As this lefty debate has evolved, it's inevitably broken down to its roots--one faction wants to burn the party down bc things are moving too slow, one sees a way to build power within it, another is open to anything new that works.
But all ultimately share the same frustrations
Ultimately, this blow-up was somewhat inevitable after 2020 with Sanders failing to win the primary twice. A whole lot of people put their hopes in a revolution only to be stymied.
And now to be shut out of power entirely...well, yeah. Inevitable.
It is easy to be completely negative about this moment, but there are positive signs for the future: progressive ideas are popular and will continue to gain steam. Progressive numbers in the House are growing and the demographics favor a continuation of that trend.
Of course, a realistic view is that money is still extremely powerful and any effort progressives launch to challenge that power will be met with forceful pushback.
It's very clear we are going to miss our climate deadlines. Even if the left had won big in 2020, that was likely.
But that just means the fight is long. Internal division will defeat this movement faster than the establishment ever could.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Biden’s selection of Neera Tanden to head OMB is an early test for progressives in their dealings with the incoming administration. Tanden is vocally anti M4a and UBI and tied to Wall St and theocratic regimes, she backed SS cuts when it counted, and she hates the left.
There’s two options:
1) Join Republican senators in blocking her appointment and risk being labeled obstructionist.
2) Confirm her and try to work with a Biden administration that has already, by virtue of her nomination, shown its complete disregard for you.
Option 1 is scary and there will be a lot of handwringing in the press, but as the Obama administration showed with its deficit reduction focus 2 years after the economic meltdown, Democrats cave to that kind of pressure.
In no world should the Democrats listen to Kasich. Centrism failed hard in 2016 and was on track to fail hard again in 2020. Had it not been for COVID-19, Trump would have taken this in a walk. As is, conservative Dems down ballot got shellacked while progressives did well.
As is, Biden’s margins in key states were narrow and his win didn’t translate down-ballot, indicating tepid support. Dems have to deliver.
People don’t want less right now from their government. There is a historic public health crisis and a historic economic crisis. Now is the time for Dems to be bold.
Want to know how badly the Democrats fucked up 2020? Consider this:
The party helped Amy McGrath raise more than $88 million for her dud campaign.
$88 million is also the total amount the party raised to win back state legislative chambers ahead of 2021’s redistricting.
Not only did Democrats likely fail to flip a single state legislative chamber, they actually lost New Hampshire's house and senate.
Now, Republicans control 59 chambers nationally with trifectas (house, senate, governorship) in 23 states. Democrats have 37 and 15 respectively.
The damage is compounded by the fact Supreme Court precedent that partisan gerrymandering claims are non-justiciable and the fact that the Trump administration stopped the census counting early, which means we're dealing with less accurate numbers.
It is truly remarkable how many people on here viscerally reject the idea that our staggeringly unequal economy is in any way contributing to the rise of far-right extremism.
Luckily, you don't have to take my word for it (thread)
Here's a 2009 DHS report with a clear warning that "prolonged economic downturn...could create a fertile recruiting environment for rightwing extremists and even result in confrontations between such groups and government authorities..." fas.org/irp/eprint/rig…
Here's a 2008 report from the European Commission warning that "unfair competition for scarce resources or an absence of prospects for a good future" are paths to "militancy and terrorism." clingendael.org/sites/default/…