capitalism gets thrown around like an epithet these days. my brother didn't go to college, didn't have any family money, didn't have any social capital and comes from a historically oppressed group. still, he had an idea, started a business and sold it to a much larger company 1/
he's not larry page with it. he still needs to find new ideas, as he's only in his 40s. but in the space of about two years he was able to *transform* his life. he literally made something out of nothing. this is possible in the US. i don't think this could ever happen in france.
he was employing business school grads with MBAs. providing jobs.
Anyway, can’t prove a universal through a particular, and I realize there is deep injustice and exploitation and the floor is too low in the US compared to europe, but there is also tremendous capacity for uplift that we should hesitate to downplay or wish to do away with.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Is there anyone working on a kind of sociology of knowledge of wokeness?
For those asking: I simply mean an analysis or genealogy of the relationship between the constellation of ideas gathered under the umbrella of “wokeness”/“successor ideology” and the social contexts in which they’ve arisen. I don’t mean an argument for it against them.
Ask and you shall receive. This is getting at what I meant:
“Cancel culture is the product of this transposition of moral rhetoric from class conflict to cultural conflicts around ethnicity and race.”
Kendi makes sense when he says “Black people don’t exist biologically or behaviorally.” But then he admits they do exist “culturally.” And he loses me when he rejects the legitimacy of making any cultural comparisons at all since they imply hierarchy. 1/
@ 29:00:
Any researcher who asks about cultural deficiencies “must create a cultural standard to answer that question. And once that cultural standard is created, cultural hierarchy is created. And once that culture hierarchy is created, culturally racist ideas are created.” 2/
So the argument is that any cultural critiques are inherently illegitimate or even racist. Each cultire is as good or bad as the next.
This argument is not new but I’m not sure I’ve ever seen it gain such unquestioning mainstream and elite traction.
The hard left––not liberals, to be clear––is fundamentally childlike insofar as it fuels itself and its fury on a vision of some future state of purity that can by necessity never be achieved.
The very foundation of adulthood is the acceptance of compromise and imperfection.
In turn, it's true that the far right fuels itself on a childlike nostalgia for the past perfect states that can never be achieved and in fact never existed either.
Liberals are the genuine adults, yet liberalism is being devoured from the left and right flanks at the moment.
Anyway, interacting this evening with the social media account of the far-left journal @curaffairs was a lot like interacting with one of my children. Just pure detachment from real-world constraints and circumstances.
Earlier today I speculated that the course we’re on will likely see statues of Obama ripped down in the future. The political commentary magazine Current Affairs responds: “lol” obvi. Like it’s not even a question.