Another Labour rebellion brewing over the covert human intelligence sources (criminal conduct) bill, which has its second reading today. Expecting a response from Labour left MPs like the one we saw at the second reading of the overseas operations bill two weeks ago.
Critics say it places no specific limits on the type of criminal activity allowed, authorisations are given internally & it limits redress for victims. "There is a grave danger that this bill could end up providing informers and agents with a licence to kill," Amnesty has said.
Here's the view of the Labour frontbench – "Such activity – the licence to commit a crime to prevent something far more serious occurring - has been happening for many years, but it has not been properly legislated for. This cannot be right": independent.co.uk/voices/police-…
Nick Thomas-Symonds says Labour will allow the bill to progress to committee stage but will later press the government for "robust safeguards" in the form of "very clear limits and oversight". Also says it should not retrospectively apply to the Northern Ireland Troubles.
Labour MPs are on a one-line whip to abstain, but those planning to rebel are talking about Pat Finucane's killing, spycops relationships, the surveillance of colleagues such as Jeremy Corbyn and interference in legitimate trade union activities. Unite has sent out a briefing.
Another Labour MP intending to defy the whip and vote against the bill today:
Understand there was a briefing call with Nick Thomas-Symonds and dozens of Labour MPs this morning and there was a broad range of opposition – much wider than expected. One source says there's a view that Keir Starmer could bring people with him on this issue, and should do.
Another source says the call peaked at 90 attendees (including staffers), with Stella Creasy, Steve McCabe and Emma Hardy all voicing concern about the Labour whip to abstain.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Call Keir with students and their parents has started. The Labour leader is joined by shadow minister Emma Hardy rather than Kate Green as advertised.
Sophie at Leeds says she is in a flat of six people and they've all tested positive after a week of living together. "It’s quite emotionally distant. I feel like I haven’t been able to make friends as easily as I would have normally"
Dylan, a Labour activist at Plymouth, noted that lectures are being prerecorded, which means you can't ask questions. "I really feel that the support from the university and government hasn’t been there"
On whether Keir Starmer sympathises with students seeking tuition fee or rent refunds, his spokesperson would not be drawn – would only say: "The immediate priority is making sure every students gets a good education safely, either in person or remotely".
Added: "We understand there is deep anxiety for students and their parents across the country... We have a huge amount of sympathy for what students are having to go through, and not to forget their parents as well."
Keir's response to the idea of processing asylum seekers on Ascension Island? "Ludicrous and inhumane. It’s completely impractical and it would be hugely expensive for taxpayers."
Starmer speaks for residents of lockdown areas when he says things feel as if they're getting worse not better despite tougher restrictions in their area – plus quotes Tory council leader saying the rules are "too complex" #PMQs
This causes Boris Johnson to U-turn on accusation that disobedient public is the problem, as he now says people do understand the rules and are following them #PMQs
Starmer now picking up on gaps in economic support, asks of sectors such as hospitality: "Why has the government decided that these jobs aren't worth saving?" PM utterly disengenuous in saying these areas need extra restrictions and ignoring the point about support #PMQs
Anneliese Dodds responding to winter economic plan: "It’s a relief that the government has U-turned now... That delay in introducing this new scheme will have impacted on business confidence."
"Will this scheme of wage support actually keep more people in work?" Dodds asks. "Does his scheme actually incentivise short hours working?"
"Will the scheme incentivise training and retraining?" Labour wants UK version of German scheme in this area too.
Is the first of Keir Starmer's ten pledges – increase income tax for top 5% of earners, reverse Tory cuts to corporation tax – now gone? "I expect so," says Lisa Nandy #PoliticsLive
What about his fifth pledge, on common ownership of rail, mail, energy and water? Lisa Nandy says public ownership is "one way" and "another way" is "giving people more control" #PoliticsLive
She explained that this change was due to the coronavirus crisis, but didn't go on to say that the pledge would be picked up again further down the line.
Starmer talks about being knighted at Buckingham Palace as he promotes "family values" – leaning into 'Sir Keir'
Sounding less conciliatory on government handling of Covid as he says "nothing inevitable about a second lockdown" – and links the pandemic to how "family really does come first"
On Brexit, Starmer says Labour is "not going to bang on about Europe" and "our country needs a deal"