Starmer begins #PMQs by listing the five promises Johnson made in his foreword to the ministerial code, and asks how many have been kept. Turns out, none of them. Johnson blathers some bullshit.
Extraordinary really. Johnson says he makes no apology for standing by the woman just found guilty of bullying. Outrageously suggests Labour is attacking her because she’s been doing her job so well. In other words, bullying gets a free pass. #PMQs
Laugh out loud moment as the Speaker says he’ll decide what a reasonable remark is, not Johnson - and threatens to mute him. No love lost there.
Starmer working a very clever strategy here. The five ministerial promises were no bullying, harassment, leaking, wasting taxpayers’ money or conflicts of interest - and he’s now shown how Johnson has broken or tolerated every single one. #PMQs
‘Either the PM doesn’t know how much taxpayer’s money has been wasted or he doesn’t care. No-one’s knocking the private sector, the government’s knocking the taxpayer.’ Ouch. #PMQs
‘It’s the same old story. One rule for the British public, one rule for the prime minister and his friends.’ Expect to hear a lot more of this line. It nails every single fear about what the Tories are, and it’s devastating because it’s true. #PMQs
Starmer finished his questions on a high. ‘If you’ve got a hotline to ministers, you get a blank cheque. But if you’re on the frontline tackling Covid, you’re picking up the bill.’ This was his best performance in months. Johnson has no response. #PMQs
Johnson’s most telling response was calling the breaking of ministerial promises ‘trivia’. Says everything about his approach to both government and standards in public life. Just three and a half years to go.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Oh great. It’s #PMQs. Labour MP begins by asking PM to confirm he won’t cut the aid budget, as has been reported. Johnson responds by mentioning how ‘world-leading’ we are on solving the world’s problems, and refuses to rule out any such cut at all.
Starmer and Johnson trade barbs on devolution. ‘Greatest threat to the Union is the PM himself,’ says Starmer. ‘Taking back control has meant taking it from the Scottish people.’ Never a truer word spoken. #PMQs
Johnson bizarrely claims that Tony Blair never foresaw the ‘separatist’ threat. Would someone like to tell him that the SNP was in fact winning seats for decades before Blair became PM? #PMQs
Extraordinary moment at the start of #PMQs: Johnson refuses to support Starmer’s assertion that it’s not election candidates who decide which ballots must count. His moral and political cowardice knows no bounds.
Meanwhile he blathers some bullshit about not being responsible for the delay in acting or the lives that will be lost as a result. He’ll never change and we’ll all pay the price. #PMQs
Unbelievable. Johnson paves the way for extending lockdown by saying it’s the Commons which will decide - as though his thoughts and policies are a mere irrelevance. A naked and extravagant attempt to deflect responsibility even for him. #PMQs
Enjoy another week or two of relative summer calm. After that we’ve got the shitshow of school reopenings and the return of Brexit.
This, from @ShippersUnbound yesterday, illustrates the calamitous miscalculation circulating in Downing Street right now. They genuinely believe no-deal will unite the people against Brussels. They could not be more wrong.
The UK establishment has used EU as a scapegoat and whipping boy for 40 years to cover up British failure. That no longer works. Literally the point of Brexit is to go it alone. For the first time, there’ll be no-one else to blame but the ones who’ve always been to blame: us.
There has always been a movement that says we can’t bring down statues or rename streets because we have to own and confront our poisonous history. And we do. But that history and is legacy is all around us. It’s not going anywhere.
The history of the Empire is not going away. The English language in Africa and Asia is not going away. The legacy of slavery and centuries of white supremacy is not going away - at least not yet.
Some quick punches from Starmer. If Johnson is ‘taking direct control’, who on earth has been in control till now? Why hasn’t the PM replied to his confidential letter? And why has trust in the government fallen more dramatically and rapidly than any time in recent history? #PMQs
Meanwhile all Johnson can do is criticise Starmer’s tone. Undercurrent is that criticism or scrutiny of the government is somehow going against public mood - in other words, unpatriotic. You know the words to this one. It’s beyond contempt. #PMQs
Starmer points out that ONS has written to the Health Secretary complaining about misuse and manipulation of data. All Johnson can do is complain, literally, that Starmer is questioning him. #PMQs
Nice get-out from Johnson: a formal inquiry into Cummings would be a distraction. Too right it would. But not in the way he wants us to think.
I hope Johnson’s had an eye test, because this is a car crash
Johnson pleads in vain to move on. We know he wants to move on. He looks deeply shifty and uncomfortable. Hard not to think that something might really have changed.