My answer: that's the wrong question. The question is, can we find the will to do it?
The problem is that our political and social systems aren't choosing to do it.
aei.org/research-produ…
My favorite (I'm biased) is the tool that I worked with @RebeccaKatz5 @BethCameron_DC @EllieGraeden to develop: covidlocal.org/metrics/
But it hasn't happened in the past 5 months and isn't on track to happen in the next 5.
This is not a failure of science or medicine, it's a failure of political will and consequent failure of public buy-in.
On that front, I'm discouraged. This point that @cmyeaton made in her recent testimony is spot-on.
- True federal ownership of the crisis and a fully engaged federal response
- Consistency and rigor at state and local levels
- Public buy-in driven by clear and consistent communication & dialog
Trump's inclination is still to claim great success, downplay the crisis, push hard decisions onto the states, and curtail federal involvement.
He'll attack anyone who acknowledges a different reality. thedailybeast.com/trump-attacks-…
Which gets to the next set of problems.
Each state gets to make its own choice about whether to pee in the pool, but all the states suffer if even a few states choose to do that.
So when a few states reopen recklessly, all states suffer.
In effect, Florida et al's reopening policies undermined others states' tracing efforts (which hinge on rapid results). nytimes.com/2020/07/16/opi…
But will these governors learn from their overly-aggressive reopening decisions? Judging by their approach to the next big test - schools - I'm not optimistic. politico.com/states/florida…
texastribune.org/2020/08/07/tex…
npr.org/sections/coron…
People can choose to do these things, regardless of the president or their governor.
And many other are mirroring the President's cavalier disregard for the virus.
We need unity of effort; politicization of health measures is a massive liability. It will be hard to unwind the COVID culture wars as long as the President keeps fueling them.
I would love to see Trump decide to go all-in on testing and PPE the way he's gone all-in on vaccines.
I would love to see GOP and DEM governors coalesce around a common approach.
I would love to see people decide that masks don't undermine freedom.
They all could! It's within our grasp! But the political and public will just...is...not...there.
Perhaps school closure sinking in would refocus public buy-in toward control measures (still perhaps possible).
I wish I had something more uplifting to say...
Like I wrote 4 months ago, the politically-driven inability to admit errors, rectify, and change course means repeating the same mistakes.
I have no more energy for producing warmed-over versions of a strategy our leaders have no will to implement. The political failure is the problem.