Much important and necessary analysis of the Pope's surprising comments yesterday: the origin, timing and context of clips from "Francesco." (And Francis had said similar things before.) But good to remember: 1) The Pope is clearly telling families not to reject #LGBT members...
2) Francis is expressing his support for (depending on the translation) some sort of legal protections for same-sex couples in civil law. 3.) Almost totally overlooked, the documentary "Francesco" looks at his warm relationships with LGBT individuals, like @jccruzchellew.
This may be the first time that many people are hearing about this pastoral outreach. It has been expressed by the Pope before in other ways (interviews, homilies, books, press conferences, etc.), but not broadcast or known as widely as yesterday's comments. So that's new.
We can see the Pope's comments as yet another positive step in the church's relationship with LGBT people and a sign of his continuing pastoral care for LGBT Catholics.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Attempts to deny that @Pontifex said what he said (or that it was edited to make him say something different) are amazing. Because he's said all these things before, though either privately or not as widely known. Let's look at what he said about #LGBT people in the new film....
1. "Homosexuals have a right to be a part of the family."
During an in-flight press conference on the way back from Dublin, in 2018, the Pope said:
"Because that son and daughter has a right to family, and their family is this family, just as it is."
I hope not! Bill Bryson can really *write.* For the uninitiated, try "A Walk in the Woods," "Notes from a Small Island" and, my favorite, "In a Sunburned Country."
Also, "The Lost Continent" includes one my all-time favorite passages of writing....
Bryson, touring the US in the 1980s, is talking about Cleveland's "Renaissance," which did not overly impress (The city has obviously improved since then, so don't be upset if you're from Cleveland, just enjoy the prose).
He writes:
"What I can say is that the view up the Cuyahoga as I crossed it on the freeway was a stew of smoking factories that didn't look any too clean or handsome. And I can't say that the rest of the town looked such a knockout either. It may be improved, but all this talk...
Gospel: One of the best books on Jesus for contemporary Christians is Amy-Jill Levine's "The Misunderstood Jew," which looks at the lazy stereotypes about first-century Judaism that have been passed along by well-meaning Christians. E.g., the Pharisees were all hypocrites...
In her book, Prof. Levine points out that what little most Christians know about 1C Judaism comes from the Gospels, which were concerned painting Jesus in a favorable light, not his opponents. So we end up with a skewed (and limited) view of Jewish practice at the time....
As she writes: “In New Testament classes, many students get a single lecture, or half a lecture, on the four major parties of Jews mentioned by the Jewish historian Josephus: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes and Zealots"....
My friends at @americamag are wearing purple on #SpiritDay to show their support for LGBTQ youth who are often the target of bullying. Bullying and harassment can lead to despair. And LGBTQ youth are several times more likely to attempt suicide. Stand with them and for them!
To those who have asked me, sincerely, how President Trump's "Do not be afraid of Covid" differs from Jesus's "Be not afraid," some thoughts:
First, Jesus often told his followers "Be not afraid." In fact, that phrase brackets his earthly life. I.e., the Angel Gabriel...
....says that to the Virgin Mary at the Annunciation. And after his Resurrection, the Risen Christ says it to his disciples. It's one of the few phrases Jesus utters several times in the Gospels. He is encouraging his followers to turn away from fear and rely on him. But...
....Jesus is not telling us to ignore the reality of human life. That is, God does not ask us to check our brains at the door and be stupid about our bodies. We don't jump off of tall buildings expecting not to get hurt. We don't drink poison expecting not to get sick....
Gospel: Today's reading, in which Jesus tells busy Martha that her sister, who sits by Jesus's feet, has chosen the "better part," is often unfairly used to denigrate active people (Lk 10). But, as I see it, Jesus isn't favoring action over contemplation. Rather, he's telling...
...Martha, who is "anxious and worried about so many things," that there is a time and place for everything. Jesus is visiting the two sisters, so it's time to be with him. It's fine to be active--after all, someone had to cook that meal--but there is a time for contemplation.
Image: "Christ in the House of Martha and Mary," by Vermeer.