A very difficult question, everyone reluctant to guess. As evidence accumulates, I decided to venture a guess, hoping to start some discussion. Pls comment w/ flaws in my arguments, other arguments, give your guess.
a) Fomites (touching objects, then touching eyes, nose, mouth): increasing consensus that they are minor. WHO: “no specific evidence. CDC: “it may be possible - not thought to be the main way”.
- thelancet.com/journals/lanin…
- Good news piece on topic with interviews: cbc.ca/news/health/co…
People should still wash hands etc. But appears unlikely to be MAJOR contributor to spread. If anyone disagrees, pls reply and explain why
2 pieces of evidence suggest relative importance:
- Pandemic driven by superspreading events (eg nytimes.com/2020/06/30/sci…). Easy to explain w/ aerosols. Harder w/ drops. Transmission requires “prolongued close contact” (PCC).
- Note that when face-to-face, majority of infection likely through aerosols, much more concentrated right in front of person: sciencedirect.com/science/articl…
@linseymarr @ShellyMBoulder @CathNoakes @Don_Milton @SaskiaPopescu @angie_rasmussen @eliowa @GidMK
- As @linseymarr said, nobody knows the real fractions. This was clearly labeled as a guess. Obviously couldn't get a paper published asserting this.
- I did estimate as a thought experiment, to motivate discussion, especially with ppl skeptic that aerosols matter
- After much discussion, not major arguments or flaws that I have seen
- If members of media are listening, please don't report on the estimate. Not a scientific result, just a guess. But hopefully the discussion is useful to see how scientists debate disagreements.