Thread:

*The Donny van de Beek Non-Issue*

Over the last few weeks, the constant chatter has been VDB's playing time.

United have played 8 games so far and Donny has featured in 7. Only Rashford has featured in more.

Either way let's dive in & tackle this non-issue👇
One of United's biggest issue last season was the lack of creativity on the bench. Ole was criticized for not making substitutions when the game wasn't going our way.

Against Seville in the EL Semi's we didn't make a sub until the 87th min - clear sign Ole didn't trust his bench
This season, the first thing he addressed was this issue

- Donny van de Beek for £35m

Donny has primarily played as an AM at Ajax but has also featured at CM and very rarely at DM too.

But Ole didn't sign him to be a CM/DM, Ole signed him to be a back up 10 as is clear below👇
Donny in his 1st interview abt what Ole told him:

"He said he knew exactly what my biggest strengths are & told me that he wants me to be in & around the 16 yard box at Man United too."

'Being in and around the 16 yard box' - Donny signed bcs he wanted to play up the field
Now you may ask "Sure but he wasn't signed as backup"

Ole: "His ability to see space, time his movements & read the game will really complement the qualities that we've in midfield. His arrival really strengthens the depth of talent we have in that position"

Keyword: 'depth'
Now you're thinking "but VDB won't be ok with this!"

VDB: “I'll start at zero again at ManUtd. That might seem sad, but I love it. If you start down the ladder you can begin to climb up again. It’s now up to me to see how high I can reach. I see this as a challenge.”

Mentality!
Of course as we know even hearing it from VDB & Ole themselves is seldom enough for our fanbase

So I present to you some 'stats' bcs a lot of you seem to trust that more than what the actual players says

Let's take a look at some stats that shows the step up he has to make now:
Donny has had 3 top flight seasons where he has played more than 2000 mins

- 17/18
- 18/19
- 19/20

Ajax primarily play in 3 major competitions
- Eredivisie, the Dutch premier league
- Champions league/Europa league
- KNVB Cup, the domestic cup

Now lets see how much they play:
In the prev 3 seasons:

Ajax in total played
- 138 games
- these 3 seasons combined ran for 826 days

United in that time played
- 171 games in 835 days

In other words,

United played 33 more games than Ajax in just 9 extra days (reminder: a full season is 38 games)
This is a fundamental reason why someone who was a regular starter in a smaller league might not be able to instantly be a regular starter in the PL

Now add
- better opposition
- faster pace
- more physicality
- more pressure

and you see why young players might need easing in
Even then just how much time can VDB expect to get.

For that let's look at Utd AM's last season:

Jesse as AM
21 Apps | 17 starts | 1307 mins

Mata as AM
18 Apps | 14 Starts | 1179 mins

Periera as AM
14 Apps | 10 starts | 877 mins

Bruno as AM
21 Apps | 20 starts | 804 mins
Now,

- Bruno came in at Jan & hasn't rested since bc he's had no backup

- this is a shortened season meaning more games in less amount of time meaning there will be need for more rotations

- Andreas has been loaned out, Lingard hasn't played much & Mata is now playing RW more
All this means only one thing:

Bruno will need a lot of rest to get through this season and when he does, the primary backup will be VDB

United played 61 games last season, more than any in the last 3 seasons bc we got to 3 semifinals (1st time we have done that since SAF)
This means we are looking at a 55-60 game season min depending on how far we go in cups

That is 55-60 starts for an AM

Even if Bruno starts 40 of them (which is a lot considering the shortened season) we are still looking at at least 30-35 appearances for VDB (he already has 7)
This'll be the perfect introduction for VDB to the English game:

30-35 apps in his first season in a new league means he gets to ease himself in while also getting a LOT of minutes without too much pressure while also giving our primary no 10 enough and more rest - planning.
Remember Donny has already played 233 mins this season while Bruno has played just 505.

He's already playing almost half as much as Bruno, that number will only go up as the season progresses as Bruno rests & Donny starts more.

It isn't the end of the world as some suggest.
To recap

- VDB was signed as a backup 10
- VDB is thrilled & sees it as a challenge
- VDB is coming into a bigger more intense league
- VDB isn't used to the demands of the English game
- VDB will need easing in to get him up to pace &
- VDB will get a lot of games by season end
Journos will always find something to write about Utd.

If things are going badly the usual suspects are
- Ole, tactics, dressing room harmony

If things are going well then
-Pogba, Martial, and now Mason & VDB

Before overreacting, look at the bigger picture & keep a cool head.
VDB is a 23 year old fantastic talent who could very well be here for the next 10 years & we're 8 games into a 60 game season

Let's let's cut out the unnecessary negativity and let's trust the manager who's shown just how good he is at handling youngsters to handle VDB well too.
This is a slight correction

Bruno as AM
21 Apps | 20 starts | 1733* mins

I had gotten the calculation for the minutes wrong.

It doesn't affect the rest of the thread or the point I am trying to make.

Just shows I need to triple check my data before posting. 🤭

Apologies.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ManUtdSense

ManUtdSense Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SensibleUtd

24 Oct
So wait, it's ok to play VDB out of position just to start him but when Pogba has to drop a little deep Ole is a clown playing him out of position?

So you do know players need to play in their best position but only as long as you can use it to criticize the manager?

Got it.
Even funnier now that Pogba is getting to play further up no one is complaining. But why is he getting to play further up? Bcs he's used as an impact sub against tired legs meaning he has less defensive workload

Almost as if the manager knows how when & where to play his players
None of this 'VDB has to start' agenda is coming from a place where they think it's a valid criticism. These fans clearly know without dropping Bruno VDB has to play out of position to start - they're not dumb. But if it means they get to bash on the manager they'll act dumb.
Read 4 tweets
29 Sep
Thread:

Ole's been our manager for 1.5 seasons and 3 windows now. Ideally he should now be getting his 8-10th signing and the rebuild should be on its last stretch.

But the mess he took over was so huge that 3 windows in, he still has 7-8 unwanted players left to clear out.
Fans need to realise the sheer magnitude of the rebuild he took over. The solution was never going to be just buying players who he wants and likes.

Before he gets to do that, first he has to clear out the ones not needed and we had quite a few of them.
The wages of those players along with their absymal form means finding a buyer for most of them is difficult.

But even with those constraints, Ole is doing the best he can - loan them out with the hopes of getting a buyer later.
Read 16 tweets
21 Sep
Catching the game only now:

7 mins in & we've gifted a goal

Frame 1:
- narrow + tight back 4
- Fosu pulled in by Ayew
- Space opens - Shlupp runs

Frame 2:
- Lindelof tries to delay cross
- Maguire + Shaw too slow to react/get back

But I'm guesssing Lindelof got all the blame? ImageImage
Utd want to play short simple passes so we stay narrow - but should be wider in defense?

Seeing Rashford tucking in might have promted Shaw to stay narrow

Fosu getting dragged in didn't help, neither did Maguire & Shaw taking too long to realise the severity of the threat
This was a sloppy goal from a team that's obviously not there physically or mentally. Although it's been just 7 mins so far, it feels like a friendly.

The lack of signings + recent controversies have lead to a drop in morale maybe?

A lazy goal conceded by a lazy team.
Read 4 tweets
5 Sep
LFC's attacking FB's convinced everyone there's no other way to play. They do that bcs their mid isn't creative. City has a creative mid so the FB's tuck in & recycle.

Utd hve inside fwd on wings
They cut in - FB's overlap
They stay wide - FB's tuck in

Need all round FBs (Shaw)
To add on:

United have great creativity in mid & superb attackers up front. There is a reason why we play fewer lobbed crosses than anyone else. Our game plan isn't to stretch play wide & cross from the byline. Ours is to compress space & progress vertically with quick one twos.
This is why Shaw was instrumental to us down the left. He has the intelligence to know when to overlap and when to tuck in. Even when he did overlap it was still almost always inside the box to offer a quick give and go for Rashy.
Read 5 tweets
5 Sep
#MUFC

Pic 1: Last season's most used XI
Pic 2: Last season's best XI
Pic 3: Next season's possible 2nd XI

Our 2nd XI next season (w/o DDG, Rash, PP, Bruno, Linda, AWB, Matic) looks as good/better than our most used XI from last season.

Promoting Youth + Shrewd Buys = Progress ImageImageImage
This is one reason why I urge fans to trust the process. A rebuild is a series of mostly incremental changes with sporadic massive changes.

The team we started last season with & the one we ended with are totally different although we bought just 1 new first team player.
That's due to Ole's focus on promoting youth and also making the players in the squad better.

Bruno was a massive change and Sancho will be another one.

The rest of the squad will incrementally improve thru the season and by the end of next season we'll have a much improved XI
Read 6 tweets
11 Aug
THREAD

Harry Maguire's Impact at ManUtd

Harry has certainly improved us but by how much?

To find out, I compared Harry's stats this season to the combined stats of Lindelof & Smalling from last season

He's better than the 2 of them combined on many key metrics

Let's dive in:
To begin with,

Harry stats this season are way better than Smalling's from last season. So comparing that wont give a clear idea of his contribution.

But comparing his stats to that of Lindelof and Smalling combined shows just how much he has singlehandedly improved us.
Harry Maguire has been a rock:

Harry Maguire this season
- 138 tackles + interceptions | 279 clearances

Lindelof + Smalling combined last season
- 156 tackles + interceptions | 253 clearances

Harry alone has more clearances & 88% as many tck+int as other 2 combined

RIDICULOUS
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!