Islamists use White guilt about colonialism and Crusades. The West does have a lot to be guilty about. But the Left in the West has been shamed (petro $'ed) into becoming Islamic apologists, ignoring that Islam is equally a colonizing & invading force in North Africa or India.
Not to mention Persia, among the early ones to be overrun.
There is surprising little study of Islam as a colonizing force, much like there is very little study about English-language-based discrimination in India (while there are thousands of volumes about "caste"). That is the real imperialism—which controls narratives.
Here is one video:
In reality, all monotheism is colonialism. The two are intertwined. Monotheism is based on supremacy, supremacy of "their" god over all others. This inevitably leads to the destruction of other people's symbols, traditions, idols and values.
False, not only wealth, even human beings were carted off to Arab and Turkic lands and their harems were full of the spoils of slave trade. @BharadwajSpeaks had done a thread on loot of wealth one time I think.
@BharadwajSpeaks In fact, the insecure jealous "god" of monotheists has all the characteristics of Hiranyakashipu; a demonic force commanding that no one but him get worshipped. Would the actual "creator" by bothered?
Even Hitler's targeting of minorities—Jews and Roma—had a precedence in Islamic treatment of minorities as "zimmis." He forced them to wear yellow badges to identify themselves, a practice first used for minorities by Islamic Caliphs.
It's a very subtle point. But "democracy" is used to justify the power of the overbearing State, its control over people's lives and it monopoly for violence. But till consciousness rises alternatives, like communism or Saudi regimes, are worse.
Anyone who uses the following terms to "explain" India is deeply colonized. They are using memes fabricated by the British for subjugation and narrative control. Which memes:
1. Caste 2. Brahmanism 3. "Aryan" race/Aryan Invasion 4. "Adivasi"/"tribal" 5. "Dravidian" as a "race"
These terms simply did not exist in pre-colonial Indian conception or they were distorted to serve imperialism in colonial scholarship. Resist and reclaim the narrative.
The "theory" of the "Caste System" is based on a fervent belief in Black Magic. 😏
Usually a scientific theory would be discarded when evidence shows that it doesn't work. Because these memes are not based on scientific theories but on colonial projection of Eurocentric dogma, they forever mutate on evidence, can't be disproven.
Of course, the crack hackers today are the Russian and the Chinese. All their technical education is in Russian and Chinese—they learn much faster.
India has been lobotomized. This is touted as an "advantage" because, hey, we got a $3/hr call center jobs from one country.
I'd be willing to bet that any Indian govt system which is connected to the internet is in control of the Chinese. I hear our defense systems are safe because their old tech is not even linked up (luckily).
His argument—Germany, Japan etc are homogenous and have "started learning from us" and moving to English.
Delusional— with Japanese medium Japan has 10 Nobel Prizes in the last 10 years. They need to learn from India? 🤣
When will *we* learn talent prospers in mother tongue?
Argument 2—India is like Europe. I agree. Has he studied how Europe does Science? Every country has education in their own language to the highest levels.
In fact, inter-country migration in Europe for work is similar to inter-state migration in India.
The "savior complex" creates far more societal problems than it fixes. It is disconnected from from reality. It is an imposition from above.
It is based on the idea that people need to be "fixed" from above. It is the liberal version of the Christian sin & savior complex.
Meanwhile teen marriage is legal in the US and UK. In same US states one can marry as young as 14 with parental consent. Yet their NGOs pressure "third world" to raise marriage age, often criminalizing vast swathes of society.
"For their own good."
But this is in the very structure of Christianity. Women are the source of "original sin." There is the Father, the Son ... and the Holy Ghost . The mother is absent or turned into a "virgin", robbed of feminine power.
Please tell more about Mokosh. I'm very interested in how European pagan traditions were first subjugated by Christianity, and the subjugation of the feminine.
Khalistan is fuelled by a narrative war which began during British times—separation of Hindus and Sikhs. Pakistan built on it after 1971, with Congress' assistance.
J&K is a narrative war.
Force cannot fix narrative. Only counter-narrative can. Indian State is terrible at this.
Unfortunately narrative war is not part of BJP/RSS sanskara. But for India to rise they must invest in it, otherwise it will always be an uphill battle.
This requires serious investment. "Good work" alone won't do it.
For example, what kind of investment has India done in pro-actively countering Hindu-Sikh separation narrative or Islamic J&K narrative. "Secularism" is not narrative. The India narrative can only be constructed on a sanatan civilizational vision.