A comprehensive new @HouseJudiciary report on family separation puts to bed any suggestion that the Trump administration intended to reunite families.

One damning new revelation? Former CBP head Kevin McAleenan tried to keep separations going after a court ordered them to stop. While HHS and ICE attempted to comply with the executive ord
The @HouseJudiciary report also sheds more light on the fact that family separation was the goal of the Trump administration from Day One.

High-level administration officials met to begin planning separations within a month of Trump taking office, and floated plans to CNN. In mid-February 2017, just weeks after the presidential inau
Within six months of taking office, the Trump administration had begun a family separation "pilot project" in El Paso.

Despite separating 281 families during a four-month period, the Trump administration never disclosed the project to the agency in charge of childrens' shelters. In July 2017, CBP began an “initiative” (hereinafter the
As the hundreds of families were being separated, one high-level official in the Office of Refugee Resettlement wrote to his boss in alarm.

"We had a shortage last night of beds for babies." Despite the impact on the agency, ORR was not informed of th
By the time the Trump administration rolled out Zero Tolerance, more than 1,000 children had already been separated from their families.

Fifty children under the age of 5 were separated in that period, including four under the age of 1.

The administration moved forward anyway. DHS internal documents confirm the high number of family sep
When Jeff Sessions announced Zero Tolerance, DHS ordered CBP to refer parents for prosecution—which meant children would be taken away.

The policy was rolled out chaotically, with individual Border Patrol sectors setting their own policies about separating small children. Chart showing that different sectors had different policies
While Zero Tolerance was going on, Border Patrol officers often treated children and families with contempt, as documented by extensive complaints.

Reports revealed children taken away without a chance to say goodbye and an 8-year-old kicked to wake him up. Due to such inconsistent guidance, the separation process wa
When children were taken away from their parents so cruelly, they broke down pyschologically and physically.

Shelter operators reported horror stories, including children who'd wake up screaming in the middle of the night and others who "could barely eat or sleep for weeks." NBC News recounted the experience of a Michigan foster mothe
As the outrage against family separation mounted, Trump administration officials struggled to even set up communication between parents and children.

By this point, the El Paso Pilot Project had begun nearly a year earlier, and yet there was still no system in place to reunify. As scrutiny mounted from all corners,senior government offic
The chaos ran through the system. When one South Texas judge ordered CBP to maintain lists of separated parents, they couldn't even do that. So the judge threatened to hold them in contempt.

Agents panicked: "A Border Patrol agent exclaimed, I ain’t going to jail!!!!!!!!!!!!!'" Similarly, CBP agents struggled to comply with an order from
When the Trump administration finally ended Zero Tolerance, ICE began the process of trying to reunify parents still in ICE custody with their children. But again they ran into the same problems they'd had for almost a year—there were no systems linking parents with kids. The plan for reunification required ICE and ORR—the two ag
It was clear no plan existed to reunify families, even days before a court order.

"On June 23, 2018, ORR Director Lloyd emailed ICE ERO, stating, "'[j]ust writing to find out if you have any intel on ICE plans for the separated parents. Give me a call when you get a chance.'" The District Court’s preliminary injunction meant that ICE
Because there had never been any real plan to reunite parents with their children, after a court ordered the Trump administration to do so, the situation quickly "devolved into chaos."

Kids were stuck on buses overnight, sent to the wrong place, and ICE missed deadlines. Reunification Efforts Devolve into Chaos: Despite their ongo
By August, most families had been reunited. But as @HouseJudiciary's report makes clear, hundreds of children remain separated from their parents, because the parents were deported without their children as a result of a cruel and chaotic policy.

It must never happen again. Over the next few months, ORR and DHS continued its attempts
Much of the information included in this report has been revealed before, though there are some new bits of information, like McAleenan's brief attempt to restart Zero Tolerance prosecutions after a court order halting separations.

You can read it here: judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/…
If you've gone through this thread and want to read even more about the horrors of family separation and how the policy was rolled out, I also suggest reading @jacobsoboroff's excellent new book, "Separated," which covers much of this topic in extensive detail.
The @HouseJudiciary report is excellent, but there's so much more that could have been covered, because there was just so much cruelty.

For instance, we @immcouncil documented extensive coercion in the reunification process. americanimmigrationcouncil.org/advocacy/illeg…
Because the report is an overview, it doesn't get into all of the horrific stories it could. But there were just so many.

I remember shaking with anger and sadness when summarizing this story for our complaint. It was our government that did this to this woman. A horrific story of separation from a woman who legally pres
A gruesome thought to end this thread. The woman whose story I highlighted above was sent to the Irwin detention center; the same place where at least 57 women have reported medical abuse, including unconsented hysterectomies.

The entire system is rotten. theintercept.com/2020/10/27/ice…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Aaron Reichlin-Melnick

Aaron Reichlin-Melnick Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ReichlinMelnick

30 Oct
Kirstjen Nielsen perjured herself. Here's the exchange from December 2018, when she was under oath:

@RepJerryNadler: Are you doing anything that would reduce your capacity to process X number of people per day at the ports?
Nielsen: No sir.

@DHSOIG today says that was a lie.
The question from @RepJerryNadler to Nielsen asked about reducing CBP capacity "to process X number of people" per day, and @DHSOIG reveals that Nielsen not only knew that "X = 650," she personally signed off on those policies herself five months earlier.

oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/… In May 2018, DHS and CBP le...
Here is the full clip of Kirstjen Nielsen testifying under oath in December 2018 about metering at ports of entry.

I strongly encourage listening to this 90 second clip, then going back one tweet and reading what @DHSOIG found.

It seems clearly perjury.
c-span.org/video/?c491962…
Read 5 tweets
21 Oct
I read the status report. It’s:

- 283 children whose parents have not been found.
- 187 children whose parents have been found, but who have not been successfully contacted.
- 75 children whose parents have not been found, but telephonic outreach is expected to be successful.
The status report from today makes clear that this claim from Miles Taylor is completely wrong.

283 children remain whose parents, after “time-consuming and arduous on-the-ground searches,” cannot be found and for whom telephonic outreach is not expected be successful.
Setting aside that @MilesTaylorUSA misunderstood what today’s story was about, I want to talk about this a little more, though, because it reflects a narrative that people at DHS often used at the time reunification began—that many parents willingly gave up their kids.

Thoughts:
Read 12 tweets
20 Oct
NEW! The criminal bars to asylum proposed in December 2019 are finally here.

The rule will impose sweeping new asylum bans for people convicted of misdemeanor crimes as minor as using a fake ID—something millions of American college students do every day.
public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2020-23159.pdf
The new criminal bars to asylum, which include not only minor misdemeanor crimes, but even situations where an immigration judge "has reason to believe" someone committed domestic violence—even if never arrested or convicted—will go into effect 30 days from tomorrow: November 20.
DHS/EOIR acknowledge that this new asylum bar—based an immigration judge having "reason to believe" an applicant has ever committed domestic battery—doesn't even require an arrest.

Immigration attorneys better prepare for mini trials, and start exercising subpoena authority.
Read 6 tweets
19 Oct
It always amuses me how confidently @RMConservative talks about immigration law while displaying how little he actually knows about it.

This article is journalistic malpractice. It gets the facts wrong, the background wrong, the law wrong, and the legal questions wrong.
Let's start with the facts he got wrong. Horowitz claims Pereida was convicted of "stealing the identity of a citizen" to get a job in Iowa.

Except he wasn't. The job was in Nebraska (despite biz having Iowa in name) and he was convicted of *attempted* "criminal impersonation." Excerpt from Blaze article: "Mexican citizen Clemente PExcerpt from Eighth Circuit opinion: "Pereida pleaded n
Here's more of the sloppiness: Horowitz claims that "Even without stealing identity [sic], he came here illegally and should have no legal standing to remain in the country."

Except that's literally not how it works. For generations, Congress has created paths to avoid removal. Excerpt from Blaze piece: "Even without stealing identi
Read 5 tweets
10 Oct
! We just learned that after the Border Patrol “assisted” this woman, they took her to the hospital where her baby went into the NICU.

Then, hours after she gave birth, the Border Patrol threw her in a jail cell and are threatening to send her to Mexico without her baby—tonight!
Here’s more information about this developing situation.
We now have @mollymotoole’s story.

This woman had already been victimized by the Trump administration and sent back to Mexico under the Orwellian “Migrant Protection Protocols.”

Those have been indefinitely suspended since March. She was desperate. latimes.com/politics/story…
Read 4 tweets
24 Sep
Wolf is making things up again. Here's what @DHSOIG said in 2005 about why Congress created ICE.

"ICE was established not with a focus on supporting a particular mission but rather on building an institutional foundation large enough to justify a new organization." Image
The entire OIG analysis from 2005 is amazing. Here's what OIG offered as one official's theory for why ICE was created in the first place—interior immigration enforcement alone would never "attain bureaucratic critical mass," so they threw a bunch of other things into the pot. ImageImage
The 2005 OIG report is worth a read. It assessed whether CBP and ICE should be merged back into one immigration agency.

OIG said merger was "the optimal solution" with "almost universal" support among employees, most of whom used to work for INS. oig.dhs.gov/assets/Mgmt/OI… Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!