Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi gave evidence on behalf of Ken Livingstone at his disciplinary hearing. Here are the quotes. You probably see the difficulties & the justification for removing her from @UKLabour
If not, you need education - speak to @JewishLabour.
She said:
"I was not
remotely offended & I didn’t know what the fuss was. I probably wouldn’t have put it that way but I have myself looked at the history. I’m aware of this very controversial historical record of Zionist leaders making approaches to leaders of the Nazi party, suggesting deals. And
in fact I’m sorry to say this but I’ve got sources here to back this up, that there was a coincidence of interest between the Zionist leadership – that’s not to say every Zionist of course – but between the Zionist leadership and the Nazi party, which wished to rid German Society
of Jews, because of their intense & visceral hatred of the Jewish people. And that coincides with what the Zionist movement intends."
Asked about Israel, “Yes, it is a racist endeavour obviously. To set up a Jewish State for Jews, that's racist I'm sorry. And there's nothing bad
about saying that. Just because Jews are involved, it doesn’t mean we have to pussyfoot around.”
Asked whether that was not a mainstream Jewish view, “That’s right because the Zionist movement has successfully occupied the minds of Jews worldwide since the Holocaust ... we're
now talking about a political position which has become embedded in people’s minds to the extent that fear is engendered deliberately. Look what Benjamin Netanyahu did when the Charlie Hebdo outrages occurred. He flies into France. He's delighted: 'Hooray! An antisemitic outrage.
We can claim it for ourselves. Jews of France you are not safe here. Come to Israel. It’s your home’”.
Asked whether comparing Zionism to Nazism was racist (as Chakrabarti said it was): "I do not think that equating or in any way comparing the actions of the Zionist state or
even aspects of the Zionist ideology with anything to do with the Nazi state is, of itself, opposed to Judaism, so it's not racist. There's got to be hatred. There's got to be motivation, which is "I'm out to get you as a Jew". ... And I'm sorry, I have asked people in the Labour
Party ‘Where are the Jews who are offended by these things?’ because I’ve not met them.”
-Ends-
@johnmcdonnellMP - you need to have a look at this. It’s not decent.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Simon Myerson QC

Simon Myerson QC Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SCynic1

4 Dec
1/4 While we're on JVL people and their defence of Ken Livingstone, this is @JonathanRosenh1:
On antisemitism from Corbynistas: "We don’t know if they are members of the Labour Party. We don’t even know if they are supporters of Jeremy Corbyn. If I was the Israeli government, I
would be running all sorts of false flag operations getting people to post – & they have hordes of them in Israel doing this sort of stuff on the internet – saying things which would then discredit Jeremy Corbyn."
Whilst appearing on @Presstvuk (the official arm of the Iranian
State) with Rev Stephen Sizer (ordered off social media by the Church of England after claiming that Jews were behind 9/11), “Many Jews are fearful & feel that the Labour Party is infected with antisemitism. That’s the result of the campaign by the Board of Deputies
Read 4 tweets
29 Oct
EHRC thread: 1/9
In terms of the debate on social media, the report is devastating. It demolishes every defence. It upholds the accuracy of Panorama and the complaints. It directly finds a failure of leadership.
Political interference is clear. There is no basis for asserting that this was the fault of individual employees. That is patently untrue. If Karie "I'm proud" Murphy is really proud then she is proud of this.
The Party did not take responsibility for the casual antisemitism of too many of its members on social media.
And this conduct IS antisemitism - making it clear that the sealioners and gaslighters with whom so many of us have dealt for so long are bad actors.
Read 9 tweets
11 Sep
1/16. Regrettably it appears that @barstandards has rejected both our analysis and our offer.
Analysis first: Our analysis was that pen and paper exams, whilst they might offer another chance, were ultimately unfair. The less well off you are, and the more employed you are,
the harder it is to find time to take exams. The longer the exams are delayed, the more work is required to repeat revision. We forcefully made the point that delay equalled injustice (as ever). It now appears that what @barstandards were telling us would be September will be/
October and December. Resists will not be until spring 2021.
On the plus side, we persuaded the BSB that everyone should be able to sit. Their initial view depended on an assessment of/
Read 16 tweets
6 Aug
As the battle against Corbyn & his followers is (almost) won - the polls show 94% of @UKLabour members are behind Starmer, the EHRC report will likely say the party was institutionally antisemitic & the Party will adopt its recommendations - the issue is how Jews deal with
1/8
the fight against antisemitism going forward.
It’s time to stop attacking each other for perceived lack of support, daring to dissent or - worst of all - being a convert. I have 5 suggestions:
1. Accept there isn’t only one answer to anything but the most basic questions.
2/8
Tolerate difference & dissent. If you disagree it doesn’t mean anyone else is wrong. Disagree on the issues. Point out you’re the vast majority. Critique the approach. But bringing in extraneous issues - gender, conversion, age, religion are a no-no. Some people hate Jews,
3/8
Read 8 tweets
8 Jun
@PhilR_R @Mendelpol I deleted my first reply, as I don’t want a personal argument.
The problem of abuse has been going on for at least 10 years. It should not take an article in the paper by somebody who’s not a victim to prompt action.
And it’s a misrepresentation to suggest this is prompt action.
@PhilR_R @Mendelpol For far too long, the community has been deaf to victims. The contrast between the praiseworthy treatment of black members of the community, & the victims of abuse cries out for explanation.
Pretending everything has been done quickly is an abuse of trust.
@PhilR_R @Mendelpol It places organisational reputation over individuals’ suffering. It is precisely what I warned against in the article.
I agree @BoardofDeputies might not be the right organisation. But that doesn’t free it from all responsibility.
Read 4 tweets
14 Apr
A number of key admissions stand out from the leaked report:
1 On any view, the party was mired in antisemitism. When @JVoiceLabour denied that fact, it was lying. How they could be defended by any member of the NEC is extraordinary.
2 The approach to dealing with antisemitism
was, as Panorama said, political. In its rather transparent effort to divert blame, the report makes clear the decision to bypass @JewishLabour was a political one, taken by politicians at the top. It was justified by a “need” to consult the “widest range” of organisations within
the community. That, of course, equates the tiny fraction of acquiescent Jews with the vast majority of the community. That was deliberate.
3 There is an extraordinary reliance on the religion of people making decisions. It appears the authors of the report believe a decision
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!