A student at College of Mount Saint Vincent in The Bronx was suspended for an Instagram post questioning George Floyd protests. Now it is a Federal case and Inner City Press has been covering it since 2:30 pm, will not live tweet the end then public story - thread
After three hours of argument, the judge is asking why the plaintiff -- "Annie Doe" -- has not moved out of her dorm room. The College gave her a referral to a homeless shelter.
Here's the beginning of the story Inner City Press started drafting: "Annie Doe - not her real name - while a student at the College of Mount Saint Vincent in Riverdale in the North Bronx posted on Instagram criticism of protests to the murder of George Floyd...
The CMSV student wrote, "Just because one black guy dies doesn't mean the entire world should act like untamed apes." [From court filing] She was charged with harassment, and issued a two year suspension. She sued - and "has not left the premises."
Doe's lawyer conceded it is not a 1st Amendment case, since CMSV is a private school. But he attacked the disciplinary process Annie Doe was put through. He noted Doe's support of Trump, and the negative reactions these drew from other CMSV students.
Annie Doe sued for sex discrimination, retaliation and most intriguingly, breach of contract. Inner City Press story soon.
The College of Mount Saint Vincent lawyer said "the optics are bad," parents who pay tuition are asking why Annie Doe is still on campus. Her "electronic card access to the front door has been canceled" - but she has not left.
Jury entering!
Judge: You have asked what is a reasonable person... It is a concept...
[He cites Hwascar Hernandez, the decedent] If you have further questions, please put them in writing.
[Jury exits]
Thread will continue as developments, below
US v Kay Flock update:
The jury sent the judge another note.
Judge: They want a transcript of my definition of "reasonable person." I'll see it to them. See you for the next note.
Thread will continue as developments, below
OK - now jury deliberates in US v Perez / Kay Flock, in courtroom gallery 30-some supporters, 8 law enforcement, & Inner City Press, covering the case and will tweet below any jury notes, and verdict, intermitent thread below matthewrussellleeicp.substack.com/p/extra-in-bro…
Update 1: at 11:56 am, the first jury note is read out by the Judge: The foreperson will be Juror 1.
That's all.
Judge: See you for the next note.
Unclear when.
Thread will continue for developments
Update 2: as of 2:05 pm, only law enforcement in the courtroom, people in the hall. The word is "nothing," as in, nothing coming out from the jury room.
Again, this thread will continue for developments
OK here's from prosecutors' closing argument:
AUSA: As Vance Brockington told you, Sev Side is a gang... The fact that the defendant is an artist does not absolve him - the defendant can't hide behind his music.
[Multiple songs played]
AUSA holds up guns, shows them to jury; white plastic on one signifies it is not operative
AUSA: This gun killed Hwascar Hernandez... Xavier Rosado, a rival gang member, gives you context -
as does Vance Brockington. He was shot in front of 4646 Park Avenue
OK - now in US v. Perez / Kay Flock trial Day 5, witness is an agent, crossed about video of sidewalk outside park and barbershop. Inner City Press is covering the case and
will live tweet, thread belowpatreon.com/posts/extra-co…
Defense: Mr. Hernandez,was he a member of a gang?
AUSA: Objection!
Judge: Sustained.
Defense: Do you have a view of why Mr Hernandez came out of the barbershop?
AUSA: Objection, lack of foundation.
Judge: Sustained
[Video show, outside barbershop]
Figure in slippers and white socks- Hwascar Hernandez gets shot.
Defense: Did he do something before?
Witness: He appeared to touch his zipper.
OK - now rare Saturday hearing in J.G.G. v. TRUMP in which DDC Chief Judge Boasberg has already issued a temporary restraining order against deporting Tren de Aragua members to Venezuela under the Alien Enemies Act. Inner City Press will live tweet, thread below
Chief Judge Boasberg: This morning when I issued by ruling I was not aware of the President's Proclamation. I understood that planes were to be departing -
AUSA: The five named plaintiffs will not be removed.
CJ Boasberg: Are they on planes to El Salvador?
No, is the answer.
Chief Judge Boasberg: Since you have appealed my ruling, I do not have jurisdiction to re-argue it here. So we will discuss class certification. Government?
AUSA: We opposed class certification, on grounds of venue and authority