Continuously restating that courts are not political does not magically make them non-political

Laws, and the context of laws, do not speak in "clear language," we hear them through OUR OWN EARS - the voice we hear is filtered through our own judgment (informed by our politics)
In other words, what @BenSasse is saying is absurd to me
The best way to explain this....remember when you were a kid and played the "telephone game?"

If we all read the same text, we will all see what that text means as DIFFERENT....the reasons for those little differences are based in the differences b/w us & who we are
The idea that there is ONE specific meaning that can be discerned and is objectively arrived at IS A POLITICAL ACT...it is saying might = right (my view of law is the objectively correct view)...it is egotism more than reality
It is like the real life Rashoman problem, every narrator thinks their perspective is the "objectively" correct one and that all other interpretations are "activist"

Originalism IS POLITICS

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Joshua B. Hoe

Joshua B. Hoe Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JoshuaBHoe

15 Oct
Picking and choosing who gets to vote is anti-Democratic

Even the statement, "I don't think our Democracy is made better by letting _____ vote" is internally contradictory and self-defeating.

Democracy is not, and should not be, about elites choosing preferred voters Ted Cruz.
Side note: Oddly enough, in the state Mr. Cruz represents, people who did time for murder can vote...and yet, Mr. Cruz was elected. Is Texas' not an acceptable Democratic state?

Political grandstanding by putting real people's vote on the line is UGLY
He was also FLAT wrong...there is actual research that shows that VOTING by incarcerated and formerly incarcerated people actually does make our communities safer and our democracy stronger Image
Read 16 tweets
14 Oct
"I am not sure our democracy is made better by allowing murderers to vote" - Ted Cruz

As usual, Ted Cruz is wrong on policy, and spectacularly wrong about what matters to a functional democracy
He even inferred that the 14th amendment suggested for disenfranchisement, which it does not (it only allows it, if a state decides to do so).

Just a shameful exercise in political theater with real people's votes on the line
1. No taxation without representation (you know the foundation of the Tea Party movement...I believe you have heard of it Mr. Cruz?)

2. Every member of that Tea Party broke the law and could have been excluded from voting under the Cruz reasoning
Read 15 tweets
14 Oct
Exactly...originalism is just political cover giving personal and religious views the appearance of objectivity...it is an attempt to suggest that the judge is like the narrator in a movie...but narrators are always unreliable
Everyone wants to believe that they make decisions objectively. Everyone wants to believe they arrive at conclusions fairly...but we all interpret what we read and arrive at what we write using OUR eyes and everything that makes us who we are...we are, by nature self-interested
If you and I read the same text, we will interpret at least parts of it differently...most likely, that is because how we read things is determined by everything that came together over a lifetime to make us who we are....Reading is ALWAYS a co-productive process
Read 8 tweets
23 Sep
Matt Gaetz should be ashamed of himself

Amendment 4 passed with 65% of the vote.

The Legislature GUTTED it to suppress votes they suspected would be for Democrats (an absurd assumption)

What @MikeBloomberg did is follow the rules, he is paying off criminal justice debt
If your party can only stay in power by suppressing votes.

If your party needs to suppress votes to win.

There is something wrong with your party, not the potential voters
I am formerly incarcerated and I can tell you from experience, the idea that all formerly incarcerated people vote Democrat is LUDICROUS

But, EVERY PERSON should have a say in their government, NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION

That is the core of our system of government
Read 5 tweets
23 Sep
People will be talking about how unfair this "attack" is

People should be talking about how sex offender registries are counterproductive, increase recidivism and sex crimes

Because those are the facts

news.yahoo.com/in-apparent-pl…
Side note, if "sex offenders" are "hiding in the shadows" that is because of registries, not b/c of legislators trying to protect people on the registry.

Here is the evidence
Oddly enough, increasing housing and employment insecurity while making people public pariahs INCREASES recidivism

Sadly, most of the people responding will just say "it's an unfair smear" which is sad, because all legislators should oppose registries on public safety grounds
Read 5 tweets
22 Sep
What if traditional arrest, imprisonment, punishment, and shaming actually does NOTHING to reduce crime?

What if crime is actually also about environment, and as a result of brutal conditions you make the huge percentage of people incarcerated WORSE instead of better?
What if making it impossible for people returning from prison to get jobs or housing and loading them down with massive criminal justice debt makes them MORE not LESS likely to recidivate or commit new crimes?
What if manufacturing massive housing and job insecurity, stress, and debt after disconnecting people from family and friends is counterproductive?

What if addressing long ignored trauma, providing meaningful services, and giving people HOPE for a real future works better?
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!