Bar and Bench Profile picture
Sep 25, 2020 30 tweets 11 min read Read on X
[Refund of Airline Tickets case]

Justice Ashok Bhushan led bench to resume hearing the plea seeking refund of air tickets for travel that could not happen during lockdown. @DGCAIndia has stated that passengers are entitled to refund

#SupremeCourt
@pravasilegalcel
However, @DGCAIndia has clarified that any refund or credit shells valid for air tickets till March next year is applicable for the passengers & not the travel agents. Further any refund is only for flights originating in India and not for the ones abroad, even if Indian carriers
The intervenors had posed a question that if a person especially elderly does not want to travel even after March 2021, then in that case an option of immediate refund has to be given and no credit shell. Senior Adv Aryama Sundaram too had supported this. Court to hear today
Hearing begins:

SC asks SG Tushar Mehta what clarification is given in the affidavit.

Mehta explains that the query raised earlier was pertaining to travel agents and the credit shell to be given.
Mehta: So far as travel agents are concerned, we cannot regulate them we don't have control over it.

But suggestion is that a passenger can use the credit shell only through the agent.
Justice Reddy: If the voucher (credit shell) is not used till the deadline, will the money go to the account of the agent?

#SupremeCourt @DGCAIndia
Mehta explains: There are travel agents, we don't know them or recognise them since there are no registrations.

If I'm an agent, I buy tickets in blocks and that is the contract between the agent and airline, DGCA has nothing to do with it.
Mehta: Once the ticket is allotted, then the passenger's name is reflected in the passenger manifest. Till such allotment, these remain as "floating tickets".

We cannot control the inter se contractual obligations between agents and passengers.

#SupremeCourt @DGCAIndia
Mehta: We can recognise two agencies because they are recognisable - passengers and airlines.

We have done our best to ensure that the passenger either gets the money back or gets the voucher which is transferable.
Mehta: For airlines, directing them refund would have devastating effect

Justice Shah: The voucher is transferable?

Mehta: Yes it is transferable by the passenger.
Justice Reddy: The transfer of voucher has to be done through the same agent?

Mehta: I cannot say that, we are praying that Your Lordships say that.

#SupremeCourt @DGCAIndia
SC: If the passenger surrenders the voucher before the agent and the same is refunded then?

Mehta: We have no problem with that if the passenger gets their money back by surrendering the voucher which is surrendered before the agent.

#SupremeCourt @DGCAIndia
Senior Counsel Pallav Shishodia for the applicant (travel agents): The passengers have paid the money not to the airline, but to agents.

There are many cases where we have paid in advance to the airline to book tickets.
Shishodia: Insolvency of airline cannot be saved at the expense of our insolvency.

SC: Your interest is protected because if the voucher is not used then the money will be deposited in your account.

Shishodia: But for that we will have to wait till March 2021
Justice Shah: When SG is saying that passengers may surender voucher before agents tochet refund and agents can use that voucher, then what is the problem?

Shishodia highlights that the modalities for that are not in place.

SC: We will consider that.
Senior Counsel Mukul Rohatgi for @IndiGo6E: If my credit shell remains till March 2021, I have no difficulty. We can work with this

Justice Shah: Your only concern is you don't have to part with money.
Senior Advocate Pinaki Misra for @airasia and @airvistara: There is an impression being given that the money retained by the Airlines is parked by me in some Bank, that is not true.

It is said that we would have to pay interest on this.

(Misra explains the expenses incurred)
Misra: The rate of interest for FD is much else and we would be asked to pay 9% which is penal interest.

SC: It is not penal interest.

Misra: It becomes a penalty when the rate is so high.

(SC says it will consider it)
Advocate Harshavardhan Bhende for petitioner: To say that the travel agents are not recognised is a sad thing to say because when the passenger manifest is prepared it is done with communication with the travel agents.

#SupremeCourt
Advocate Puneet Jain for an intervenor raises the grievance about making bookings on an international carrier which starts from outside India.

Mehta explains that if the booking is made from India then they have jurisdiction over it and it will be taken care of
Sr. Adv Sanjay Hegde explains: Suppose bookings are made on Indian carriers but from a Gulf country, then the CAR says that they exercise some jurisdiction.

SC: Your concern is that if booking is made form Air India office in New York then you are not covered?

Hedge: Yes
Sr. Adv. Arvind Datar for @goairlinesindia highlights the issues affecting Airlines: My working capital has been frozen.

(Datar explains the expenses that Airlines have to incur and juxtaposes the same against cap that is imposed on ticket prices and frozen working capital)
SC: But that is your Airline's problem, how can you hold up passenger's money?

(Datar points out that there are other Airlines too in need of more time to make the refunds)

SC: If you need more time then you need to approach the government
(Datar has been logged out if the VC hearing. Senior Counsel Aryama Sundaram makes submissions for petitioners in the meantime)

Sundaram: Mr. Datar's client may have problems but we have the right to get our money back.

#SupremeCourt
(Datar resumes arguments after being reconnected)

Datar: We are not saying we won't refund but March 31 is an unrealistic deadline. We are only seeking some relaxation.

SC: The scope of the writ petition is not to give direction to the govt to give relaxation
Datar: Credit shell and who will it go to, travel agent or passengers, is all now being judicially decided so that is why we are only requesting Court's indulgence.

31st March is unrealistic. We are requesting to make it 1 year more or at least six months more.

#SupremeCourt
SC: What is GoAir's liability?

Datar: ₹300 crore liability. Already refunded ₹40 Crores. From 100% flights I'm at 60% flights in operation as in September.

(Datar requests for credit shell to be transferable)

SC: That is what SG said.

Datar: it's a wonderful suggestion
Advocate Kunal Cheema for intervenors Akhil Bhartiya Grahak Parishad makes brief submissions.

Shishodia: WRT what Mr.Rohatgi said, @IndiGo6E is doing what we had suggested and Mr. Datar had also suggested source to source refund and that will make things easy.

#SupremeCourt
The three judge bench reserves order.

Arguments concluded
Supreme Court reserves order in plea seeking refund of airfare for tickets booked during COVID-19 lockdown [Read full story] #Airfare #Airlines #COVID19 @IndiGo6E @goairlinesindia @DGCAIndia

bit.ly/3kNVAKw

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bar and Bench

Bar and Bench Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @barandbench

May 29
Delhi High Court to hear the defamation suit filed by Asian News International (ANI) against YouTuber Mohak Mangal over a video accusing ANI of extortion and blackmail after copyright strikes. Image
Comedian Kunal Kamra and AltNews co-founder Mohammed Zubair are also added as defendants for sharing the video on their X handles.
ANI is seeking takedown of the video, no further trademark infringement and damages of Rs. 2 crores, 10 lakhs.
Read 84 tweets
May 23
Ceremonial bench proceedings underway to mark the last working day of Justice Abhay S Oka

AG R Venkataramani: All of us got equal treatment in your court. I have cherished the questioning moments. By working so tirelessly you have set bad standards for your law clerks as some even forgot to go home..Image
SG Tushar Mehta: Despite such an irreparable loss you treated duty as a judge first. You could have addressed virtually also. This shows duty. Please spare more time for family. You have often been much more prepared than lawyers. Your lordships services are required and please do not close any door
.
SG: you may not believe in God, but i believe, May God be always on your side. Me and ASG Raju were almost always at the wrong side of the judgment ..but our love and respect for you was never affected. We respect your for who you are.
Read 32 tweets
May 21
Delhi High Court to shortly hear a defamation suit filed by Newslaundry Executive Editor Manisha Pande and eight other women journalists against Abhijit Iyer-Mitra for referring to them as ‘prostitutes’ and their workplace as a ‘brothel.’ Image
Advocate Bani Dixit appears for Newslaundry journalists. She says "Plaintiffs are journalists from all walks of life. These are defamatory articles outside the bounds of criticism. These are all working women."
Court: What does the defendant do ?

Dixit: The kind of things he has said I cannot read it out also.

She reads out the allegedly defamatory portions
Read 14 tweets
May 21
[Arrest of Ashoka University Professor]

Supreme Court to shortly hear a petition challenging the arrest of Ali Khan Mahmudabad, an associate professor at Ashoka University, Sonipat, over certain remarks on Operation Sindoor

#AliKhanMahmudabad
#OperationSindoor
@AshokaUniv
#SupremeCourtofIndiaImage
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal to argue for Mahmudabad

#AliKhanMahmudabad
#OperationSindoor
@AshokaUniv
#SupremeCourtofIndia
@AshokaUniv Sr Adv Sibal: Please see page 46 which has the statement on the basis of which criminal culpability is attributed

#AliKhanMahmudabad
#OperationSindoor
@AshokaUniv
#SupremeCourtofIndia
Read 21 tweets
May 20
[Waqf Hearing in Supreme Court]

Supreme Court bench led by CJI B.R. Gavai would hear the petitions challenging the constitutional validity of the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 on May 20, for the limited purpose of interim relief

#SupremeCourt #WaqfAct Image
The bench will consider whether interim relief of stay is required on three issues - waqf by user, nomination of non-Muslims to the Wakf Council and State Waqf Boards and identification of government land under waqf #WaqfAct
The Central government had earlier told the Supreme Court that certain key provisions of the controversial Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025, including the formation of the Central Waqf Council and Waqf Boards and provisions on de-notifying properties already declared or registered as waqf, will not be acted upon for the time being.
Read 36 tweets
May 16
Supreme Court hears a plea stating Rohingya refugees were thrown into the sea

Justice Surya Kant: Everytime you have a new story. Now how is this beautifully crafted coming from

Sr Adv Colin Gonsalves: this is the 38 persons deported and then they were taken to Andamans and then were put in the sea with life jackets

Justice Kant: who was clicking the videos and photos? How did he come back ? What is the material on record ? We did not see anything at night.Image
Justice Kant: when the country is going through such a tough time you bring up these fanciful petitions.

Gonsalves: Then there was call made from Myanmar

SC: We know how these calls are made of Jharkhand etc and numbers of Myanmar, Dubai etc are shown

Gonsalves: Govt can probe. One of the deported called from Myanmar.
Justice Kant: Where is this corresponding averment in the submission regarding this annexure. Show us that.
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(