Reaction in Brussels to this article 👇 is that either A) Downing Street is sending a message via journalist that it is now willing to make compromises - thereby immediately making a deal more likely (as Eu already said it‘s willing to compromise) OR ../1 thetimes.co.uk/article/a-brex…
B) more downbeat EU assessment is this is a PR exercise by Downing Street. Suggesting compromise (but not coming up with specific political compromise on state aid for example) .. only to use apparent UK flexibility to accuse EU of intransigence if talks ultimately break down /2
Not much trust here in Johnson government. BUT EU leaders still believe PM wants a deal. High level EU insider told me „government „mess“ over exams and covid19 test and trace plus huge strains on UK economy make it more likely the uk government will complete a trade deal“ /3
Everyone here admits a deal is in EU best interest too. But both UK and EU insist they cannot accept a deal „at any price“. So far, so NOT new. Has anything changed then as we head next week into next negotiating round? Yes and no is the (irritating) answer ../4
Sticking points remain the same: state aid (and other level playing field issues), fish and governance. This is why EU diplomats say there’s no point right going into a media blackout negotiating „tunnel“. Only enter those, they say, if the political landing zone is in sight /5
But it’s not yet there on those key sticking points. Both the EU and the UK need to make compromises. On the EU side, some countries suggest the EU could compromise on level playing field demands - thereby protecting UK post #Brexit sovereignty - if and only if - /6
The UK signs up to having a robust arbitration mechanism in the deal. This, so that EU could feel assured that if UK broke competition rules(or vice versa of course), swift action could be taken. Apart from „protecting single market“ EU leaders need to be able to sell an /7
Eventual deal to their business owners and voters back home. NB Big UK trading partners France, Netherlands, Germany already feel the weight of upcoming big elections back home. EU politicians would want the UK to sign up to „principals“ on labour, environment, state aid /8
UK would be free to implement those principles as it saw fit and if EU felt that implementation allowed unfair competition to UK businesses in EU single market, then Brussels could trigger arbitration process. This is a compromise position being floated in some EU circles /9
BUT not all EU countries on board with that compromise (France..) and UK compromise positions not at all clear either. Guesstimate in EU capitals is - if reached- a trade deal (with all the back and forth *needed* between now and then) might be concluded by mid/late November /10
Still time to ratify in European and UK parliament. Aim is to keep deal at a level where it needs approval by all EU leaders but not all national parliaments. Even though what EU and UK still aiming for goes beyond a basic free trade agreement /11
To include fish, police and judicial cooperation, professional qualifications and data flow .. On a technical level there is EU-UK agreement on majority of elements but concensus is: the political decisions that remain will decide if there’s a deal this year or not /12
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Macron speaks of a morning of excellent exchanges here in Paris with Rishi Sunak - the first such high level bilateral summit in 5 years.
The French Presidents speaking of new beginnings between France and the UK. Speaking of the challenges in Europe facing both countries. Looking to find « concrete solutions » together
Macron congratulates Rishi Sunak and the European Commission President for reaching a new Brexit deal on NIreland. On Ukraine, Macron speaks of coordinating and working together with UK to help Ukraine
Joint statement by EU Commission President von der Leyen and PM Sunak👇meeting in person in UK tomorrow. Widely viewed as last step before announcing revised joint deal on contentious post Brexit NIreland Protocol BUT /1 ec.europa.eu/commission/pre…
If we’ve learned ANYTHING after years of painfully difficult negotiations on the Protocol - never count your chickens .. /2
Here in Brussels the sense (for a while now) is that the ball is in UK court. Accepted wisdom is that Sunak’s negotiations within his own party and with the DUP are at least as complex as talks have been with the EU /3
Leopards first. US Abrams tanks come later but signal from US is important. Though Berlin denies was a precondition to it giving the green light to allow its heavy tanks to be delivered to Ki’iv. Germany clearly did not want to be sole main source of battle tanks to Ukraine /1
a) Russia making all sorts of threatening noises. Many Germans fear escalation of conflict potentially beyond Ukraine‘s borders. Keen to feel nuclear power US beside them. /2
b) Scholz faced domestic pressure to deliver tanks but also domestic pressure NOT to. Not everyone in his SPD party is thrilled w idea and German public opinion is split. Though increasingly supportive of Leopard 2 deliveries to Ukraine /3
German Chancellor Scholz has raised eyebrows at home + abroad by deciding to travel to China this Friday -the first visit by a western leader since president Xi further cemented his hold on power. Today Scholz’s foreign minister publicly instructed him../1 spiegel.de/politik/deutsc…
To make Germany’s ‘new China policy’ clear, insisting on fair trade/business conditions, human rights and international norms. Just as Europe is weaning itself off energy dependency on Russia, critics worry Germany is continuing to prioritise lucrative trade with China over /2
Other concerns. Emmanuel Macron was incensed Scholz did not coordinate the China trip with big ally France. Macron has been pushing for years to become less beholden to China. Critics accuse Macron of protectionism but after A) headaches w global supply chains with covid & /3
Norwegian energy giant Equinor has reported a spike in profits thanks to spiralling oil+gas prices, exacerbated by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Norway is now biggest energy exporter to UK + EU after the bloc drastically reduced imports from Russia /1
Norway is making huge profits and as of meeting with European Commission yesterday, is still resistent to idea of accepting a price cap on exports to EU in exchange for contracts bbc.com/news/world-eur… /2
Domestic energy prices are high for consumers in Norway. Local media report on factories stopping production and families putting on their washing-machine at 3am to benefit from lower energy costs that time of day /3
Northern Ireland is on course for fresh elections, possibly set for Dec after no power sharing government was formed following the last poll in May. The Democratic Unionist Party refused to participate in protest, it said, over the Brexit agreement on NIreland (the Protocol) /1
But many in NIreland don’t believe new elections will solve the impasse. There’s fear a cycle of vote-impasse-vote could now follow. Parties have 24 weeks to form a power-sharing gov after an elex. UK+EU negotiations on finding solutions to problems w Protocol have re-started /2
Mood music is improved but big differences remain. DUP have called for fundamental re-write /ditching of Protocol - an international treaty signed by EU leaders and former PM Boris Johnson. The treaty keeps NIreland in some EU trading arrangements to avoid a hard customs border/3