secondly, the Church is more than just the Pope...
...it is also the clergy, theologians, and the laity, etc. There is a real question within the Church re the validity of a teaching that is thoroughly rejected by the majority of the people in the Church & the teaching around contraception has been, since almost the beginning.
Thirdly, saying that this is a question about "papal infallibility" is itself a slippery slope indeed. It argues that Church teaching is frozen like amber - that wasn't true when the Church talk that the sun revolved around the earth, and it isn't true now.
We're Catholic. We accept the teaching authority of the hierarchy. And we're human beings who know when to question what that hierarchy does with that teaching authority.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"The organization of societies worldwide is still far from reflecting clearly that women possess same dignity & identical rights as men. We say one thing with words, but our decisions & reality tell another story."
Glad to see but this is true of the Church, too. #FratelliTutti
These two sentences from #FratelliTutti: "War, terrorist attacks, racial or religious persecution, and many other affronts to human dignity are judged differently, depending on how convenient it proves for certain, primarily economic, interests..."
Fr. James Altman (WI pastor), has produced a disturbing video w/RW pol. group, illegitimately smearing all Catholic Dems (2 by name) & even clergy & bishops (@WashArchbishop by name). In doing so he has violated Canon Law & ignored a 1993 Pope JPII directive against such actions.
Fr. James Altman (a pastor) said you cannot be Catholic + a Democrat & that we don't know God, saying at same time (w/smirk) that he doesn't love people in Borneo. Fr. Altman, pls learn the Gospels or perhaps you'd be happier w/ a different job. Bp Callahan @DIOLaCrosse? @USCCB
Won’t share his egregious video but given it's broken thru on social media & RW blogs, we must issue a Public Notice of Canon Law Transgression so all Catholics - including clergy & bishops - learn our pastors should "form consciences, not replace them," as @Pontifex says. @USCCB
The answer to your question, LW, is "because baptism is a sacrament in the Catholic Church and Mass is the way we roll"?
Yes, it's rude for you to skip Mass, even if "Deb" isn't "really religious at all."
We always end up rolling our eyes when people ask Catholicy questions at Dear Prudence.
The eye-rolling comes from the fact that so many of the people who write in with Catholic questions seem to often boil down to something that they could solve with 5 minutes of Googling.
Invocation by Dr. Polly Baca, the first Hispanic woman elected to the Colorado State Senate and in the House and Senate of a state Legislature. #CatholicsforBiden#BidenHarris