Sunder Katwala Profile picture
Sep 18, 2020 25 tweets 9 min read Read on X
Weekly Covid attitudes memo, no 24!

Significant short-term attitude shifts
- Lowest govt approval to date
- Big rise in pessimism over last 4 weeks.
- Broad 2/3 permission for national lockdown if needed.

+ vg new comparative study from @MiC_Global

britishfuture.org/wp-content/upl…
70% think Covid is getting worse, up from 54% last week. Hopes that the situation was improving have collapsed over last 4 weeks - from 48% to 14% since late Aug. (YouGov) Image
Govt approval on Covid -33 this week, from -18 last week. This is the lowest since the start @YouGov

Most Conservative voters still approve: 58% to 39% (+19)

Over 65s: 42% approve vs 55% disapproval (-13)
Under 24s: 18% vs 72% disapproval (-56) Image
Caution about Covid and rising pessimism about how its being handled generates broad public permission for a national lockdown if required (66%), though a much larger group (27%) are opposed than in the Spring. Image
So 2020 is now going to get worse before it gets better.

9% say its been a good year so far
A stoic 41% say it has been OK Image
On the bright side, Brexit is back!
- Brexit at its highest salience since Covid began: 51% pick as a top 3 issue with YouGov
yougov.co.uk/topics/politic… Image
A plurality opposed the government’s position on breaching international law: polls varied between 25-49 (-24) and 33-46 (-13) with a large number of Don’t Knows.

This was @OpiniumResearch Image
Here 25-47 (YouGov for Best for Britain)
- Many more women (1/3) than men (1/5) in Don’t Know.
- ABC1 opposition to government was 22-53 (-31)
- C2DE opposition 28-38 (-10): narrower but against too. Image
That the 'OK to breach international law' polls are so very similar to the 'no deal is a good idea' polls (a stable 1/4 in support all along) offers some clear indicators as to what drives attitudes here.

Interlude: a thread of personal thoughts/tips on some of the dilemmas this presents to "activist lawyers" and their allies.
Attitudes on Covid have been changing pretty incrementally. This week saw some of the biggest week-on-week shifts for a few months.

Whether a temporary coincidence of bad news stories, or sustained slump in govt approval, or shifts again with new cases/restrictions, is tbc.
Is this 'the new normal'? A major new 7 country study from @MiC_Global steps back to look at the bigger picture. (This is data from June 19th-28th in UK, June/July overall)
7 country overview here.

America is different: most sense of division, lowest trust in government, keenest to see efforts to address division

Britain is an outlier, in many ways, sometimes suprisingly

moreincommon.com/media/03rgk0wg…
UK slides here: lots of fascinating details

moreincommon.com/media/ucvfntgq…
The British public's verdict on the UK government's handling of Covid is "incompetent, but pretty fair"

This Competence v Fairness distinction is not found in the other countries' responses. Image
Here is some bad news for @toadmeister and the Lockdown Sceptics; they seem especially un-influential in Britain, where people (8/10) are most likely to think the restrictions have been completely reasonable and proportional Image
UK ranks highest on people accepting it is our duty to follow rules (90%), but do we trust others to play their part? A big 31% gap in trust in other people. (This trust gap is incredibly wide in France – 50% - and v.narrow in Germany – 5%). [Are the media one driver here?] Image
Some interesting news for @togethercoalit in this comparative study. UK top for solidarity during Covid.

Over 60% of people feel the crisis has shown that most people care about each other – and have felt the support and care of others themselves. But 4/10 have felt alone. Image
* 54% in Britain feel worried that Covid will have a worse impact on people who belong to racial, ethnic or
religious minorities in the UK.
* Fewer people in Britain than any other country (of the 6) say they would refuse a safe and effective vaccine.
{Several studies find this}
Another nuance/paradox. UK public have highest appetite to seize the opportunity of Covid to make important changes (64%), rather than trying to return to normal - but most people doubt that will happen (55%). Image
So lots of interesting big picture findings in that study from More in Common. While the latest polling has some quite dramatic short-term fluctuations, that could have fairly big political implications if they stick, with next 6-8 weeks on Covid and Brexit very much in flux.
The 'fairness' point is quite striking
- furloughing a big part of that
- Maybe lockdown restrictions (fair sacrifices by all) saw more cohesion than complex/subjective arguments on social distancing and right pace of relaxing rules? (At least the first time around anyway)
Government in a good place at 40% approval, but may be quite jittery if 30% and below becomes a norm. (There may still be a crisis boost *within* the 30%)

Govt will know it needs to deliver or Starmer's approach (support aims + challenge on competence) may have broader appeal Image
The More in Common study is the latest of several to show UK attitudes to migration as relatively pro-migration in comparative context. The context of a pandemic has generated more short-term scepticism in Europe than in the UK Image
This is overall 'govt approval': its v similar to Covid approval during a pandemic.

Could this present a pragmatic political case for making a Brexit deal? Unless govt with 30% approval + 30% Covid approval wants to risk a Brexit policy [no deal] which 25% of people approve of. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sunder Katwala

Sunder Katwala Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @sundersays

Apr 17
There is a persistent pattern of CCHQ/government investigations burying very serious issues (including credible allegations of criminality) until they act rapidly, after exposure in the media, months after knowing the content
Sexual assault of a minor. CCHQ received this allegation before Dec 2019 election but did not investigate. Victim went to police instead after the election. MP Khan (Wakefield) suspended by party 15 months later, when charged & expelled him in 2022 after he was convicted in court Image
Read 9 tweets
Apr 11
Spoke to Guardian about this. My view is politics of dealignment have been v successful for Labour - advancing most where weaker - & & time for a change will hold most core votes too. Bigger challenge to come in trying to retain that coalition in power theguardian.com/politics/2024/…
Excellent visualisation by @Dylan_Difford of Labour's advances 2019-24 Image
In 2024 this is an "every silver lining has a cloud" thought. No risk to 99%+ of Lab-held seats, though Greens hope to challenge in Bristol. A 10%+ swing would sweep all target seats

Maybe turnout worries with young voters if many people thought result was foregone conclusion.
Read 16 tweets
Apr 7
Sunday Telegraph news report on a poll of British Muslim attitudes, with comments from Fiyaz Mughal responding to it. This survey found that 4/10 Muslim respondents say Hamas did not commit atrocities on October 7th. Thread on these findings follows.
telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/04/0…
The poll results are published here by JL Partners. It was conducted for the Henry Jackson Society. (HJS don't seem to have published a report; there is nothing I could find on their website or socials beyond media reports/press releaase)
jlpartners.com/polling-results
Press release note = what is avaiable on the methodology. It is tricky to sample Muslims & other minority groups. JL Partners have used Number Cruncher/Matt Singh who are good at this. Eg, 14th Feb - 12th March period is one way to avoid over-sampling the highly engaged. Image
Read 49 tweets
Mar 23
Interesting report on the nuances of public views of equality and diversity. While there is general support in principle, this research suggest a number of ways that could broaden/sustain support, defuse polarisation & above all put more focus into things that are effective.
6/10 people think equality/diversity a good thing, five times more than bad thing

But almost a quarter of people (3/10 men and 1/6 women) worry could be bad for "people like me". Majorities of black & Asian respondents (3-1) think its good for them. White split is 39-24 Image
Does it make a difference? A plurality 46% to 28% that it does.

I would tend towards a more "it depends" - or it could lead to fairer outcomes if it was done effectively. Nb there is not a broad/deep conservative opposition against the progressive enthusiasm Image
Read 7 tweets
Mar 21
I think @TiceRichard will surely need to drop Mr Beau Dade as a Reform parliamentary candidate by tonight after Tice's interview yesterday about the Conservatives being too slow in taking 2 days to call Frank Hester racist
"Standing by every word" of advocating the forcible deportation of all legal migrants over the last 25 years (imagining "whole families crying and shrieking" as a necessary step ) is a very obvious open and shut case of extremism and racism for @TiceRichard re @HistoryBro1
Image
Image
One useful simple step could be for @reformparty_uk to make "is the Prime Minister British?" a question that is always asked before candidates go onto the approved list or get selected. Tice did act within minutes of being shown this last year


Image
Image
Image
Image
Read 35 tweets
Mar 17
Martin Sellner of Generation Identity, banned from the UK for being an extremist danger, gets sympathy from Elon Musk for being impeded from making the case for "remigration" (the removal of migrants and ethnic minorities to reverse demographic changes) Image
Who is Martin Sellner & why banned from UK & US?
- promotes Great Replacement & ethnic minority "remigration"
- received $ donation from the Christchurch killer
- daubed swastika on synagogue in 2003 to protest for David Irving's right to deny Holocaust
Elon Musk is replying to a tweet containing "Remigration is inevitable" and seeking cash donations to that cause of promoting the Great Replacement Theory & campaigning for removal of migrants & the children of migrants born as citizens in Europe Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(